2
C.-H. Liu et al. / Tetrahedron xxx (2016) 1e4
In contrast, cheap iron-mediated photo-[5þ1] reaction of VCPs
a transformation under the balloon-pressured CO gas had no ben-
efit for the [5þ1] reaction (Table 1, entries 16e18). Very similar
result was obtained when Fe3(CO)12 (instead of Fe2(CO)9) was used
under the same reaction conditions (Table 1, entry 19). Therefore,
we chose the reaction conditions in entry 6 of Table 1 as the optimal
conditions for Fe-mediated [5þ1] reaction.
and CO has a broad reaction scope.8,9 The iron-mediated [5þ1]
cycloaddition was originally developed by Sarel’s group,10 in which
they used Fe(CO)5 or Fe2(CO)9 under ultraviolet irradiation condi-
tion.11,12 After that, Taber’s group further advanced photo-
irradiated and iron-mediated [5þ1] cycloaddition13aec and ap-
plied such a methodology to the total synthesis of natural
products13def (Scheme 1b). However, a limitation in both the
original and modified iron-mediated [5þ1] cycloadditions is that
the reaction had to be carried out by photoirradiation, which is
difficult for reaction scale-up. Another drawback of the photo-
irradiated and iron-mediated [5þ1] cycloadditions is the use of
toxic and volatile Fe(CO)5. Therefore, we were interested in de-
veloping a new iron-mediated [5þ1] reaction of VCPs and CO that
needs neither difficultly handled Fe(CO)5 nor photoirradiation
conditions.
Table 1
Optimization of the reaction conditions
Entrya
Solvent
T (ꢀC)
t (h)
Yield (%)b
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
iPrOH
nPrOH
tamylOH
tBuOH
tBuOH
tBuOH
HFIP
THF
DME
Dioxane
CPME
Toluene
DCE
90
90
90
90
90
90
60
60
90
90
90
90
90
Reflux
90
90
90
90
90
1
4
4
4
7
12
3
4
4
8
53c
62d
49
65
70
80
3
58
32
58
41
44
59
13e
df
76
64
34
79
We noticed that Fe2(CO)9 is a cheap14 and much easily handled
solid. Fe2(CO)9 is also regarded as precursor of Fe(CO)4,15a which is
the active species in the Fe(CO)5-mediated photo-[5þ1] reaction.
We also found that stoichiometrical Fe2(CO)9 has been used in the
carbonylation reactions such as PausoneKhand reaction15,16 and
[4þ1] cycloaddition of allenyl imines and CO17 under
photoirradiation-free conditions. Therefore, we hypothesized that
the original photo-irradiated Fe(CO)5-mediated [5þ1] reaction of
VCPs and CO could be advanced to a Fe2(CO)9-mediated [5þ1] re-
action without photoirradiation.18 We report here our realization of
such a Fe2(CO)9-mediated thermal [5þ1] cycloaddition for the
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16g
17h
18h,i
19j
5
6
7
3
MeCN
DMF
construction of a, b-cyclohexenones (Scheme 1c).
6
tBuOH
tBuOH
tBuOH
tBuOH
12
12
12
12
2. Results and discussion
We first screened the reaction conditions using the easily ac-
cessible VCP 1a as the standard substrate and Fe2(CO)9 as the me-
diator without using photoirradiation. The [5þ1] reaction can give
a
The reaction was performed in 0.3 mmol scale and 2 mL solvent was used.
Isolated yields.
b
c
d
e
f
Byproduct 4a can be detected by 1H NMR.
Byproduct 5a can be detected by 1H NMR.
Large amount of the substrate 1a remained.
Complex mixture.
both unconjugated and conjugated cyclohexenones. To obtain a, b-
cyclohexenone 2a exclusively, after the accomplishment of the
[5þ1] cycloaddition, DBU was added to the reaction solution and
stirred at room temperature for 30 min to realize the complete
isomerization. Initially, the reaction was performed using iPrOH as
solvent and stirred at 90 ꢀC for 1 h. The desired product 2a was
isolated in a moderate yield and a byproduct 4a was detected (Table
1, entry 1). Alcohol 4a is the reductive product of the unconjugated
intermediate 3a and may be formed by the iron-catalyzed hydro-
gen transfer from iPrOH.19 Apart from the reductive byproduct 4a,
some unidentified byproducts with low polarity similar to the
substrate 1a, were also observed from the TLC plate. We proposed
that such low-polar byproducts might originate from the heat-
induced rearrangement of VCP 1a.20 When nPrOH was used as
the solvent, the reaction yield was increased to 62%, together with
a byproduct, ketal 5a, which can be isolated (Table 1, entry 2). To
avoid the formation of byproducts 4a and 5a, we chose tertiary
alcohols such as tamylOH (tert-amyl alcohol) and tBuOH as the
solvents, finding that the yield could be increased to 65% when the
g
h
i
0.5 equiv Fe2(CO)9 was used.
0.2 equiv Fe2(CO)9 was used.
The reaction was performed under the CO atmosphere (1 atm).
1 equiv Fe3(CO)12 was used instead of Fe2(CO)9.
j
The reaction scope of the iron-mediated [5þ1] cycloaddition
under the optimal reaction conditions was studied (Table 2 and
Fig. 1). It was found that the electronic properties of the sub-
stitutions in the benzene rings of aryl-substituted VCPs had little
effect on the yields of the [5þ1] reactions (Table 2, 2beg). Besides
the phenyl group, both electron-withdrawing and -donating
groups gave good yields. The position of the substitutions on the
aryl ring of the substrate had limited effect on the outcome of the
reaction. We found that para-, meta- and ortho-methoxy
substituted substrates gave similar yields (Table 2, 2gei). We also
tried the naphthyl-substituted substrates 1j and 1k, finding that the
corresponding products 2j and 2k were obtained in moderate
yields. In addition, heterocyclic aryl substituted substrate 1l could
also give the cyclohexenone product in a good yield when it was
subjected to the iron-mediated [5þ1] reaction.
t
reaction was performed in BuOH (Table 1, entry 4). Further pro-
longing the reaction time led to the increase of the reaction yield of
the desired product 2a to 80%, accompanied by a trace amount of
low-polar rearrangement product (Table 1, entry 6). We also
screened several other solvents such as HFIP (hexa-
fluoroisopropanol), ethers, toluene, DCE and acetonitrile (Table 1,
entries 7e15). HFIP and acetonitrile were found to be inefficient for
the present transformation as only a trace amount of target [5þ1]
product could be isolated in these reaction systems. In ether sol-
vents, the transformation was slow and some other unidentified
byproducts were observed. The [5þ1] reaction performed in tolu-
ene or DCE only gave moderate yields. We also observed that, re-
ducing the equivalent of Fe2(CO)9 or carrying out such
Apart from the aryl substituted substrates, alkyl substituted VCP
substrates were also synthesized and tested for the present [5þ1]
cycloaddition reaction (Table 2, 2mep). Moderate yields could be