Angewandte
Chemie
DOI: 10.1002/anie.201206670
Natural Product Synthesis
Divergent Total Synthesis of the Antimitotic Agent Leiodermatolide**
Jens Willwacher, Nina Kausch-Busies, and Alois Fꢀrstner*
The development of drugs based on microtubule toxins
marked major leaps forward in cancer chemotherapy.[1,2] All
approved spindle poisons exert their primary function by
interfering with tubulin dynamics upon binding to the protein.
Cell-cycle arrest is the immediate biological response, which
ultimately translates into cell death through a complex
signaling cascade. In clinical settings, however, severe side
effects as well as (multidrug) resistance set serious limitations
to the use of such antimitotic agents, and make the search for
more effective and selective drugs indispensable.[3]
It is against this backdrop that the recent discovery of
leiodermatolide has to be seen.[4,5] This complex macrolide of
marine origin exhibits remarkable, yet selective, cytotoxicity
in vitro, with IC50 values for the most sensitive human cancer
cell lines well below 10 nm.[6] This concentration also sufficed
to effect cell-cycle arrest of the highly responsive A549 lung
adenocarcinoma and PANC-1 pancreatic tumor cells at the
G2M phase transition, accompanied by abnormal spindle
formations in both cell types. Surprisingly though, leioder-
matolide exerted no noticeable effect on purified tubulin even
at much higher concentrations.[5] Therefore, this particular
natural product seems to operate through a mechanism
distinct from that of the established antimitotic agents such as
vincristine, colchicine, paclitaxel, epothilone, and discoder-
molide, to mention only the most prominent ones,[1,2] and
hence warrants close chemical, biochemical, and, possibly,
pharmacological inspection.
Leiodermatolide was isolated from a lithistid Leioderma-
tium sponge collected by submersible in the deep waters off
the Florida coastline (0.0011% of the wet weight).[5] Approxi-
mately tenfold lower concentrations were detected in speci-
mens harvested in the Bahamas,[7] whereas an earlier study on
Leiodermatium sponges collected off Palau had only given
structurally unrelated secondary metabolites of mixed poly-
ketide/nonribosomal peptide synthetase origin (“leioto-
lides”).[8,9]
A masterful investigation combining the predictive power
of modern computational tools with advanced NMR spectro-
scopic techniques allowed the constitution and much of the
stereostructure of leiodermatolide to be established.[5] How-
ever, the segregated stereoclusters within the macrolac-
tone[10,11] and the d-lactone terminus could not be correlated
with each other, thus leaving it open as to whether structure
1 or 2 represents the natural product (Scheme 1). The
absolute configuration of leiodermatolide also remained
unknown. Moreover, Maier and co-workers cautiously ques-
tioned whether the unusual axial attachment of the side chain
onto the d-lactone at the tertiary alcohol site C21 had been
correctly assigned by the isolation team.[12]
To resolve these open issues, we pursued an approach to
this rewarding target that was programmed for late-stage
divergence. If necessary for an unambiguous structure assign-
ment, the retrosynthetic analysis outlined in Scheme 1 allows
any conceivable stereoisomer of the terminal d-lactone
(fragment E) to be attached to a truncated macrolide synthon
of type A while forming the E,E diene unit of the side
chain.[10] Provided that A can be forged by ring-closing alkyne
metathesis (RCAM) as envisaged,[13,14] the macrocyclization
and the formation of the Z,Z diene become advantageously
aligned. In this context, it is important to note that the stereo-
and site-selective generation of Z,Z-configured 1,3-dienes by
olefin metathesis seems currently impossible even with the
most advanced catalysts.[15] The proposed strategic substitu-
tion of an alkene for an alkyne, as shown in Scheme 1,
however, allows the orthogonal reactivity of the different
p bonds through a metal alkylidyne catalyst to be harnessed,
and hence the site of ring closure to be reliably determined.
Moreover, as the configuration of the targeted alkene can be
determined at will by stereoselective semireduction of the
acetylene linkage, 1,3-dienes of any configuration—including
the generally rather labile Z,Z-configured ones—seem within
reach.[16]
In the leiodermatolide case, we opted to apply the
ꢀ
RCAM/semireduction tactics at the C10 C11 bond rather
ꢀ
than at the neighboring C12 C13 olefin, as this disconnection
arguably leads to more manageable building blocks. The
anticipated bonus of step economy aside, however, this
strategic decision bore considerable risk at the stage of ring
closure: in general, enynes tend to be less reactive than
nonconjugated alkynes, and bulky[17] propargylic substrates
have so far rarely succumbed to RCAM.[13] Both structural
elements are present in the envisaged cyclization precursor B.
At the outset of this project it was also unclear whether an
alkenyl halide is compatible with the available alkyne meta-
thesis catalysts, even though we were optimistic in view of the
excellent tolerance of the latest generation of metal alkyli-
dynes toward many different reactive functional groups.
These reservations notwithstanding, we pursued the syn-
thesis of the required building blocks as shown in Scheme 2.
The cheap malonate derivative 3 served as the point of
departure, which was advanced into 3-iodomethacrolein (6)
by following a literature procedure.[18] A subsequent boron-
mediated Masamune–Abiko reaction with donor 7[19] fur-
[*] Dipl.-Chem. J. Willwacher, Dr. N. Kausch-Busies, Prof. A. Fꢀrstner
Max-Planck-Institut fꢀr Kohlenforschung
45470 Mꢀlheim/Ruhr (Germany)
E-mail: fuerstner@kofo.mpg.de
[**] Generous financial support from the MPG and the Fonds der
Chemischen Industrie (Kekulꢁ stipend to J.W.) is gratefully
acknowledged. We thank the Analytical Departments of our Institute
for the excellent cooperation.
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2012, 51, 12041 –12046
ꢀ 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
12041