Organic Letters
Letter
Scheme 1. Synthesis of (+)-Septicine (1)
veratraldehyde. Azetidinone 10 served as our divergent
intermediate and was synthesized from glutamic acid according
to Seebachs’s procedure.51 Both reagents were transformed
into 3-piperidinone 11 using our developed Ni-catalyzed (4 +
2)-cycloaddition procedure. Compound 11 has also been
previously synthesized using our developed in situ generated
catalyst system.50 The stereo information on azetidinone 10
was retained during this transformation (97:3 er, Scheme 1).
Piperidinone 11 was reduced under Luche conditions to form
the alcohol. Subsequent deprotection using Pd/C and ester
aminolysis using triazabicyclodecene (TBD) furnished the
cyclized alcohol 12. Dehydroxylation using Et3SiH and
reduction of the amide with LiAlH4 provided (+)-septicine
(1) in 12 steps and 8.2% overall yield (Scheme 1).
Scheme 2. Proposed Mechanism of Cycloaddition
It is worth mentioning that the hydroxy group at C14 is
desired for high anticarcinogenic activity.36,52 Moreover, the
additional polarity was proposed to reduce CNS toxicity by
reducing transition into the blood−brain barrier.22 Several
syntheses were since designed to include functionalizations at
C14.33,35,36 However, inclusion of this functional group leads
to increased sensitivity to acids, and we noticed partial
racemization at C13a of ketone 11 during the Luche reduction,
when HCl was used during workup. Similar instabilities have
previously been observed.53,54 We therefore recommend the
use of mild acids, such as NH4Cl, to avoid acid catalyzed
epimerization.
A key element to expand our approach to indolizidine
alkaloids with different aryl substituents, such as (+)-ipalbidine
and (+)-seco-antofine, is the regiocontrolled cycloaddition of
unsymmetrical alkynes into the Csp3−Csp2 bond of azetidinone
10. We previously observed regiocontrol in Ni-catalyzed
cycloadditions with unsymmetrical alkynes where the larger
group was distal to the carbonyl carbon (C, Scheme 2) unless
silyl or stannyl substituted alkynes were employed. In these
cases, the larger silyl and stannyl substituents are adjacent to
the carbonyl carbon in the product (F, Scheme 2). Though we
originally proposed a mechanism that involved minimizing
steric interactions in an initial oxidative addition between the
alkyne and the azetidinone carbon and subsequent β-carbon-
elimination (red pathway, Scheme 2), computational studies
and the ligand (intermediate H) also contributes to the
regioselectivity. However, silyl and stannyl substituents
increase the electron density of the alkyne carbons resulting
in an alkyne insertion where the alkyne acts as nucleophile to
attack the electron-deficient carbonyl carbon and inserts into
the other Ni−C bond, namely the Ni−C(O) bond, to form
metallacycle E via intermediate G2.
With this in mind, we used both steric and electronic factors
to our advantage to develop a regioselective synthesis of
(+)-ipalbidine and (+)-seco-antofine. Ni-catalyzed (4 + 2)
cycloaddition of alkyne 14 and azetidinone 10 yielded desired
piperidinone 15 with high regioselectivity (10:1 rr). The
1
regioselectivity was analyzed by H NMR spectroscopy using
suggest a mechanism involving oxidative addition of the Csp3
−
the crude reaction mixture, and the desired regioisomer was
supported by 2D NOE correlation. Importantly, a lower
reaction temperature was necessary to avoid alkyne trimeriza-
tion.
In a similar approach to (+)-septicine, Luche reduction of
piperidinone 15 to alcohol 16 and subsequent deprotection
and cyclization and deoxygenation afforded intermediate 18.
Finally, demethylation using BBr3 yielded (+)-ipalbidine (3)
in 8.4% total yield (Scheme 3A).
Csp2 bond of azetidinone alone (blue pathway, Scheme 2)
rather than oxidative coupling with the alkyne.55 The
regioselectivity was then determined by the alkyne insertion
(G1 vs G2, Scheme 2) and, furthermore, the alkyne either
acted as an electrophile or a nucleophile. When the alkynes
possess only alkyl or aryl substituents, the alkyne acts as an
electrophile in the insertion step, and the more nucleophilic
Ni−Csp3 carbon forms a bond with the more electrophilic
carbon (i.e., the aryl substituted carbon in unsymmetrical
alkyl/aryl alkynes) to form metallacycle H via intermediate G1.
Minimizing steric interactions between the alkyne substituent
In an attempt to synthesize (+)-seco-antofine, we utilized
alkyne 19 to access piperidone 22. However, the marginally
unsymmetrically methoxy substituted alkyne 19 underwent
B
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX