R. R. Ravu et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 23 (2013) 4828–4831
4829
new miltefosine analogs and evaluated their antifungal activities
in vitro and in vivo in a candidiasis mouse model.
Me
N
Me
N
O
P
R1
OH
R1
O
OR2
Me
OH
b
a
N
The available structure–antifungal activity relationship (SAR)
information on alkylphosphocholines was the basis for designing
new compounds in this study. A hydrophobic chain in the miltefo-
sine analogs with 16–18 carbon atoms is necessary for antifungal
activity.16 Reduction of the alkyl chain length to 12 carbon
atoms,16,17 increasing the chain length to 22 carbon atoms,8 or
insertion of ester/amide functionalities in the middle of this
chain16 significantly reduces the antifungal activity. Structurally
more complex alkylglycerophosphocholines exhibit moderate
activities against C. albicans and C. neoformans, when compared
with alkylphosphocholine derivatives.16 Extensive modification of
the N-substitution and the C2 unit of the choline moiety (head
group) resulted in a large number of compounds,17–19 some of
which showed activities more potent than erucylphosphocholine19
that is eight-fold less potent than miltefosine.16 Within this class,
octadecylphosphocholine demonstrates as much as a four-fold in-
crease in in vitro potency against C. albicans when compared to
miltefosine.16 It appears that the intact head group or the presence
of at least two small N-methyl groups plays a key role for anti-
fungal activity. Based on the above SAR information, we decided
to synthesize compounds by slightly modifying the structure of
miltefosine (Fig. 1).
We first designed compound 3a with a benzyl group replacing
one methyl group of the choline structural moiety in miltefosine,
taking into consideration the strong antimicrobial activity of ben-
zalkonium chloride that possesses the benzyldimethylammonio
structural moiety.20 However, the zwitterion nature of 3a makes
it distinctly different from the cationic surface-acting benzalkoni-
um chloride. While this design allows the compound to retain most
of the structural features required for antifungal activity within the
class, it also increases lipophilicity due to the introduction of an
aromatic ring, as indicated by the calculated octane-water parti-
tion coefficient (clogP) from 1.80 for miltefosine to 3.80 for 3a,21
which may improve antifungal properties. The synthetic method
for the preparation of 3a is an adaption of the reported proce-
dures18,22 and is depicted in Scheme 1. Quaternization of
N,N-dimethylaminoethanol (1) with benzyl bromide afforded the
quaternary ammonium salt 2, which was subject to phosphoryla-
tion reaction of n-hexadecanol with POCl3 followed by hydrolysis
to afford the target compound.23
Me
1
Me
2
Me
O
3
R1
R2
c LogP
3a
3b
3c
3d
3e
3f
n-C16H33
n-C14H29
n-C18H37
n-C16H33
n-C16H33
n-C16H33
n-C16H33
n-C16H33
3.80
CH2
2.97
4.49
3.69
3.77
4.29
4.39
4.21
CH2
CH2
O2N
MeO
Cl
CH2
CH2
CH2
3g
3h
Br
CH2
CH2
CH2
3i
n-C16H33
2.38
Scheme 1. Reagents and conditions: (a) R1X, CH3CN, room temperature, 1–3 h; (b)
(1) R2OH, POCl3, Et3N, CHCl3, 0 °C, room temperature, 2 h, (2) pyridine, 2a–2i, 0 °C,
room temperature, 12 h, (3) H2O, room temperature, 1 h.
when compared with 3a (Table 1), and compound 3c was only ac-
tive against C. glabrata with an MIC/MFC of 4.2/4.2 lg/mL, indicat-
ing that C16 is an optimal alkyl chain length.
Keeping a constant C16 alkyl chain, we next synthesized six
analogs (3dÀ3i) with different head groups by replacing one
methyl group of the choline moiety in miltefosine with p-nitroben-
zyl, p-chlorobenzyl, p-bromobenzyl, p-methoxybenzyl, cinnamyl,
and allyl groups. Among these, compound 3d with an N-4-nitro-
benzyl substitution produced the best in vitro activity profiles,
exhibiting slightly improved potency against C. glabrata and A.
fumigatus when compared to miltefosine (Table 1). Compound 3e
with an N-4-methoxybenzyl substitution also showed good activi-
ties similar to 3a and 3d (Table 1). Compounds 3f and 3g with a
halogen-substituted aromatic ring were only active against C. glab-
rata and A. fumigatus, and 3i with an N-allylic substitution, the only
compound without an aromatic ring in this series, was only active
As shown in Table 1, in vitro antifungal testing by the method
described previously24 indicated that compound 3a showed potent
activities with minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) ranging
from 2.5 to 5.0 lg/mL against the opportunistic fungal pathogens
C. albicans, Candida glabrata, Candida krusei, Aspergillus fumigatus,
and C. neoformans. The compound was also fungicidal against all
tested fungal pathogens with minimum fungicidal concentrations
(MFCs)25 from 2.5 to 15.0
l
g/mL. Its antifungal potency is similar
to that of miltefosine with MICs and MFCs of 2.1–3.3 and 2.1–
9.2 g/mL, respectively, against the aforementioned pathogens.
To investigate the influence of the chain length on the anti-
against C. glabrata with an MIC/MFC of 16.6/16.6 lg/mL. It appears
that among the five tested fungal species, C. glabrata is most sus-
ceptible to this series of compounds. Evidently, the minor struc-
tural differences of these compounds, especially for compounds
3a and 3dÀ3g, have a significant effect on their activity profiles.
In addition, the permeability of the compounds towards different
fungal cells, which may be associated with their lipophilicities,
may play a role in the observed activities. Coincidentally, the three
compounds 3a, 3d, and 3e with close chemical structures that
showed excellent activity profiles have similar calculated logp val-
ues ranging from 3.69 to 3.80 (Scheme 1).
The in vitro antifungal activity data of miltefosine obtained in
this study (Table 1) are similar to those reported in the literature.9
The potent activities of the three synthetic analogs (3a, 3d, and 3e)
are further evident by comparison with the ‘gold standard’ clinical
drug amphotericin B. Compounds 3a and 3d that showed strong
l
fungal activity within this series, analogs 3b and 3c with the same
head group but an alkyl chain length of C14 and C18, respectively,
were prepared by a synthetic method similar for 3a. However,
compound 3b showed decreased activity against C. albicans, C.
glabrata, C. krusei, and A. fumigatus in terms of MICs and MFCs
Me
N
O
P
R1
O
O
Me
O
Figure 1. Miltefosine (R1 = Me) based synthetic template.