6<17+(6,6ꢃꢃ2)ꢃꢃ&+,5$/ꢃꢂꢉ$5</7(75$+<'52)85$1ꢉꢇꢉ21(6ꢃꢃ
ꢀꢁꢐꢃ
ꢊ&+ &+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢄꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢅꢃꢊꢀ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢄꢁꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢂꢃWꢃ
ꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢐꢆꢃꢏꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢁꢃGꢌGꢃꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢈꢌꢐꢁꢆꢃ
ꢇꢌꢅꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢎꢃWꢃꢊꢄ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢅꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢎꢌꢄꢃGꢃꢊꢄ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃ
Eꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢁꢃ+]ꢋꢌꢃ
ZDVꢃSXULILHGꢃE\ꢃSUHSDUDWLYHꢃWKLQꢉOD\HUꢃFKURPDWRJUDSK\ꢃ
ꢊHOXHQWꢃHWK\OꢃDFHWDWH±OLJURLQꢆꢃꢀꢔꢄꢈꢋꢌꢃ<LHOGꢃꢈꢌꢈꢂꢁꢃJꢃ
ꢊꢀꢀLꢋꢆ > @ ꢃ ꢃ±ꢀꢇꢌꢂꢃꢊpꢃ ꢃꢈꢌꢅꢅꢆꢃ&+&O ꢋꢆꢃrrꢃ!ꢏꢏLꢃ>ꢇꢏ@ꢆꢃ
PSꢃ ꢀꢅ±ꢀꢁ&ꢓꢃ SXEOLVKHGꢃ GDWDꢃ >ꢇꢏ@ꢔꢃ PSꢃ ꢀꢂ±ꢀꢁ&ꢌꢃ7KHꢃ
,5ꢃDQGꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUDꢃZHUHꢃLGHQWLFDOꢃWRꢃDꢃVDPSOHꢃ
SUHSDUHGꢃDVꢃGHVFULEHGꢃDERYHꢃLQꢃhꢌꢃ
ꢇ±ꢈꢁꢀꢁꢇꢉꢁ0HWKR[\SKHQ\OꢈWHWUDK\GURIXUDQꢁꢂꢁRQH
ꢇ9ꢈꢃZDVꢃV\QWKHVL]HGꢃDVꢃGHVFULEHGꢃDERYHꢃIRUꢃFRPSRXQGꢃ
,9ꢃIURPꢃꢈꢌꢇꢂꢃJꢃꢊꢄꢌꢈꢁꢃPPROꢋꢃRIꢃHWK\OꢃꢅꢉꢊꢅꢉPHWKR[\ꢉ
SKHQ\OꢋꢉꢅꢉR[REXWDQRDWHꢃꢊ,,,ꢋꢃꢊUHDFWLRQꢃWLPHꢃꢄꢅꢅꢃKꢓꢃ
7/&ꢆꢃ HWK\Oꢃ DFHWDWH±OLJURLQꢆꢃ ꢄꢔꢇꢌꢂꢋꢌꢃ <LHOGꢃ RIꢃ FUXGHꢃ
SURGXFWꢃꢈꢌꢇꢃJꢃꢊꢎꢈLꢋꢓꢃDIWHUꢃSXULILFDWLRQꢃE\ꢃSUHSDUDWLYHꢃ
WKLQꢉOD\HUꢃFKURPDWRJUDSK\ꢃꢊHWK\OꢃDFHWDWH±OLJURLQꢆꢃ
ꢄꢔꢇꢌꢂꢋꢆꢃ \LHOGꢃ ꢈꢌꢄꢇꢃ Jꢃ ꢊꢂꢏꢌꢂLꢋꢆꢃ > @ ꢃ ꢃ ±ꢀꢂꢃ ꢊpꢃ ꢃ ꢈꢌꢐꢁꢆꢃ
&+&O ꢋꢓꢃrrꢃYDOXHꢃDQGꢃDEVROXWHꢃFRQILJXUDWLRQꢃZHUHꢃQRWꢃ
GHWHUPLQHGꢃIRUꢃWKHꢃODFNꢃRIꢃWKHꢃFRUUHVSRQGLQJꢃSXEOLVKHGꢃ
GDWDꢌꢃ,5ꢃVSHFWUXPꢃꢊILOPꢋꢆꢃ ꢆꢃFP ꢔꢃꢀꢈꢂꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢇꢏꢎꢈꢃPꢆꢃ
