CHEMBIOCHEM
COMMUNICATIONS
DOI: 10.1002/cbic.201300482
Simplified Deoxypropionate Acyl Chains for
Mycobacterium tuberculosis Sulfoglycolipid Analogues:
Chain Length is Essential for High Antigenicity
Benjamin Gau,[a] Aurꢀlie Lemꢀtais,[b] Marco Lepore,[d] Luis Fernando Garcia-Alles,[a]
Yann Bourdreux,[b] Lucia Mori,[d, e] Martine Gilleron,[a] Gennaro De Libero,[d, e] Germain Puzo,[a]
Jean-Marie Beau,*[b, c] and Jacques Prandi*[a]
Human tuberculosis remains
a major worldwide
health problem, with about 1.5 million casualties
every year. Despite numerous efforts over decades to
implement better diagnosis and extensive availability
of antibiotic treatments, this number is only slowly
decreasing, making tuberculosis still one of the most
lethal infectious diseases in the world.[1] New anti-
biotic treatments against Mycobacterium tuberculosis,
the etiologic agent of human tuberculosis, are
needed.[2] A new vaccinal approach is also mandatory,
because the bacillus of Calmette and Guꢀrin (BCG),
Scheme 1. Structures of the natural Acyl2SGLs 1 from M. tuberculosis.
the only existing vaccine against tuberculosis, does not afford
protection in adults.[3]
conclusion that lipid-specific T-cells are primed during infection
and persist in patients with latent tuberculosis.[6]
In this context, lipidic antigens presented by the CD1 (clus-
ter of differentiation 1) family of proteins might be worth con-
sideration as potential candidates for a subunit vaccine.[4]
Indeed, experimental demonstration of the vaccinal interest of
lipidic antigens in the case of mycobacterial infections was
provided in 2003, when it was shown that immunization of
guinea pigs with an uncharacterized mixture of mycobacterial
lipids improved the pulmonary pathology of the animals after
M. tuberculosis infection.[5] We found strong responses to diac-
ylsulfoglycolipids (Acyl2SGLs, Scheme 1) only in patients with
clinical histories of mycobacterial infection; this supported the
Most of the mycobacterial lipidic antigens characterized so
far are presented by the CD1b protein. Among these antigens,
Acyl2SGLs 1 (Scheme 1) stimulated human CD1b-restricted ab
T-cells to release interferon-g (IFN-g) and to kill intracellular my-
cobacteria residing in M. tuberculosis-infected antigen-present-
ing cells (APCs).[6] The scarcity of this lipid antigen in mycobac-
terial cells prompted us to synthesize Acyl2SGL analogues in
which the hydroxyphthioceranoic acyl unit (Scheme 1) had
been replaced by chiral multiply methylated saturated and
a,b-unsaturated fatty acyl chains.[7]
Some of these analogues were able to stimulate the
Acyl2SGL-specific T-cell clone, with the T-cell response gov-
erned by the presence of the sulfate group,[6] the location of
the fatty acyl chains on the trehalose core, and the fine struc-
ture of the multiply methylated fatty acyl chain, including chir-
ality and number of methyl groups.[7,8]
[a] B. Gau, Dr. L. F. Garcia-Alles, Dr. M. Gilleron, Dr. G. Puzo, Dr. J. Prandi
Institut de Pharmacologie et de Biologie Structurale (IPBS)
CNRS and Universitꢀ de Toulouse
BP 64182, 205 route de Narbonne, 31077 Toulouse (France)
[b] A. Lemꢀtais, Dr. Y. Bourdreux, Prof. J.-M. Beau
Institut de Chimie Molꢀculaire et des Matꢀriaux d’Orsay
Laboratoire de Synthꢁse de Biomolꢀcules, Universitꢀ Paris-Sud and CNRS
Bꢂtiment 430, 91405 Orsay (France)
The very recent total synthesis of an Acyl2SGL with a specific
hydroxyphthioceranoic acyl side chain (1, n=7, Scheme 1) re-
vealed antigenic properties of the synthetic glycolipid identical
to those of the natural mixture of antigens.[9] We show here
that synthetic structures much simpler in their 1,3-methyl-
branched lipid part are as potent as or more potent than the
natural antigens 1. Their synthesis is based on an efficient
preparation of long-chain chiral 1,3-methyl-branched fatty
acids of very high optical purity and on a new sequence of re-
gioselective steps initiated by a tandem catalytic approach for
the one-pot regioselective protection of trehalose. We further
demonstrate the crucial role of the length of the lipid chain in
the antigenic properties of synthetic SGLs.
[c] Prof. J.-M. Beau
Centre de Recherche de Gif
Institut de Chimie des Substances Naturelles du CNRS
Avenue de la Terrasse, 91198 Gif-sur-Yvette (France)
[d] Dr. M. Lepore, Dr. L. Mori, Prof. Dr. G. De Libero
Experimental Immunology, Department of Biomedicine
University Hospital Basel
Hebelstrasse 20, 4031 Basel (Switzerland)
[e] Dr. L. Mori, Prof. Dr. G. De Libero
Singapore Immunology Network (SIgN)
Agency for Science, Technology and Research
8A Biomedical Grove, 138648 Singapore (Singapore)
We devised a new route to the deoxypropionate fatty acids
that overcome the drawbacks (purification and solubility prob-
lems) of our previous synthesis[7] (Scheme 2).
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW under
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/cbic.201300482.
ꢁ 2013 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ChemBioChem 2013, 14, 2413 – 2417 2413