Full Paper
presence of various amounts of silver salt, with the stoichio-
metric ratio of Au/Ag either 1:1 or 2:1 (Table 2, entries 8–12). In
each case, the product yield was lower when silver salt
(0.5 equiv) was employed but the level of enantioselectivity re-
mained invariant. This is a significant observation. Considering
the different cationic complexes that can be generated in each
case (Scheme 4), the involvement of a bimetallic Au/Ag com-
Scheme 3. Au-catalysed cycloisomerisation of 1,6-enynes 1a–d.
Table 2. Effect of chiral diphosphine ligands and Au/Ag stoichiometry in
the cycloisomerisation of 1,6-enynes (Scheme 3).[a]
Entry
Substrate
L
Au/Ag
Yield[b] [%]
ee[c] [%]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
1a
1a
1a
1a
1a
1a
1a
1b
1b
1c
1c
1d
1d
(S)-L1
(R)-L7
(R)-L8
(R)-L10
(R)-L11
(R)-L11
–
(R)-L11
(R)-L11
(R)-L11
(R)-L11
(R)-L11
(R)-L11
1:1
1:1
1:1
1:1
1:1
2:1
0:1
1:1
2:1
1:1
2:1
1:1
2:1
87
70
85
96
92
89
–
86
54
76
69
54
45
99 (+)
46 (À)
75 (À)
38 (À)
60 (À)
64 (À)
–
66 (À)
64 (À)
78 (+)
74 (+)
72 (+)
74 (+)
Scheme 4. Possible complexes generated by using different Au/Ag ratios.
plex as the active catalyst can be ruled out because this can
only be generated in a significant quantity when a sub-stoi-
chiometric amount of silver salt is used.[41] Furthermore, the
result also strongly suggests that each metal centre operates
independently as an active catalytic site, that is, the presence
of any cooperative effect between the two proximal Au metal
centres may be discounted. This is commensurate with the
previous study, in which greater enantioselectivity was
observed with complexes that had larger intermetallic
distance/less propensity to form Au···Au interactions for steric
(L1) and/or electronic (L8, L11) reasons.
Finally, the active catalyst was also generated in situ by pre-
mixing the gold–chloride complex with the silver additive prior
to addition of the substrate, or by introducing an intermediate
operation, in which the AgCl formed was removed by filtration
through a bed of Celite before the introduction of the sub-
strate. These procedures had no effect on the results. Hence,
the involvement of [LÀAuÀClÀAg]+ is also highly unlikely.
9
10
11
12
13
[a] Reaction conditions: Substrate 1 in toluene (0.5m), [Au]2 (5 mol%),
[Ag] (5 or 10 mol%), RT, 24 h. [b] Isolated yield. [c] Determined by chiral
HPLC. Optical activity of the product is given in parentheses.
from the BINAP series (L7 and L8) were tested as catalysts be-
cause they have similar Au···Au distances (>5.3 ꢁ). In both
cases, the product was isolated in good yields. By using the
BINAP ligand L7, a modest 46% ee was obtained, whereas
tolyl-substituted L8 gave a much higher 75% ee (Table 1,
entries 2 and 3). Similarly, two ligands from the P-Phos series
(L10 and L11) were selected for their similar torsional angles
to L1. In these cases, excellent yields of the product were ob-
tained. Once again, the more-electron-rich P-xylyl-substituted
complex L11 offered significantly better enantioselectivity than
L10 (38 vs. 60% ee; Table 1, entries 4 and 5).
Correlations between structural parameters obtained from
solid-state structures and homogeneous catalytic reactions
should always be exercised with caution. Nevertheless, these
preliminary studies seem to suggest that the enantioselectivity
of atropisomeric biaryl diphosphine ligands can be enhanced
by using more-electron-rich P substituents.
Conclusion
We have conducted a structural study on a series of [(diphos-
phine)Au2Cl2] complexes. Even within the small selection of ex-
amples, some trends can be observed within the diaryl diphos-
phine complexes, for instance an increase in the electron-do-
nating character of the P-Ar substituent increases the Au···Au
distance. This effect is not observed, however, in the BINAP
series of ligands, which is attributed to the greater barrier to
rotation/more-rigid structure. The catalytic activity of selected
complexes was tested in the cycloisomerisation of 1,6-enynes;
the incorporation of electron-rich P donors enhanced the ste-
reoselectivity. Critically, the enantioselectivity of the process
was not affected by using different gold/silver ratios or by re-
moval of the silver by-product. This suggests that each metal
centre is likely to operate independently and that silver does
not participate in the process. These observations are useful
for the future design of better catalysts for these reactions.
Next, we examined the importance of the silver salt in these
reactions. In previous studies, the choice of silver salt/counter-
anion often had a profound effect on the catalytic activity and
it has been suggested that the participation of silver catalysis
cannot be discounted in such reactions.[26] In this case, a control
reaction showed that the linear substrate 1a remained un-
changed in the presence of AgBF4 alone at ambient tempera-
ture (Table 2, entry 7), that is, any background racemic process
due to the silver salt can be categorically ruled out. Subse-
quently, by using the L11-ligated complex, the cycloisomerisa-
tions of three other substrates 1b–d were performed in the
&
&
Chem. Eur. J. 2014, 20, 1 – 6
4
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ÝÝ These are not the final page numbers!