ꢄꢐꢁꢈꢃVꢆꢃꢄꢅꢂꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢇꢅꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢄꢏꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢎꢀꢈꢃPꢌꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃ
VSHFWUXPꢆꢃ ꢆꢃSSPꢔꢃ ꢇꢌꢇꢃ GꢌGꢃ ꢊ&+ &+ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃ ꢎꢆꢃ ꢄꢀꢃ +]ꢋꢆꢃꢃ
ꢇꢌꢁꢃGꢌGꢌGꢌGꢃꢊ&+ &+ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢐꢆꢃꢁꢌꢁꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢀꢌꢎꢃVꢃꢊ&+ ꢋꢆ ꢂꢌꢅꢃWꢃ
ꢊ2&+ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢎꢃ+]ꢋꢃꢁꢌꢏꢃGꢃꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢎꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢀꢃGꢃꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃ
(WK\O ꢉꢁꢇPHWKR[\SKHQ\OꢈꢁꢉꢁR[REXWDQRDWH ꢇ,,,ꢈꢄꢃ
&RQFHQWUDWHGꢃVXOIXULFꢃDFLGꢃꢊꢏꢎLꢋꢆꢃꢅꢃPOꢆꢃZDVꢃFDUHIXOO\ꢃ
DGGHGꢃGURSZLVHꢃXQGHUꢃVWLUULQJꢃWRꢃDꢃPL[WXUHꢃRIꢃꢇꢌꢈꢎꢃJꢃ
ꢊꢄꢈꢃ PPROꢋꢃ RIꢃ ꢅꢉꢊPHWKR[\SKHQ\OꢋꢉꢅꢉR[REXWDQRLFꢃ DFLGꢃ
;,,ꢃ >ꢇꢀ@ꢆꢃ ꢇꢀꢃPOꢃ RIꢃ DQK\GURXVꢃ HWKDQROꢆꢃ DQGꢃ ꢀꢇꢃ POꢃ RIꢃ
EHQ]HQHꢃ ꢊIUHVKO\ꢃ GLVWLOOHGꢃ RYHUꢃ PHWDOOLFꢃ VRGLXPꢋꢌꢃ7KHꢃ
PL[WXUHꢃ ZDVꢃ VWLUUHGꢃ IRUꢃ ꢄꢈꢃ PLQꢃ DWꢃ URRPꢃ WHPSHUDWXUHꢃ
DQGꢃ ZDVꢃ WKHQꢃ KHDWHGꢃ XQGHUꢃ UHIOX[ꢃ RYHUꢃ ꢄꢅꢃ Kꢌꢃ 7KHꢃ
PL[WXUHꢃ ZDVꢃ FRROHGꢃWRꢃ URRPꢃ WHPSHUDWXUHꢆꢃ ꢏꢈꢃ POꢃ RIꢃ
ZDWHUꢃZDVꢃDGGHGꢆꢃWKHꢃRUJDQLFꢃSKDVHꢃZDVꢃVHSDUDWHGꢆꢃDQGꢃ
WKHꢃDTXHRXVꢃSKDVHꢃZDVꢃH[WUDFWHGꢃZLWKꢃGLHWK\OꢃHWKHUꢃ
ꢊꢀîꢀꢈꢃ POꢋꢌꢃ7KHꢃ H[WUDFWVꢃ ZHUHꢃ FRPELQHGꢃ ZLWKꢃWKHꢃ
RUJDQLFꢃ SKDVHꢆꢃ ZDVKHGꢃ ZLWKꢃ Dꢃ VDWXUDWHGꢃ VROXWLRQꢃ RIꢃ
1D+&2 ꢃꢊꢇîꢄꢈꢃPOꢋꢆꢃGULHGꢃRYHUꢃ0J62 ꢆꢃILOWHUHGꢆꢃDQGꢃ
HYDSRUDWHGꢌꢃ7KHꢃUHVLGXHꢃZDVꢃDꢃVHPLVROLGꢃVXEVWDQFHꢌꢃ
<LHOGꢃꢄꢌꢎꢅꢃJꢃꢊꢐꢏLꢋꢆꢃPSꢃꢀꢀ±ꢀꢂ&ꢌꢃ,5ꢃVSHFWUXPꢃꢊ.%Uꢋꢆꢃ
ꢆꢃFP ꢔꢃꢀꢈꢈꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢇꢏꢎꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢐꢈꢂꢃVꢆꢃꢄꢁꢎꢈꢃVꢆꢃꢄꢅꢈꢈꢃPꢆꢃ
