Organic Letters
Letter
bonding catalysts. Bifunctional cinchona alkaloid-based squar-
amides I, II, and thiourea III are widely used with nitro-group
containing Michael donors.14,15 The reaction did not take
place in the presence of catalyst I at room temperature in
DCM, although increasing the temperature to 80 °C led to
moderate conversion (71%) and afforded product in high ee
(92%) in DCE in 2 days (Table 1, entries 1 and 2). Only traces
of the product were detected in the presence of the catalyst II
under the same conditions (Table 1, entry 3). The reaction in
the presence of quinine-based thiourea III afforded product in
high enantioselectivity but the conversion was unreasonably
low (Table 1, entry 4). According to our previous experience
with indole chemistry with phase-transfer catalysis,7a PTC IV
was used (Table 1, entry 5). Full conversion was achieved at
room temperature but the formed product was racemic. Next,
cyclopropenimines as enantioselective Brønsted base catalysts
were applied.16 With the catalyst V, low conversion of the
starting material and obtained racemic product were character-
istic (Table 1, entry 6). Next, a brief screening of the solvents
with the most selective catalyst I revealed that toluene was the
best solvent in terms of both yield and enantioselectivity
(Table 1, entry 8). A slightly higher reactivity was achieved
when the temperature was raised to 100 °C (Table 1, entry 9).
Moreover, almost full conversion was reached by increasing the
concentration from 0.2 to 0.5 M without a significant impact
on the stereoselectivity (Table 1, entry 10).
Scheme 3. Scope and Limitations of the Reaction with
Nitromethane
a
Additionally, the influence of the catalyst amount on the
reaction rate was examined (see, Figure S1). There was no
significant difference when 10 or 20 mol % of the catalyst was
used. However, the experiment with 5 mol % of the catalyst
was inefficient demonstrating a considerable decline in reaction
rate and the conversion was only 78% in 26 h. Notably, the
catalyst amount did not affect the enantioselectivity of the
reaction, and the ee value remained constant and high during
the entire experiment.
Under optimized reaction conditions (toluene, 100 °C, 10
mol % of catalyst I, and reaction time 24 h), the substrate
scope of the reaction was investigated. Initially, variations on
the indolyl scaffold were evaluated (Scheme 3, I). The reaction
was run with monosubstituted indole derivatives that differ-
entiated from each other in the position and nature of the
substituent. The incorporation of the methyl group into the
C2- or C3-position did not have a significant impact on the
reaction yield or on the enantioselectivity. Substrates with
electron-withdrawing substituents at the C3- or C4-positions
tolerated the reaction well, providing the products 3c and 3d in
good yields (88 and 81%) and high ee-s (92% and 94%). A
drastic decline in the reaction yield was detected (most
probably a retro-Michael reaction occurred) when the 7-nitro-
substituted Michael acceptor 1e was used (yield 12%).
However, the ee value of the product 3e remained high
(93%). The tolerance toward electron-donating groups (and
also the substituent at the seventh position) on the indolyl ring
was well represented by 4- and 7-metoxy-substituted N-
functionalized indoles. The electron-donating groups did not
affect the reactivity, and the desired products 3f and 3g were
isolated in good yields (83% and 68%) and excellent
enantioselectivities (94% and 95%). Halogen-substituted C5-
and C6-unsaturated N-indolyl ketones reacted smoothly,
affording N-alkylated indoles 3h and 3i in good yields (71%
and 78%) and high ee’s (93% and 91%). Thus, the substitution
pattern of the indole ring is not essential and the method is
applicable to the monosubstituted indole derivatives possessing
a
Reaction conditions: 0.2 mmol scale, 1 equiv of 1−1o, 10 equiv of
nitromethane, 10 mol % of catalyst I, in 0.4 mL of toluene (0.5 M), 24
b
c
d
h. ee was determined by chiral HPLC analysis. 0.2 M. 0.1 mmol
scale. Reaction time 7 days.
e
substituents in any position. The absolute stereochemistry of
product 3g was unambiguously assigned by single-crystal X-ray
diffraction (see the SI), and other compounds in the series
were assigned based on the analogy.
Next, we turned our attention to the scope of Michael
acceptors with parent indolyl scaffolds (Scheme 3, II). Both
electron-withdrawing and electron-donating substituents at the
para-position of a phenyl ring did not have a significant impact
on the reaction yield (68% and 76%), but slightly better
enantioselectivity (95%) was achieved in the case of methoxy-
substituted substrate 1j. The p-bromo-substituted product 3l
was isolated in high yield (89%), and the achieved ee was
comparable with the model compound 3. The bulky 1-
naphthyl substituent of 1m led to a moderate yield (50%) and
slightly decreased the ee value (85%). Heteroaromatic furyl
derivative 3n was obtained in high yield and ee (77% and 94%,
respectively). Notably, the reaction rate and stereoselectivity
dropped drastically when the substrate 1o with the aliphatic
1822
Org. Lett. 2021, 23, 1820−1824