3528
S. Kandre et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 54 (2013) 3526–3529
yields and the ease of product isolation observed in DMF.
Microwave heating in DMF at 95 °C for 1 h was found optimum
due to shorter reaction times and increased product purities and
yields. Although increasing the reaction temperature to 130 °C in
DMF lowered the time required for reaction completion to
20 min, it was also observed that the product yields reduced to
69% as a result of increased side-products seen at this elevated
temperature.
Following optimization of reaction conditions, the scope of this
simplistic method was studied by reacting several amidoximes and
substituted or unsubstituted benzoyl cyanides in DMF using
microwave heating at 95 °C for 1 h (Table 2).26 The reaction pro-
ceeds via a O-carbophenyl amidoxime intermediate (2) that subse-
quently dehydrates and undergoes cyclization to yield the
appropriately substituted 3,5-disubstituted 1,2,4-oxadiazoles.
After completion of the reaction, the desired product precipitates
as a solid on addition of water to DMF and is thus isolated using
simple filtration thereby avoiding the need for column chromato-
graphic purification techniques. The 3-position substituent is
obtained from the amidoxime whereas the 5-position substituent
is obtained from the corresponding benzoyl cyanide used in this
reaction. The aromatic and aliphatic amidoximes used to develop
this methodology were synthesized using a reported procedure.23
Although the benzoyl cyanides used in this study are commercially
available, they can also be readily synthesized from appropriate
acyl chlorides as reported in the literature.27a,b
In this study, the reactivities of an unsubstituted phenyl
amidoxime (Table 2, entries 1–3) were compared with ortho-,
meta-, or para-methoxy substituted phenyl amidoximes (Table 2,
entries 4–12) and ortho-, meta-, or para-nitro substituted phenyl
amidoximes (Table 2, entries 13–21). The reactivities of aliphatic
amidoximes such as cyclohexyl amidoxime (Table 2, entries
22–24) and an adamantly amidoxime (Table 2, entries 25–27) were
also evaluated. We have thus attempted to understand the effects
exerted by electron withdrawing and electron donating amidox-
ime substituents on the yields of corresponding 3,5-disubstituted
1,2,4-oxadiazoles. The corresponding benzoyl cyanides that have
been evaluated for their reactivity include either an unsubstituted
benzoyl cyanide yielding a phenyl substituent, an electron with-
drawing para-fluoro benzoyl cyanide yielding a para-fluorophenyl
substituent, and an electron donating para-methyl benzoyl cyanide
yielding a para-methylphenyl substituent at the 5-position.
The reactivity trend can be discussed from the benzoyl cyanide
perspective as well as from the amidoxime perspective. From the
benzoyl cyanide perspective, the general reactivity trend observed
is para-fluorophenyl substituent > phenyl substituent > para-
methylphenyl substituent indicating that the presence of an elec-
tron withdrawing substituent on the phenyl favors reactivity as
compared to the presence of an electron donating substituent.
However this reactivity trend appears reversed in the case of ami-
doximes, wherein the yields with methoxy phenyl substitu-
ents P phenyl substituent > nitrophenyl substituent indicate that
the presence of an electron donating substituent on phenyl ami-
doxime favors reactivity as compared to the presence of an elec-
tron withdrawing substituent. The order of reactivity of phenyl
amidoximes substituted with an electron donating methoxy group
appears to be ortho substituent P para substituent > meta substi-
tuent. A similar comparison with an electron withdrawing nitro
phenyl amidoxime identifies the order of reactivity to be me-
ta P para > ortho. The aliphatic cyclohexyl and adamantyl amidox-
imes exhibit similar reactivity as seen with aromatic phenyl
amidoxime thereby exemplifying the utility of this reaction. All
the studied examples (Table 2, entries 1–27) proceeded with mod-
erate to high yields and in each case the desired product was iso-
lated using simple filtration. This methodology thus provides an
attractive alternative to existing literature methodologies.
To demonstrate the utility of our developed methodology, we
compared the synthesis of methyl 3-(4-((4-(5-phenyl-1,2,4-oxa-
diazol-3-yl)benzyl)amino)phenyl)propanoate (31) with another
reported microwave reaction condition21 and compared the yields
obtained from each methodology (Table 3). The reported micro-
wave procedure for the synthesis of 1,2,4-oxadiazoles reports
yields in excess of 90% on reacting an aldehyde with an amidoxime
for 3 min at 150 °C. However the reaction of methyl 3-(4-((4-(N0-
hydroxycarbamimidoyl)benzyl)amino)phenyl)propanoate
(30)
with benzaldehyde under microwave conditions at 150 °C for
15 min yielded only 24% of 31 (Table 3, entry 1). The reaction time
was extended from the originally reported 3–15 min in an attempt
to ensure complete consumption of the starting material and
maximize the product yield. Although the yield obtained with
the reported methodology was much lower than that anticipated,
our alternative microwave methodology (Table 3, entry 2) that
involves reacting amidoxime 30 with benzoyl cyanide at 95 °C
for 1 h yielded 63% of compound 31. Moreover, we were able to
isolate compound 31 using simple filtration techniques as opposed
to the column chromatographic purification warranted when the
reported methodology21 was implemented.
In summary, an alternate intermolecular synthesis of 3,5-disub-
stituted 1,2,4-oxadiazoles has been achieved. This reaction pro-
ceeds via an O-carbophenyl amidoxime intermediate synthesized
in situ. Both aliphatic and aromatic amidoximes can undergo a
reaction with substituted or unsubstituted benzoyl cyanides to
yield 3,5-disubstituted 1,2,4-oxadiazoles in moderate to high
yields. In general, electron donating substituents on the aromatic
phenyl amidoxime are observed to favor the reactivity over elec-
tron withdrawing substituents. In the case of substituted para-
substituted benzoyl cyanides, electron withdrawing substituents
are favored over electron donating substituents. The synthetic
methodology described herein allows for ease of purification as
the desired product precipitates out as a solid and can thus be
isolated using simple filtration as opposed to lengthy column chro-
matographic purification techniques. This synthetic protocol thus
Table 3
Effect of varying reaction conditions on product yield
O
O
O
O
N
H
N
H
N
N
a
HO
31
30
N
O
NH2
Entry
Reaction conditions (a)
Yield of 31 (%)
1
2
Benzaldehyde/150 °C/MW/15 min
Benzoyl cyanide/DMF/95 °C/MW/1 h
24
63