ꢄꢇꢅꢈꢃ Vꢆꢃ ꢄꢄꢎꢈꢃ Pꢆꢃ ꢎꢅꢈꢃ Vꢌꢃ +ꢃ 105ꢃ VSHFWUXPꢆꢃ ꢆꢃ SSPꢔꢃꢃ
ꢄꢌꢀꢃ Wꢃ ꢊ&+ &+ ꢆꢃ Eꢃ ꢃ ꢐꢌꢄꢃ +]ꢋꢆꢃ ꢇꢌꢐꢃ Wꢃ ꢊ 2&2&+ ꢆꢃ Eꢃ ꢃ
ꢁꢌꢐꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃ ꢀꢌꢀꢃ Wꢃ ꢊ&2&+ ꢆꢃ Eꢃ ꢃ ꢁꢌꢐꢃ +]ꢋꢆꢃ ꢀꢌꢏꢃ Vꢃ ꢊ 2&+ ꢋꢆꢃꢃ
ꢅꢌꢇꢃTꢃꢊ&+ &+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢄꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢁꢌꢏꢃGꢃꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃꢉ+ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢃ
ꢀꢌꢐꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢎꢌꢈꢃGꢃꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃꢉ+ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢎꢌꢐꢃ+]ꢋꢌꢃꢃ
+
ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢎꢃ+]ꢋꢌꢃ &ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢆꢃ ꢆꢃSSPꢔꢃꢇꢏꢆꢃꢀꢈꢆꢃ
ꢂꢁꢆꢃꢎꢄꢆꢃꢄꢇꢁꢆꢃꢄꢇꢎꢆꢃꢄꢀꢈꢆꢃꢄꢂꢎꢆꢃꢄꢐꢁꢌꢃ
5()(5(1&(6ꢃ
ꢃꢃꢄꢌꢃ (QGRꢆꢃ$ꢌꢆꢃ.XURGDꢆꢃ0ꢌꢆꢃDQGꢃ7VXMLWDꢆꢃ<ꢌꢆꢃEꢃꢁ6vivꢌꢆꢃꢄꢏꢐꢁꢆꢃ
ꢃ
YROꢌꢃꢇꢏꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢄꢀꢅꢁꢌꢃꢃ
ꢃꢃꢇꢌꢃ %URZQꢆꢃ +ꢌ&ꢌꢆꢃ .XONDUQLꢆꢃ 6ꢌ.ꢌꢆꢃ DQGꢃ 5DFKHUODꢆꢃ 8ꢌ6ꢌꢆꢃꢃ
EꢃꢁPꢀtꢃꢁ8urꢌꢆꢃꢄꢏꢏꢅꢆꢃYROꢌꢃꢂꢏꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢀꢁꢂꢌꢃꢃ
ꢃꢃꢀꢌꢃ Chqixꢁ sꢁ Ihꢀhyꢁ Qrvpvqrꢆꢃ 0RUJDQꢆꢃ (ꢌ'ꢌꢃ DQGꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
0DQGDYDꢆꢃ 1ꢌ%ꢌꢆꢃ (GVꢌꢆꢃ %RFDꢃ 5DWRQꢔꢃ &5&ꢆꢃ ꢄꢏꢎꢎꢆꢃꢃ
YROꢌꢃ,9%ꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢎꢈꢌꢃ
&RPSRXQGVꢃ,,ꢃDQGꢃ9,ꢃZHUHꢃV\QWKHVL]HGꢃLQꢃDꢃVLPLODUꢃ
ZD\ꢌꢃ
ꢃꢃꢅꢌꢃ 7URVWꢆꢃ%ꢌ0ꢌꢆꢃ7DQJꢆꢃ:ꢌꢆꢃDQGꢃ6FKXOWHꢆꢃ-ꢌꢆꢃPꢀtꢃꢁGrꢌꢆꢃꢇꢈꢈꢈꢆꢃ
YROꢌꢃꢇꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢅꢈꢄꢀꢌꢃꢃ
ꢃꢃꢂꢌꢃ 'HYRQꢆꢃ7ꢌ.ꢌꢃDQGꢃ6FRWWꢆꢃ$ꢌ,ꢌꢆꢃChqixꢁsꢁIhꢀhyyꢁPpꢄ
pꢀꢀvtꢁ8qꢆꢃ1HZꢃ<RUNꢔꢃ$FDGHPLFꢆꢃꢄꢏꢐꢂꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢄꢌꢃ
