2
H. Liu et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. xxx (2014) xxx–xxx
Ph
activity much less than expected (only 3-fold), and was accompa-
O
O
H
N
nied with reduced CYP3A inhibitory potency (ꢀ3–5-fold), indicat-
ing the lipophilic interaction of RTV with protease contributes
greatly to its activity. The two benzyl groups of RTV interact with
the lipophilic S1 and S10 pockets of HIV protease, thus contribute
to its PI potency, so it was anticipated that modification of either
benzyl group could alter activity against HIV protease. The replace-
ment of either benzyl with an n-propyl (9d and 9e) reduced the
inhibitory activity against HIV by 2–5-fold. When both benzyl
groups were replaced with either ethyl (9f) or methyl (9g), the ana-
N
S
N
a or b
N
N
H
N
H
O
OH
O
S
Ph
1 ritonavir
core
Ph
O
O
H
N
2a R1, R2 : = H
2b R1R2 : = O
N
S
N
N
N
H
O
H
R1 R2
O
S
N
Ph
logs were inactive against HIV-1 (EC50 >30 lM). However, com-
Scheme 1. Synthesis of Compounds 2a/2b. Reagents and conditions: (a) (1) TCDI/
75 °C, (2) AIBN/Bu3SnH/115 °C; (b) Dess–Martin periodinane.
pound 9g has a 3-fold reduction in its inhibition of CYP3A as
well. It seems that the smallest size benzyl replacement at P1/P10
maintaining CYP3A activity is the ethyl. When the stereochemistry
of both benzyl groups was inverted from R,R- to S,S-, the compound
(9i) showed no anti-HIV-1 activity. To simplify the chemistry and
reduce the molecular complexity, both benzyl groups were either
eliminated (9j), or their attachments to the core were shifted to
nitrogen from carbon, which also eliminated the synthetic com-
plexity associated with the two chiral centers (9k). Both com-
pounds 9j and 9k were inactive against HIV protease since
elimination or relocation of the two benzyl groups disrupts their
interaction with S1 and S10 pockets. Compound 9k also eliminated
the hydrogen bond formation of the amines with the HIV protease
backbone. As observed with other anologs, compound 9j also dis-
played reduced ability to inhibit CYP3A, but it is notable that 9k
maintained this activity.
The physicochemical properties, especially aqueous solubility,
of RTV are poor, and one of our goals was to improve physicochem-
ical properties while generating novel CYP3A inhibitors. Polarity
and heteroatoms were introduced to increase the solubility of
the analogs. This could be readily designed-in by the introduction
of hydrazine in the core (9l and 9m). As shown in Scheme 3, hydra-
zine-containing analogs were prepared via a slightly modified syn-
thetic scheme. Carboxylic acid 8 was coupled with amine 10 to
give compound 11. The ester moiety of 11 was reduced to the cor-
responding alcohol, which was subsequently oxidized to aldehyde
12. Reductive amination of 12 with hydrazine 13, prepared from
hydrazine and p-nitrophenylcarbonate 3, provided compound 9l,
which was then treated with benzaldehyde under reducing condi-
tions to generate analog 9m. The profile of compound 9m against
CYP3A and HIV is similar to its carbon counterpart (2a), while com-
pound 9l lost activity against both enzymes.
To study the effect of core length on the anti-HIV activity and
CYP3A inhibitory potency, more analogs with different diamines
(1,2- or 1,3-diamines) were synthesized. These simple 1,2- or
1,3-diamines were either acquired from commercial sources, or
were synthesized following literature procedures. The synthesis
of the 1,3-diamine core of analogs 9r, 9s, 9t, 9u, and 9v is shown
in Scheme 4. Carboxylic acid 14a was esterified with iodomethane
to provide the corresponding methyl ester, which was then
reduced with lithium aluminium hydride (LAH) to alcohol 15a.
Alcohol 15a was converted to mesylate 16a, which was treated
with excess of the targeted amines to form compound 17a. The
synthesis of the 1,2-diamine core analogs 9aa and 9ab was similar
to that of 1,3-diamine core in Scheme 4, except starting from the
corresponding commercially available N-Boc-DL-phenylalaninol
15b in place of alcohol 15a. The 1,2-diamine core of analog 9z
was synthesized using a modified literature procedure from
Fokin.10 These mono-protected or unprotected 1,2- or 1,3-dia-
mines were converted to the final analogs following the same pro-
cedure for analogs with 1,4-diamine core shown in Scheme 2.
Consistent with the lower PI and anti-CYP3A activities observed
with 9g, it was not surprising that 1,3-diamine analogs lacking P1/
P10 moieties (9n, 9o, and 9p) showed reduced activity against both
HIV and CYP3A (Table 2). Re-installation of two benzyl moieties
structure–activity relationship (SAR) exploration. In this and the
following letter, we report our extensive SAR investigation towards
identification of novel human CYP3A inhibitors.7 Here we will de-
tail our SAR studies on the core portion of compound 2a.
It is interesting that 2a has limited reduction of anti-HIV activ-
ity; this serves to highlight the importance of optimized hydropho-
bic interactions contributing significantly to the HIV PI activity of
RTV. We next focused on modifications of the 1,4-diamine core.
Unsymmetric 1,4-disubstituted diamines were synthesized via a
sequence utilizing Julia olefination,8 while symmetric diamines
were prepared from an efficient synthesis newly developed by
us.9 N,N-Dibenzyl 1,4-diamines were produced by reductive ami-
nation of 1,4-butanediamine with benzaldehyde. A general route
for synthesis of analogs containing a modified diamine core is sum-
marized in Scheme 2. Reaction of diamine 4 with p-nitrophenylcar-
bonate 3 afforded monoamines 5. Urea formation via CDI coupling
of thiazolyl amine 6 and L-valine methyl ester 7 was followed by
subsequent ester hydrolysis to produce carboxylic acid 8. Com-
pound 9 was prepared through amide formation from acid 8 and
amine 5.
The CYP3A and HIV protease inhibitory activity data for these
compounds are summarized in Table 1. Compared to compound
2a, introduction of a rigid trans-double bond in the 1,4-diamine
core (9a) significantly reduced anti-HIV-1 activity (35-fold de-
crease). Compound 9h has a similar rigid backbone, and its 2,2-di-
methyl-1,3-dioxolane moiety likely interferes with its binding to
HIV protease, leading to significant loss of activity against HIV pro-
tease (EC50 >30 lM). It is known that both N–H groups of the 1,4-
diamine backbone of RTV form hydrogen bonds with Gly27/227 of
HIV protease. It was thus expected that introduction of a methyl
group (9b and 9c) on either nitrogen atom would be detrimental
to binding affinity for the protease. Both analogs reduced anti-HIV
O2N
O
O
a
S
N
S
N
O
O
H2N
X
N
H
O
core
3
5
H2N
X
4
NH2
O
N
OH
N
S
b
NH
+
N
N
H
OMe
H2N
HCl
O
S
O
O
6
7
8
core
X
O
H
N
S
N
O
N
c
N
N
H
H
N
5
O
S
9
Scheme 2. Synthesis of Compound 9. Reagents and conditions: (a) iPr2NEt; (b) (1)
CDI/iPr2NEt, (2) NaOH/MeOH; (c) HOBt/EDCI/iPr2NEt.