Photolytic Cleavage of 1-(2-Nitrophenyl)ethyl Ethers
A R T I C L E S
3
ATP. It is reasonable to assume that the activation barrier for
From these data it appears reasonable in the methyl-
substituted series, where the initial nitronic acid 14 is of
substantially weaker acidity than the corresponding species that
lacks the R-methyl group, that the rearrangement of 14 that leads
directly to the hemiacetal 11 could be in competition with the
alternative of ionization to the aci-nitro anion 15. Once
ionization has occurred, the aci-nitro anion will be kinetically
trapped, with its decay controlled by the second-order rate
constant for reprotonation. The protonation step is more likely
to take place on the less-hindered oxygen to give 16, followed
by cyclization to 17. For the nitronic acid of higher acidity
formed initially in the nonmethylated series, ionization is likely
to compete more effectively with the direct rearrangement path,
so the reaction proceeds entirely (subject to the limits of
detectability) via the “conventional” benzisoxazoline route.
The discussion above gives a broad rationale for the reactivity
of the compounds investigated here. Further detailed studies
beyond the capability of our present instrumentation will be
required to delineate details of individual steps. The present work
however does highlight the likely importance of differing
acidities of structurally diverse nitronic acids that has not
previously been considered.
the direct 14 f 11 path in solution is no higher than that
measured from the Arrhenius plot for the overall process 15 f
1, i.e., that both pathways have a low barrier in aqueous
solution.
To rationalize the occurrence of the two competing pathways
in the overall reaction of 6-9 (Scheme 2) and the contrary
position with 10, which appears to react only by a single
pathway (the non-methyl analogue of the route via 16 and 17),
it was necessary to consider the additional factor of flux through
1
4
b
different intermediates. The study by Schw o¨ rer and Wirz
explains the kinetics of acid-catalyzed decay of aci-nitro anions
of the type considered here, i.e., that cyclization to a benzisox-
azoline such as 17 requires prior protonation of the aci-nitro
anion and is therefore controlled by the pK of this species. The
decay of 15 is considerably faster than that of its nonmethylated
analogue, which indicates that 15 is the stronger base of the
two compounds. The underlying reasons for this difference in
basicity and its consequences are discussed below.
aci-Nitro anions of type 15 are expected to be stronger bases
than the corresponding species lacking the R-methyl substituent,
because of the combined actions of the inductive effect of the
methyl group and poorer solvation of the more substituted
system. A stereoelectronic factor probably also operates to
destabilize 15 relative to its nonmethylated analogue. Our gas-
phase PM3 calculations showed a dihedral angle between the
exocyclic C-C and C-N bonds in 15 of 42.6° for the
Z-configuration shown (calculated for the species derived from
Conclusions
The overall results of this study and the proposal outlined
above to explain the kinetic records of Figure 2 obtained upon
flash photolysis of 9 have general implications for the field of
caged compounds. A particularly significant point for their use
in time-resolved biological studies is that reliance solely on aci-
nitro decay rates can be misleading as an indicator of the rate
of product release. Our data demonstrate that the discrepancy
can in some cases be very large and reinforce the value of
complementary time-resolved infrared measurements to study
this photochemistry. The elegant work by Toscano and col-
6
with its carboxylate group in an ionized state; note that
calculations for the E-configuration gave a similar dihedral
angle). By contrast in the non-methyl analogue of 15, where
the alkoxy substituent has a preferred E-configuration that
minimizes steric crowding (i.e., structure 22), this dihedral angle
1
9
was calculated to be 2.5° (cf. calculations by Dunkin et al.
for different isomers of the nitronic acid derived from 2-ni-
trobenzyl methyl ether, which consistently show a planar
conformation for the E-configuration but twisting of ∼30° for
the Z-configuration). To test the effects of this twisting,
semiempirical calculations that include solvation effects were
24
leagues on photochemistry of diazeniumdiolates further shows
the value of the technique in unraveling mechanistic details of
dark reactions triggered by photolysis. Indeed, it is noteworthy
that they were also able to detect two competing mechanistic
pathways in their study.
The duality of mechanism uncovered in our work is interest-
ing, as it requires competition between very rapid alternative
pathways. From the discussion presented here, this partition
appears to be controlled by the pKa of the initially formed
nitronic acid, but it is of interest that the participation of dual
pathways has not previously been observed in o-nitrobenzyl
photocleavage reactions. In cases such as caged ATP, it seems
likely that the presence of an anionic side chain very near the
nitro group would facilitate ionization of the initial nitronic acid
22,23
carried out using the AMSOL program.
Solvation energies
were calculated for the deprotonation reaction of the respective
nitronic acid isomers derived from 6 and 10, respectively, to
their corresponding aci-nitro anions. These energy differences
calculated for the deprotonation reaction (14 f 15) showed that
the aci-nitro anion derived from 10 is 15 kJ mol better
stabilized than the anion from 6, which corresponds to a
difference of at least 2.6 pKa units between the two nitronic
acids; that is, the nitronic acid derived from 10 is significantly
more acidic than that derived from 6 (and by extension from
-
1
(analogous to 14), thereby channeling the reaction via the slower
7
-9).
aci-nitro path. Nevertheless, we recognize that our analysis
leaves questions open. For example, the fact that the partitioning
between fast and slow processes for photolysis of 6-9 is
independent of pH (as judged by the pH-invariant amplitude of
the 406 nm transients for 9) suggests that additional consider-
ations may be relevant, in particular the extent to which
partitioning of 14 is influenced by reaction from a vibrationally
excited state. The factors that promote formation of a hemiacetal
(
22) Hawkins, G. D.; Giesen, D. J.; Lynch, G. C.; Chambers, C. C.; Rossi, I.;
Storer, J. W.; Li, J.; Zhu, T.; Rinaldi, D.; Liotard, D. A.; Cramer, C. J.;
Truhlar, D. G. AMSOL version 6.5.3; University of Minnesota: Min-
neapolis, 1997.
(24) Srinivasan, A.; Kebede, N.; Saavedra, J. E.; Nikolaitchik, A. V.; Brady,
D. A.; Yourd, E.; Davies, K. M.; Keefer, L. K.; Toscano, J. P. J. Am.
Chem. Soc. 2001, 123, 5465.
(
23) Cramer, C. J.; Truhlar, D. G. J. Comput. Chem. 1992, 13, 1089.
J. AM. CHEM. SOC.
9
VOL. 125, NO. 28, 2003 8553