ꢃꢃꢁꢌꢃ 0L\DEHꢆꢃ+ꢌꢆꢃ)XMLLꢆꢃ.ꢌꢆꢃ*RWRꢆꢃ7ꢌꢆꢃDQGꢃ1DLWRꢆꢃ7ꢌꢆꢃPꢀtꢃꢁGrꢌꢆꢃ
ꢇꢈꢈꢈꢆꢃYROꢌꢃꢇꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢅꢈꢐꢄꢌꢃꢃ
ꢃꢃꢐꢌꢃ /LQꢆꢃ*ꢌ4ꢌꢆꢃ:DQJꢆꢃ:ꢌꢆꢃDQGꢃ;Xꢆꢃ0ꢌ+ꢌꢆꢃ PꢀtꢃꢁGrꢌꢆꢃꢇꢈꢈꢈꢆꢃ
YROꢌꢃꢇꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢇꢇꢇꢏꢌꢃꢃ
(WK\O ꢉꢁR[RꢁꢉꢁSKHQ\OEXWDQRDWH ꢇ,,ꢈꢃ ZDVꢃ V\QWKHꢉ
VL]HGꢃIURPꢃꢄꢌꢐꢎꢃJꢃꢊꢄꢈꢃPPROꢋꢃRIꢃꢅꢉR[RꢉꢅꢉSKHQ\OEXWDQꢉ
RLFꢃ DFLGꢃ ꢊ,ꢋꢃ >ꢇꢀ@ꢃ DQGꢃ ꢇꢈꢃ POꢃ RIꢃ DQK\GURXVꢃ HWKDQROꢃ LQꢃꢃ
ꢀꢈꢃPOꢃRIꢃEHQ]HQHꢃꢊIUHVKO\ꢃGLVWLOOHGꢃRYHUꢃVRGLXPꢋꢌꢃ&RPꢉ
SRXQGꢃ ,ꢃ ZDVꢃ LVRODWHGꢃ DVꢃ Dꢃ ZKLWHꢃ V\UXSꢌꢃ<LHOGꢃ ꢄꢌꢐꢇꢃ Jꢃ
ꢊꢎꢀLꢋꢆꢃPSꢃꢅꢎ±ꢂꢈ&ꢌꢃ,5ꢃVSHFWUXPꢃꢊ.%Uꢋꢆꢃ ꢆꢃFP ꢔꢃꢃ
ꢀꢈꢂꢈꢃEUꢆꢃꢇꢏꢂꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢐꢅꢈꢃVꢆꢃꢄꢅꢅꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢇꢈꢈꢃVꢆꢃꢄꢄꢁꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢃ
ꢐꢂꢈꢃVꢆꢃꢁꢏꢂꢃVꢌꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢆꢃ ꢆꢃSSPꢔꢃꢄꢌꢇꢃWꢃ
ꢊ&+ &+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢄꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢇꢌꢐꢃWꢃꢊ22&&+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢁꢌꢁꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃ
ꢀꢌꢀꢃWꢃꢊ&2&+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢁꢌꢁꢆꢃꢐꢌꢇꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢅꢌꢄꢃTꢃꢊ&+ &+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢃ
ꢐꢌꢄꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢅꢃWꢃꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢀꢌꢄꢆꢃꢐꢌꢇꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢂꢃWꢃꢊꢄ+ꢆꢃ
ꢃ
ꢁ
ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃꢃꢎꢌꢃ &ROHꢆꢃ'ꢌ&ꢌꢆꢃUrꢀhurqꢀꢆꢃꢄꢏꢏꢅꢆꢃYROꢌꢃꢂꢈꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢏꢂꢄꢐꢌꢃ
ꢃꢃꢏꢌꢃ )DEHUꢆꢃ .ꢌꢆꢃ 7vꢀhsꢀhvꢁ vꢁ Pꢀthvpꢁ 8urvꢀꢆꢃ
