B. Ay et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 18 (2008) 4038–4043
4041
Table 1
were measured as Böhringer Light Units (BLU in Table 2). In all
cases, we could measure different signal intensities that approxi-
mately correspond to peptide yields. Based on these results, for
automated SPOT synthesis we recommend using a HMPB linker if
proline is the C-terminal amino acid (HMPB is 2-fold more expen-
sive than HMPA).
To assess the quality of SPOT synthesized peptides using the
HMPA-linker approach, we used the peptide VTEHDTLLY, known
as a CMV-derived CD8 T-cell epitope (VPAP protein), as a model.
T-cell stimulation by this peptide was determined by flow
cytometry (detailed protocol is given in Supplementary mate-
rial). First, the peptide sequence VTEHDTLLY was synthesized
by conventional Fmoc-chemistry on resin and purified by HPLC.
Then the same peptide sequence was synthesized by our novel
HMPA-linker-aided SPOT technology. Subsequently, both pep-
tides were tested in parallel for T-cell stimulation measured by
flow cytometry.
Characterization of model peptides by ESI mass spectrometry and analytical HPLC
Sequences
Expected [M] Measured [M+H+]+ Puritya (%) Byproductsb
WKL-A
WKL-C
WKL-D
WKL-E
WKL-F
WKL-G
WKL-H
WKL-I
516.30
548.28
560.29
574.30
592.33
502.28
582.32
558.34
573.35
558.34
576.30
559.30
573.32
601.36
532.29
546.31
544.33
631.34
608.32
1269.62
517.28
549.22
561.24
575.22
593.27
503.26
583.28
559.28
574.28
559.27
577.28
560.29
574.29
602.35
533.22
547.29
545.28
632.32
609.30
1270.57
1547.83
1366.79
>95
80
<1
15
<1
n.d.
<1
<1
n.d.
<1
n.d.
<1
10
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
<1
<1
n.d.
<1
>95
>95
>95
>95
>95
>95
>95
>95
65
WKL-K
WKL-L
WKL-M
WKL-N
WKL-Q
WKL-R
WKL-S
WKL-T
WKL-V
WKL-W
WKL-Y
APINSNPPNTFV
>95
80
>95
>95
>95
>95
80
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) were obtained
from CMV (AD169) sero-positive healthy donors (HLA 0101*).
The PBMC assay (5 million cells, stimulated overnight) was per-
formed as described previously4 using a peptide concentration of
90
70
n.d.
n.d.
n.d.
WVYFPPQYAYLT 1546.74
YSQLAKLGINPY
79
1365.71
68
1
lg/ml. A positive signal corresponds to CD8 and interferon
c
a
Purities were determined by HPLC peak area integration.
Byproducts represented C-terminal elongations and/or oxidation of cysteine/
(INF ) signals over a threshold of 0.03% of the total CD8 T-cells.
c
b
Figure 4 presents the stimulation effect of both synthesized pep-
tides (Fig. 4C and D) compared to the controls, DMSO (as a sol-
vent, Fig. 4A), and HMPA (as a potential impurity, Fig. 4B).
Neither control had any impact on T-cells (both signals below
<0.03%). Both the peptide prepared by standard resin-based
Fmoc-chemistry (Fig. 4C) and the peptide synthesized according
to the HMPA-linker-aided SPOT technology (Fig. 4D) resulted in
high T-cell stimulation. Furthermore, the stimulation values of
0.270% and 0.210% for these peptides are within the same range,
thus directly validating our synthesis strategy.
Taken together, using both the hydroxymethylphenoxy derived
linkers and the automated synthesizer, it is now possible to gener-
ate huge sets of soluble peptides without restriction, in the upper
microgram range (approximately 5000 peptides) within one week,
for example, for screening CD8 T-cell epitopes. This represents a
time- and cost-saving advantage to the conventional large-scale
SPPS.
methionine; n.d., not detectable.
Such a side reaction was previously described as a problem during
CDI/CDT activation.14
In addition, these results could be reproduced with three differ-
ent, randomly chosen 12-mer peptide sequences, whose purities
are also >65% (Fig. 2B and Table 1) and many other sequences (data
not shown).
Synthesis of the WKL-P sequence turned out to be more compli-
cated due to the well-known formation of diketopiperazine. The
extent of this side reaction is generally limited, but increases mark-
edly when the cis-conformation of the peptide bond is favored, for
example, in peptides with a C-terminal proline.21,22
To prevent diketopiperazine formation we analyzed another
acid-cleavable linker: 4-(4-hydroxymethyl-3-methoxyphenoxy)-
butyric acid (HMPB). First, we determined the best activation re-
agent, which proved to be 1.1 equiv of EEDQ for HMPB, just as
for HMPA.
Thereafter, we synthesized the sequences WKL-G (as a control),
KDT-P (the protected T should avoid cleavage), and WKL-P. By
measuring the Fmoc-piperidine adducts of the first C-terminal
amino acid, we could follow the coupling efficiencies of the first
amino acid on the linker (data not shown). MS measurements re-
vealed the expected mass for WKL-G and KDT-P (although peak
intensities were very low) using both linkers. The mass peak of
WKL-P could only be detected using HMPB.
Nevertheless, there should still be enough peptide for a biolog-
ical screen. To prove this hypothesis, we synthesized a His-tag on
the three sequences using SPOT synthesis. The cleaved peptides
were then printed on a solid support (e.g., PVDF-membrane) and
detected by antibody incubation (Fig. 3). The signal intensities
Here, we demonstrate in detail that introducing the HMPA lin-
ker during the SPOT synthesis procedure, combined with an opti-
mized cleavage/washing procedure, results in peptides with
authentic C-termini without racemization or oligomerization of
the C-terminal amino acid, and with excellent purity. For peptides
with proline as C-terminal amino acid, we advise using HMPB to
Table 2
Characterization of proline sequences in comparison to glycine sequences
Linker
Seq.
Tag
Massexp.
Massfound
BLU
HMPA
HMPA
HMPB
HMPB
HMPA
HMPA
HMPB
HMPB
HMPA
HMPA
HMPB
HMPB
WKL-P
WKL-P
WKL-P
WKL-P
KDT-P
KDT-P
KDT-P
KDT-P
WKL-G
WKL-G
WKL-G
WKL-G
—
542.3
1227.6
542.3
1227.6
459.2
1144.5
459.2
1144.5
502.3
—
—
HHHHH
—
HHHHH
—
HHHHH
—
HHHHH
—
16,111
543.31
410.22**
460.22
382.53**
460.23
573.30*
503.21
594.8*
503.28
594.8*
73,588
29,574
171,811
617,774
1,455,500
HHHHH
—
HHHHH
1187.6
502.3
1187.6
Massexp., expected mass; Massfound, measured mass using ESI mass spectrometry
[M+H+]+; BLU, Boehringer Light Units detected by blot analysis and measured using
LuniImiger.
Figure 3. Test for biological activity. His-tagged peptides as listed in Table 2 were
spotted on PFDV-membranes and detected using anti-polyHis/anti-mouse-HRP
antibodies. (For details see Supplementary material.)
*
[M+2H+]++
.
[M+3H+]+++
.
**