J oC u0 2r n/ a) 2l oD f +M .a +t e7 r/i aD l* s, C) 7h 9e m/ -i Es t( .r y) A
Page 4 of 6
DOI: 10.1039/D0TA01256D
:=SSX'D:A2D='
!"#$%&ꢀ'%()
H-+9+7(.E 7'2 8+-9/7(+. +8 '4D-+6/-S+. (.72-92D(/72)> 7',)
2/D(.E 7+ 7'2 '(E' )20267(F(74 +8 ꢀ +F2- ꢀA%.
'2 #dAd() D(88,)2 -280267/.62 )H267-/ Ya(E= 5?T!Z> ,07-/F(+027
H'+7+29())(+. )H267-/ Y#C5Z Ya(E= 5?U!Z> /.D 7'2(- D2-(F2D S/.D
7-,67,-2 Ya(E= 5?` ! Z ),EE2)7 7'/7 S+7' 7'2 -2D,67(F2 /.D
<(D/7(F2 /S(0(74 +8 6/7/04)7) 6/. S2 2.'/.62D /872- 6/-S+.
[
\
K
I= ꢀ'2.> c= P'/.E /.D ꢁ= M22> !ꢀ8#)%-!ꢀ01%$!ꢀA3ꢀ:;?U> FI
?TT\[A?TU?`=
0
V
: T
: @
5 =
&
I= M= M(,> Q= c,> "= Q= 5,.> Q= V,/.E> Q= a= Q, /.D O= P'/.E>
!8#)%-!ꢀ01%$!ꢀA3ꢀ:;:;> YI ?;[[A?;\@=
)
c= P'/.E> c= M(> I= P'/.E> $= m= 5,> N= Q/.E /.D V= != ^F2-(77> G=
+
M(,> "#)!ꢀ0.$$*'!3ꢀ:;?[> YI ?TUT:=
?; $= "2.E> ꢀ= M(,> Q= M(, /.D O= P'/.E> A'H%L!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ7')!ꢀGK!3
;?K> JY> ?\K;\A?\K?:=
D+H(.E> S2.28(7(.E 7'2 9,07(A20267-+. -2D,67(+. H-+62))=@[> U:AUT
:
"
+-2+F2-> 7'2 H'+7+0,9(.2)62.62 YCMZ D/7/ Ya(E= 5?[ ! Z
?
? ꢁ= P'/.E> Q= M(/.E> V= M(> c= P'/+> Q= ꢀ'2.> O= P'/.E> N= P', /.D
G= P2.E> "#'.ꢀD%))!3ꢀ:;?K> +ZI `UT[A`UU@=
(.D(6/72) 7'/7 7'2 H'+7+(.D,62D 6/--(2-) -26+9S(./7(+. ()
E-2/704 ),HH-2))2D /872- 7'2 D+H(.E +8 6/-S+.=UUAU[
?
: Q= c= C/.> Q= Q+,> 5= c(.> Q= M(> k= a,> P= ꢀ,(> Q= M= "2.> a= a= ꢀ/+>
5= V= Q, /.D k++D2.+,E'> G= O> !ꢀA$!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ4.5!3ꢀ:;?[> +FZI
T?:@AT?:K=
:
!$/&".6!$.
?
@ ꢀ= ꢀ+9277+> 3= p,-(X(> M= ꢀ'2.> p= "/2D/> &= ꢀ= M/,> != %)'(7/.(
%
. ),99/-4> W2 D29+.)7-/72D 6/-S+.AD+H2D %.
88(6(2.7 /.D D,-/S02 H'+7+6/7/04)7 8+- )4.7'2)(](.E ꢀ
'2-9/004A/))()72D H'+7+6/7/047(6 6+.F2-)(+. +8 ꢀ!
W'(6' W/72- () D(-26704 ,)2D /) '4D-+E2. )+,-62)= %. 7'2 /S)2.62
8 /.4 )/6-(8(6(/0 /E2.7) +- 6+6/7/04)7)> 7'2 H-+D,67(+. -/72 /.D
:
5
@
/) /.