ꢃ
%HUOLQꢔꢃ6SULQJHUꢆꢃꢇꢈꢈꢈꢌꢃꢃ
ꢄꢈꢌꢃ 6DQWDQLHOORꢆꢃ (ꢌꢆꢃ )HUUDERVFKLꢆꢃ 3ꢌꢆꢃ *ULVHQWLꢆꢃ 3ꢌꢆꢃ DQGꢃ 0DQꢉ
]RFFKLꢆꢃ$ꢌꢆꢃ8urꢃꢁSrꢌꢆꢃꢄꢏꢏꢇꢆꢃYROꢌꢃꢏꢇꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢄꢈꢐꢄꢌꢃꢃ
+
ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢅꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢐꢌꢏꢃGꢃꢊꢇ+ꢆꢃ+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢄꢀꢌꢈꢃ+]ꢋꢌꢃ
ꢃ
(WK\O ꢂꢁEHQ]R\OEHQ]RDWH ꢇ9,ꢈꢃ ZDVꢃ V\QWKHVL]HGꢃ
ꢄꢄꢌꢃ 6HUYLꢆꢃ6ꢌꢆꢃTurvꢆꢃꢄꢏꢏꢈꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢄꢌꢃꢃ
IURPꢃ ꢇꢌꢇꢁꢃ Jꢃ ꢊ ꢄꢈꢃ PPROꢋꢃ RIꢃ ꢇꢉEHQ]R\OEHQ]RDWHꢃ ꢊ9,,,ꢋ
>ꢇꢅ@ꢃ DQGꢃ ꢇꢐꢃ POꢃ RIꢃ DQK\GURXVꢃ HWKDQROꢃ LQꢃ ꢀꢈꢃ POꢃ RIꢃ
EHQ]HQHꢃꢊIUHVKO\ꢃGLVWLOOHGꢃRYHUꢃPHWDOOLFꢃVRGLXPꢋꢌꢃ<LHOGꢃ
ꢄꢌꢏꢎꢃJꢃꢊꢐꢎLꢋꢆꢃFRORUOHVVꢃFU\VWDOVꢆꢃPSꢃꢂꢀ±ꢂꢂ&ꢌꢃ,5ꢃVSHFꢉ
WUXPꢃꢊ.%Uꢋꢆꢃ ꢆꢃFP ꢔꢃꢀꢈꢂꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢇꢏꢎꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢐꢇꢈꢃVꢆꢃꢄꢁꢎꢈꢃVꢆꢃ
ꢄꢂꢎꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢅꢅꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢇꢀꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢄꢈꢎꢈꢃPꢆꢃꢐꢏꢈꢃPꢌꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃ
ꢄꢇꢌꢃ &VXNꢆꢃ5ꢌ%ꢌꢃDQGꢃ*ODQ]HUꢆꢃ,ꢌꢆꢃ8urꢃꢁSrꢌꢆꢃꢄꢏꢏꢄꢆꢃYROꢌꢃꢏꢄꢆꢃꢃ
ꢃ
Sꢌꢃꢅꢏꢌꢃ
ꢄꢀꢌꢃ 6HHEDFKꢆꢃ'ꢌꢃDQGꢃ =XJHUꢆꢃ0ꢌ)ꢌꢆꢃCryꢃꢁ8uvꢃꢁ6phꢆꢃꢄꢏꢎꢇꢆꢃ
YROꢌꢃꢁꢂꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢅꢏꢂꢌꢃ
ꢄꢅꢌꢃ 0RULꢆꢃ.ꢌꢃDQGꢃ6XJDLꢆꢃ7ꢌ-ꢌꢆꢃTuꢃꢁPꢀtꢃꢁ8urꢃꢁEꢌꢆꢃꢄꢏꢎꢀꢆꢃ
YROꢌꢃꢅꢄꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢄꢈꢅꢅꢃꢊVHHꢃDOVRꢃUHIHUHQFHVꢃWKHUHLQꢋꢌꢃꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
VSHFWUXPꢆꢃ ꢆꢃSSPꢔꢃꢄꢌꢈꢃWꢃꢊ&+ &+ ꢆꢃEꢃ ꢃꢐꢌꢄꢃ+]ꢋꢆꢃꢅꢌꢄꢃTꢃ ꢄꢂꢌꢃ )UDWHUꢆꢃ*ꢌꢆꢃCryꢃꢁ8uvꢃꢁ6phꢆꢃꢄꢏꢐꢏꢆꢃYROꢌꢃꢁꢇꢆꢃSꢌꢃꢇꢎꢇꢂꢌꢃꢃ
5866,$1ꢃꢃ-2851$/ꢃꢃ2)ꢃꢃ25*$1,&ꢃꢃ&+(0,675<ꢃꢃꢃ9ROꢌꢃꢃꢅꢇꢃꢃꢃ1Rꢌꢃꢃꢀꢃꢃꢃꢇꢈꢈꢁꢃ