Full Paper
Scheme 5. Studies on the epimerization.
configurational instability of the final products under the reac-
tion conditions; whereas for the carbamate-protected deriva-
tives 4, racemization occurs neither on the final product nor
on the starting material. Therefore, we suggest that this partial
racemization takes place by reversible b-hydride elimination
(b-HE)/hydropalladation (HP) on one of the intermediates after
oxidative addition (Scheme 6).
Scheme 7. Aminocarbonylation reaction on deuterium-labeled derivatives D-
4b and ND-4c.
Table 3. Dependence of the e.r. with the pKa of the base.
Entry
Base
pKa
5c [%][a]
e.r.[b]
1
2
3
4
Et3N
10.75
7.4
5.96
4.76
85
88
95
70
71:29
76:24
90:10
98:2
collidine
NH2OH
AcONa
[a] Yield of the isolated product. [b] Determined by chiral HPLC analysis.
Scheme 6. Mechanistic proposal for the epimerization.
entries 1–4).[19] In this way, the use of a milder base, such as
AcONa, allowed us to obtain product 5c with complete preser-
vation of the optical purity (Table 3, entry 4). A few features de-
serve mentioning: 1) To date, most examples of anti b-hydride
elimination mechanisms have been reported on Heck or allylic
acetate elimination reactions;[16] 2) In most of those examples,
isomerization of the palladium intermediate to one featuring
hydrogen in a syn disposition cannot be excluded,[20] therefore,
they would only be formally anti; 3) To the best of our knowl-
edge, this is the first report on erosion of optical purity by a re-
versible anti b-hydride elimination/hydrometalation mecha-
nism; 4) Identification of such undesired reaction pathway has
allowed us to suppress the racemization by fine-tuning the pKa
of the base used.
The geometrical restrictions imposed by the cyclic structure
of intermediate A[15] (the same argument may be applied to in-
termediate C) require the b-hydride elimination step to take
place in an anti-fashion rendering planar intermediate B
(Scheme 6). Although several authors have proposed processes
of this kind, little mechanistic support has been reported to
date.[16,17] Again, this proposal would explain the greater exten-
sion of the racemization when electro-withdrawing substitu-
ents are present by increasing the acidity of the benzylic
proton.
In a further effort to find experimental support for the intra-
molecular nature of the racemization process, the aminocarbo-
nylation reaction was tested on deuterium-labeled derivatives
D-4b and ND-4c (Scheme 7). In agreement with our hypothe-
sis, neither H- nor D-incorporation was observed upon amino-
carbonylation of D-4b and ND-4c, respectively (Scheme 7).
The lack of H/D scrambling seems to rule out that a simple
acid–base reaction is responsible for the observed partial epi-
merization.
With the optimal base (AcONa, Table 3, entry 4), other reac-
tions for which a higher degree of racemization was observed
under our initial reaction conditions were repeated (Scheme 8).
As expected, carbamate derivative 4b underwent smooth ami-
nocarbonylation with complete preservation of optical purity.
On the other hand, the most challenging substrate, the unpro-
tected 5-CF3 derivative 2c, led to complete racemization be-
cause of the configurational instability of the free NH isoindoli-
none under the reaction conditions. However, the correspond-
ing product 3c was achieved in excellent optical purity by tri-
fluoroacetic acid (TFA) deprotection of 5c (see below).
Assuming that the anti b-hydride elimination is a base-pro-
moted E2-type process,[18] the degree of epimerization should
display a pronounced dependence on the pKa of the base.
Therefore, fine-tuning of the basicity made it possible to over-
come the partial racemization on substrates bearing fluorinat-
ed residues at the aromatic ring (Table 3).
Deprotection
From Table 3, a nice correlation between the pKa of the base
and the e.r. of the final products may be inferred: the weaker
the base, the higher the optical purity of the product (Table 3,
Finally, free NH isoindolines 3 may be obtained in high optical
purity by TFA deprotection of the corresponding NBoc deriva-
Chem. Eur. J. 2015, 21, 11579 – 11584
11582
ꢀ 2015 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim