Hilt and Hengst
SCHEME 1
SCHEME 2
Results and Discussion
In an attempt to apply phosphorus-containing starting materi-
als to the arsenal of building blocks suitable for cobalt-catalyzed
Diels-Alder reactions, we investigated alkynylphosphines5 and
propargylic phosphonium salts as well as longer chained alkyne-
functionalized phosphonium salts as dienophiles in the cobalt-
catalyzed cycloaddition process.
First, we investigated the use of an alkynylphosphine deriva-
tive (1) in the cobalt-catalyzed Diels-Alder reaction with a
simple symmetrical 1,3-diene such as 2,3-dimethyl-1,3-butadiene
(Scheme 1).
recrystallization, filtration, or precipitation. In addition, because
of the presence of paramagnetic cobalt catalyst components in
the reaction mixture the conversion could not be determined
by means of 31P NMR directly from the reaction mixture.
Therefore, all further investigations focused on the one-pot
cobalt-catalyzed Diels-Alder/Wittig olefination reaction se-
quence without any isolation of the air-sensitive dihydroaromatic
intermediates. The reaction products formed by this reaction
sequence were furthermore oxidized by the addition of DDQ
to generate the styrene (R ) aliphatic) or stilbene (R ) aromatic)
type products 6 which were then detectable and could be isolated
and characterized. Consequently, we report herein a sequential
three-step conversion which was performed without the iso-
lation of the dihydroaromatic intermediates of type 4 and 5 in
terms of a one-pot process. However, separation of the organic
intermediates of type 5 by simple filtration from the cobalt
catalyst mixture and its inorganic components was feasible
and led to the isolated dihydroaromatic styrene or stilbene
intermediates.
Unfortunately, we have not been able to identify an appropri-
ate cobalt catalyst system which is able to convert starting
materials of type 1 into a dihydroaromatic phosphine derivative
2. The low conversion of the alkynylphosphine 1 is most likely
based on a competitive complexation of the phosphorus donor
functionality versus the alkynyl moiety. The stronger Co-P
coordination of starting material 1 blocks free coordination sites
at the cobalt center so that the coordination of the alkyne or
the 1,3-diene is less favorable. These results are also in
accordance with previous observations namely that the addition
of excess phosphine ligand reduces the reactivity of the cobalt
catalyst system considerably. Therefore, the complexation of a
large excess of the starting material results in an efficient
retardation of activity of the cobalt catalyst. Even if the catalysts
were applied in up to 50 mol % the desired products will not
be obtained.6
Nevertheless, the use of propargylic phosphonium salts, such
as 3, was performed because in this type of starting material
the phosphorus does not behave as a donor ligand anymore. In
addition, this type of transformation seems to be of considerably
higher synthetic value in terms of the possibilities implied in
the allylic phosponium salt for further carbon-carbon bond
formation processes. While the follow-up chemistry of cycload-
ducts of type 2 is rather limited, the cycloadduct of type 4 should
allow a sequential Diels-Alder/Wittig reaction cascade. The
proposed cobalt-catalyzed Diels-Alder reaction of a propargylic
phosphonium salt such as 3 (Scheme 2) generates a new kind
of an allylic-type phosphonium salt 4 with a dihydroaromatic
subunit next to the acidic CH-protons suitable for an in situ
Wittig olefination with carbonyl compounds such as aldehydes.
If propargylic phosphonium salts such as 3 are brought to
reaction in a cobalt-catalyzed Diels-Alder reaction with 1,3-
dienes, a systematic problem arises. Not only the starting
materials but also the proposed dihydroaromatic intermediates
4 are saltlike intermediates. Therefore, the isolation of phos-
phonium salt 4 from all the other cobalt and zinc inorganic-
type ingredients in the reaction mixture is very tedious. In fact,
the phosphonium salt 4 could not be obtained in pure form by
The addition of a base and an aldehyde converted the
dihydroaromatic and allylic type phosphonium salts 4 into the
organic products 5 via the Wittig olefination reaction which
could then be detected by GC or GCMS analysis. Therefore, in
a series of experiments the reaction time and the cobalt catalyst
loading for the cobalt-catalyzed Diels-Alder reactions were
optimized using anisaldehyde for the Wittig olefination reaction.
The best results were obtained for a protocol in which 10-20
mol % of the catalyst was used in the cobalt-catalyzed Diels-
Alder reaction, and the mixture was stirred for 0.5 h at room
temperature after which the characteristic color change from
green toward a deep brown was observed. Then the base and
the aldehyde for the Wittig olefination reaction were added.
After further 1-2 h of stirring at ambient temperatures, the
dihydroaromatic product 5 could be detected and the conversion
estimated by GC and GCMS. The dihydroaromatic products
were obtained by simple filtration over a small amount of silica,
evaporation of the solvent before further oxidation by DDQ in
benzene or toluene to generate the corresponding aromatic
products 6. Without this simple filtration of the dihydroaromatic
intermediates from the cobalt-catalyst mixture the yields of
the desired products 6 were somewhat diminished if the DDQ
oxidation was performed in a straightforward one-pot reaction.
The results of the Diels-Alder-Wittig reaction-DDQ oxida-
tion sequences are summarized in Table 1.
(4) For leading references, see: (a) Hilt, G.; Galbiati, F. Org. Lett. 2006,
8, 2195. (b) Hilt, G.; Galbiati, F.; Harms, K. Synthesis 2006, 3575. (c) Hilt,
G.; Hess, W.; Schmidt, F. Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2005, 2526. (d) Hilt, G.;
Lu¨ers, S.; Smolko, K. I. Org. Lett. 2005, 7, 251. (e) Hilt, G.; Korn, T. J.;
Smolko, K. I. Synlett 2003, 241.
(5) (a) Ashburn, B. O.; Carter, R. G. Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 2006, 45,
6737. (b) Ashburn, B. O.; Carter, R. G.; Lakharov, L. N. J. Am. Chem.
Soc. 2007, 129, 9109.
The variation of the base gave rather disappointing results.
If sodium hydride, sodium amide, or n-butyllithium was used
as a base, only traces of the product were formed whereas for
(6) In contrast, higher catalyst loadings in the case of sulfur-functionalized
alkynes led to the desired conversions. See ref 3f.
7338 J. Org. Chem., Vol. 72, No. 19, 2007