/
.D "= 3+S2-7> !ꢀA$!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ4.5!3 :;?\> +@*I [T@[A[TT;=
T O= "= &/6X277> ^= k+92] /.D G= k= ꢀ'2.> "#)!ꢀ0#)#6!3ꢀ:;?K> >I
\?A@\`=
U O= P'/+> Q= V,/.E> I= M(,> Q= Q, /.D O= P'/.E> 45&!ꢀ01&'#ꢀ
1%$!3ꢀ:;:;> PFI :\A@T=
6/. S2 -2/6'2D 7+ :`=` e T=? f9+0 E ' /.D ?` I= k/+> Q= P'/.E> P= P'+,> a= ꢀ/(> c= P'/+> N= V,/.E> Q= M(> G=
2
V F(/ 7'2
: T
?
?
7
: :
AV !> (.
@
+
0
A? A?
)20267(F(74 +8 ꢀ
:
V
T
U;=: g= ?@ꢀ!
/.D I
! ()+7+H2 7-/6(.E 2<H2-(92.7) 6+.8(-9 7'/7
+-(E(./72 8-+9 ꢀ! /.D
:
:
P',> C= M(,> a= Q/.E> k= N/.E /.D c= O/+> !ꢀA$!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ4.5!3ꢀ
:;?[> +FZI U`U:AU`UU=
7
'2 6/-S+. /.D '4D-+E2. /7+9) +8 ꢀ
V
: T
:
V
:
!> -2)H267(F204= &'2 (. )(7, 2<H2-(92.7/0 /.D 7'2+-27(6/0 ?[ c= ꢀ,(> G= N/.E> O= M(,> 5= M(.E> 3= M+.E /.D Q= c(+.E> !ꢀA$!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ
4.5!3ꢀ:;?\> +@*I ?`U?TA?`U:;=
/67(F/7(+.> S,7 /0)+ D26-2/)2 ?\ "= k'+,))+,S> "= c(/> C= $= I,6'2).2> I= 52E/0 /.D k= ꢁ= !](.>
.2-E4 S/--(2-) +8 8+-9(.E '4D-+6/-S+. (.72-92D(/72) 8+- ꢀ
G'%-H2ꢀG'=&-.'!ꢀ45&!3ꢀ:;?K> +>I ??::A??T:=
= &'() W+-X +882-) .2W ?K P= G= N/.E> V= 5+.E> V= M(, /.D G= Q2> A'H%L!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ7')!ꢀGK!3ꢀ
-
2),07) -2F2/0 7'/7 D+H(.E 6/-S+. 6+,0D .+7 +.04 2.'/.62 W/72-
/D)+-H7(+.LD())+6(/7(+. /.D ꢀ!
:
2
: T
V >
7
',) -2),07(.E (. '(E' )20267(F(74 +8 ꢀ
V
: T
+
HH+-7,.(7(2) 7+ D2)(E. 6+.)7-,67(+.) +8 6/-S+.AD+H(.E
:;:;> I!%J ?;=?;;:L/.(2=:;?K;[TT@=
6'29(6/0) F(/ :; k= ꢀ'2.> k= %= $= N/72-'+,)2> 3= 5'(> G=P'/+> P= M(> M= P= N,> ꢀ=
H'+7+6/7/04)7) 8+- )4.7'2)(](.E F/0,2A/DD2D ꢀ
:
7
'2-9/004 /))()72D H'+7+6/7/047(6 6+.F2-)(+. +8 ꢀ!
:
AV
:
!=
V= &,.E /.D &= P'/.E> A'H%L!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ7')!ꢀGK!3 :;?K> JYI?[U:\A
[UU?=
? I= M= M(,> ꢀ= V= N/.E> Q= a= Q,> O= V= P'/+> N= ꢀ= N/.E> Q= V= I,
.D O= P'/.E> 01%$3ꢀ:;?K> JI @[`A@\K=
?
:
:
!$<&6/7.ꢀ!<ꢀ6$7)#).7
/
&'2 /,7'+-) D260/-2 .+ 6+9H27(.E 8(./.6(/0 (.72-2)7=
:: P= 5,.> $= &/0-2*/> V= &/+> G= &2<72-> "= ",'02-> G= 57-,.X /.D
G= ꢀ'2.> A'H%L!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ7')!ꢀGK!3 :;?\> JMI [`?;A[`:[=
:
:
@ 5= N/.E> O= Q= k,/. /.D c= N= M+,> !ꢀA$!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ4.5!3ꢀ:;?\>
@*> U;@[AU;T;=
A/V$!,&)80)()$7.
