R. Nolla-Saltiel et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 55 (2014) 4484–4488
4487
presence of
p
donor substituents in the para position with respect
structure of 10c was confirmed by the X-ray diffraction analysis).11
The introduction of electron-withdrawing groups at the terminal
aryl ring of the alkyne favored again the nucleophilic addition over
the alkyne. Thus, in the presence of a CF3 group (12a) lactone 12b
was formed in 35% yield while 2H-chromene 12c was formed in
to the carboxylic group (R1 = 4-OMe, 4-Cl) decreased dramatically
the reactivity of 4a–5a, and the desired lactones were only formed
after the addition of 2 equiv of Et3N to the reaction media. In the
presence of Et3N lactones 4b and 6b were obtained in 99% and
81% yields, respectively (entry 1). Substrate 7a with a naphthalene
core also needed the addition of 2 equiv of Et3N to promote the
reaction (entry 2). Non-terminal alkynoic acids in general were
reluctant to react except for the case of 8a (entries 3–6). The addi-
tion of Et3N in the cycloisomerization of 9a–13a led to an insepa-
rable mixture of the desired lactones, and the derivatives obtained
from the substitution reaction with the solvent. With the aim of
achieving full conversion to the lactones, in these cases the reac-
tion was promoted stoichiometrically with the system AgNO3/
PPh3 (1/1 equiv) (entries 4 and 5). Substrate 14a with a chlorine
substituent in the meta position with respect to the carboxylic
group and a methyl at the terminal position of the alkyne, failed
to undergo the cycloisomerization under all the conditions exam-
ined and only decomposition products were observed. Remarkably,
the nature of the substituents at the end of the alkyne modified the
regioselectivity of the reaction. When R2 was a methyl group, a
mixture of seven- and eight-membered ring lactones was formed,
the seven-membered ring lactone being the major isomer (entries
3 and 4). On the other hand, when R2 was an aryl group only the
seven-membered ring lactones were formed (entry 5). This result
can be explained by a more symmetrical coordination of Ag(I) to
the substituted alkyne which reduces the difference in electrophi-
licity of the alkyne carbons.12 Under such coordination mode,
thermodynamic factors govern the orientation of the nucleophilic
addition. Additionally, the double bond of the so-formed seven-
membered ring lactones was always of Z geometry as confirmed
by the NOESY experiment.11 This is in accord with an anti attack
50%.
A more electron-withdrawing group (NO2, 13a) led
exclusively to lactone 13b in 84% yield.
Conclusion
In summary, after studying the cycloisomerizations of alkynoic
acids with Ag(I) and Au(I), it was shown that Au(I) was a superior
catalyst than Ag(I). Regarding the substrates, whereas terminal
alkynoic acids were regioselectively transformed into methylene
seven-membered ring lactones by both metals, the cycloisomeriza-
tion of non-terminal alkynoic was not always regioselective. In
addition, certain non-terminal alkynoic acids gave a divergent
reaction pathway under Au(I) catalysis that led to 2H-chromenes
obtained from the hydroarylation of the alkyne. The rate of
hydroarylation decreased with the introduction of electron-with-
drawing groups. This difference in reactivity must be attributed
to the special coordination mode of Au(I) to alkynes.12c,d,e,f
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by CONACyT (project No. 153523),
DGAPA (project No.IB202212), and Instituto de Química (UNAM).
The authors would like to thank Ma Angeles Peña-González,
Elisabeth
Huerta-Salazar,
Beatriz
Quiroz-García,
Isabel
Chávez-Uribe, Simón Hernández-Ortega, Ma del Rocío Patiño-
Maya, Luis Velasco-Ibarra, and Francisco Javier Pérez-Flores for
technical support (NMR, X-ray diffraction analysis, IR analysis,
and mass spectra).
of the nucleophile to the
g2-alkyne Ag(I) complex.
Concerning cycloisomerizations catalyzed by Au(I), similarly to
what happened with alkynoic acid 1a, the system AuCl(PPh3)/
AgSbF6 was more active than AgSbF6/PPh3 for the cycloisomeriza-
tion of terminal alkynoic acids (Table 3). Thus substrates 2a–7a
were converted into the corresponding seven-membered ring
methylene lactones (2b–7b) with very good yields (85–99%) in
15 min except for the case of alkynoic acid 6a (with a NTs group),
Supplementary data
Supplementary data (experimental details, characterization
data, crystallographic information, and copies of 1H and 13C NMR
spectra for all new compounds) associated with this article can
which took 2 h to complete the reaction. The presence of p-donor
substituents at the para position of the carboxylic group (4a and
5a), did not significantly affect neither the yields nor the reaction
times (entry 1). With respect to non-terminal alkynoic acids, cer-
tain substrates instead of reacting by attack of the carboxylic group
to the activated alkyne, reacted by a hydroarylation reaction path-
way. Alkynoic acid 9a bearing a NTs and a methyl group at the end
of the alkyne behave as expected and analogously to the catalysis
with Ag(I) gave a mixture of seven and eight-membered ring lac-
tones in 90%. Nonetheless changing the NTs group by an oxygen
atom resulted in the exclusive formation of 2H-chromene 8d in
82% after only 15 min of reaction. The structure of 8d was con-
firmed by the X-ray diffraction analysis.11 Au(I) catalyzed hydro-
arylation of alkynes to give 2H-chromenes has been described
even in the presence of deactivating groups,17 but to the best of
our knowledge the competition between nucleophilic addition
and hydroarylation has not been studied before. Substitution of
the alkyne with an aryl group or the introduction of a chlorine
atom into the salicylic phenyl ring (entries 5–8) decreased the
reactivity of alkynoic acids, not being possible to achieve full reac-
tion conversion. For the cycloisomerization of these substrates,
complex AuCl(PPh3) was changed by a more electrophilic one with
a phosphite ligand.15a Using this complex, cycloisomerizations
were completed in 1–1.5 h, although in some cases the yields were
low.18 Alkynoic acids 10a, 11a, and 14a gave the corresponding
2H-chromenes in 80%, 55%, and 50% yields, respectively (the
References and notes