100
G.D. Yadav, P.M. Paranjape / Journal of Fluorine Chemistry 126 (2005) 99–106
PTC). The aqueous phase promoted reactions can thus be
totally suppressed and better selectivities obtained. While
L–L PTC involves heterogeneous reaction between two
reagents located in an aqueous, and an organic phase, S–L
PTC involves reaction of an anionic reagent in a solid phase
(
usually a salt) with a reactant located in a continuous
organic phase. Yadav and Sharma [5] proposed the first
mechanistic and kinetic model of solid–liquid PTC followed
by Naik and Doraiswamy [6]. We have carried out the
detailed mechanistic and modeling studies for industrially
important reactions under S–L PTC conditions [7,8]. The
role of small amounts of water, the so-called omega phase, in
S–L PTC was analysed in our earlier work [9] including
others [2–4] and a rigorous model of S–L PTC with omega
phase has been established [9].
+
Scheme 1. Complex of PEG with metal cation K .
ꢀ
the solid and the transport of another nucleophile [F ] into
the organic phase. In the current case, the S–L PTC
mechanistic description is the implication that the reaction
takes place in anhydrous condition, since both solid and
liquid phases were dry. So the formation of the omega phase
was discounted. There are two types of mechanisms for S–L
PTC, the homogeneous solubilization mechanism of Yadav
and Sharma [5] and heterogeneous solubilization of Naik
and Doraiswamy [6]. In the heterogeneous solubilization,
the particles are totally insoluble and the catalyst get
adsorbed on to the solid whereas in the case of homogeneous
solubilization model, the particles are sparingly soluble in
the organic phase and the particle solubility is augmented by
the phase transfer agent [PEG]. The particle size goes on
decreasing with time due to the reaction in the organic phase.
2
. Results and discussion
The reaction scheme is given by
+
ꢀ
Preliminary experiments established that the reaction was
Depending on the relative rate of transfer of [PEG K F ] in
the organic film next to the solid and the reaction of the
species, four different regimes can be identified just like the
L–L PTC [13]. These are shown in Fig. 1 and the importance
of various steps is delineated in the captions.
facile at 30 8C. To understand the enhanced rates of reaction
under these conditions, it was thought worthwhile to study
the mechanism and kinetics of this reaction. Since a typical
experiment produced 90% conversion of p-toluenesulfonyl
chloride, with 100% selectivity to the fluoride, a further
insight was obtained by studying the effect of various
parameters on the rates of reaction.
Preliminary experiments suggested that the homoge-
neous solubilization model illustrated by the S 2 type of
N
reaction of the substrate RX with the nucleophile Y of the
solid reactant MY.
The overall reaction is:
2
.1. Mechanism and kinetic model
k obs
RX
ðorgÞ
þ MYðsÞ þ PEGðorgÞ ꢀ! RYðorgÞ þ MXðsÞ
Polyethylene oxide chains form complexes with cations,
much like crown ethers, and these complexes cause the
anion to be transferred into the organic phase and to be
activated [10]. Complexation of solid alkali metal salts by
PEG is strongly dependent on both the anion and the cation
of the salt [11]. The phase transfer catalytic efficiencies of
polyethylene glycols were proven and analysed [12]. It was
observed that best catalytic efficiencies were obtained by
using medium chain length PEG [n = 7–9].
þ PEGðorgÞ
(1)
The solid reactant is in equilibrium with its solution in the
organic phase. This is the solubility of KF in the solvent in
the presence of the catalyst. It was obtained by taking a large
and known amount of KF in the solvent and catalyst and
stirring for 1 h and then filtering the solution under vacuum
and weighing the dry solids again. It was obtained
ꢀ5
ꢀ3
The first step of the reaction involves the complexation of
+
PEG with metal cation [K ] (Scheme 1) and forms [PEG
2.62 Â 10 mol cm . In the absence of the catalyst the
solubility was less
+
ꢀ
K F ], which is organophilic and is freely transported to the
bulk organic phase. There could be a resistance associated
with the transfer of this complex across the liquid film next
to solid–liquid interface. The second step involves the
K2
þ
ꢀ
½MY Ð ½M Y
(2)
s
ðorgÞ
This represents saturation solubility of the solid in organic
liquid.
+
ꢀ
reaction of the [PEG K F ] with the reactant [RX] located in
the organic phase. There are several possibilities by which
this reaction can occur. Finally the third step involves the
+
PEG forms the complex with metal cation M
K3
þ
ꢀ
þ
ꢀ
ꢀ
½PEGðorgÞ þ ½M Y
Ð ½PEG M Y
(3)
ðorgÞ
ðorgÞ
transport of the co-product anion [X ], the leaving group to