+
T c= Q,> P= Q/.E> O= m(,> 5= k,+> C= Q/.E> O= Q,> V= P'/.E> Q= P'/+>
N2 /6X.+W02DE2 7'2 8(./.6(/0 ),HH+-7 8-+9 7'2 $/7(+./0
/7,-/0 56(2.62 a+,.D/7(+. +8 ꢀ'(./ Y$+= :?\[?:;` /.D $+=
?T::?;TZ /.D 7'2 $/7,-/0 56(2.62 a+,.D/7(+. +8 &(/.*(. ꢀ(74
Y$+= ?[GꢀGmGꢀTT[;;Z=
c= Q/.E> O= V/. /.D P= M(,> A'H%L!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ7')!ꢀGK!3ꢀ:;?K> JYI
$
`
@:A`@`=
:
:
:
U c= V+.E> G= p(9> 5= a= 5'(> Q= P'/.E> ꢀ= G(.> Q= 5,.> 5= &+.E/4> G=
N,> Q= P'/.E /.D a= N/.E> "#)!ꢀ"#'.)%51'.6!3ꢀ:;?T> ZI `\:A
`
\`=
` Q= N/.E> P= P'/.E> M= P'/.E> P= M,+> G= 5'2.> V= M(.> G= M+.E> G=
'
!7).ꢀ%$8ꢀ#)<)#)$/).
ꢀ= 5= N,> c= a,> c= N/.E /.D ꢀ= M(> !ꢀA$!ꢀ01%$!ꢀ4.5!3ꢀ:;?\>
?
"= 56'-2(2-> a= Vn-+E,20> M= 572(2-> 5= ꢁ'9/D> G= 5= M,72-S/6'2->
+
@*I ?TUKUA?TUK\=
"
= &= "/42-> G= M,+ /.D "= k-o7]20> "#)!ꢀG'%-H23 :;?[> >I
[;\[=
"= "/-)]2W)X(> 5= ꢀ/+> G= Q, /.D "= G/-+.(26> 8#)%-!ꢀI.-&J!3ꢀ
;?U> >I :`?A:[\=
G= 3/.> "= G/-+.(26 /.D 5= P= m(/+> AK=!ꢀ 8#)%-!ꢀ :;?\> F*I
[;T`TK=
:
:
:
[ ꢀ= M(,> O= ꢀ= ꢀ+0q.> "= P(2)/6X> C= ꢁ= 5(0F2- /.D I= k= $+62-/>
5&%'5%3 :;?`> FJ>I ?:?;=
\ m= M,> Q= Q,> m= "/> O= ꢀ'2. /.D V= P'/.E>ꢀAK=!ꢀ8#)%-!3 :;?`>
YI ?K?[A?K@@=
?
4
:
@
:
>
K M= P'+.E> a= Q,> Q= ꢁ.> Q= P'/+> Q= 5,.> P= M(> &= M(.> Q= M(.> c= m(>
Q= I/(> M= k,> G= V,> 5= G(.> m= 5'2. /.D V= N/.E> "#)*-%3ꢀ:;?`>
JFYI \TA\[=
?
T
U
k= ꢁ= !](.> AK=!ꢀ8#)%-!ꢀ:;?U> >MI ?KU[A?K`@=
I= O= O,-X)> 5= I/F()> 3= N= M/9S> c= M(,> 3= 3= 3+D-(E,2)> $= C=
M(4/./E2> Q= 5,.> ꢀ= ^= N2S)72-> G= V= I206/9H /.D ^= &= C/H()'>
@
@
; c= P',> 5= G(/.E> ꢀ= M(> c= ꢀ'2. /.D ꢀ= Q/.E> 7'KꢀG'H!ꢀ01%$!ꢀM%(!3ꢀ
:
;?@> J>I ?T@``A?T@[U=
01%$!ꢀ0.$$*'!3ꢀ:;?\> J@I @\?KA@\::=
? c= O= P'/+> G= P= M(> C= &(/.> M= Q= N/.E> c= a= M(> 5= a= M(.> c= N=
`
p= M(> O= C2.E /.D &= C2.E> A04ꢀ0#)#6!3ꢀ:;?`> PI [T\UA[U:[[=
k,+ /.D P= "= M(,> A04ꢀ0#)#6!3ꢀ:;?K> ZI @;?[A@;:U=
@
B
!ꢀ"#$%=> :;?:> **> ?A@
&'() *+,-./0 () 1 &'2 3+4/0 5+6(274 +8 ꢀ'29()7-4 :;<<
C02/)2 D+ .+7 /D*,)7 9/-E(.)