4846
P. J. Lee et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 4845–4849
a major determinant in acquisition of the drug resistance in human
colon cancer cells. Drug-resistant cells were characterized by ele-
vated aerobic glycolysis and higher absolute levels of intracellular
ATP.13 Metabolic reprogramming by tumor cells aimed to inhibit
the H+-ATP synthase activity can be mediated by an overexpression
of the ATPase inhibitory factor 1 (ATPIF1),14 which is a physiolog-
ical inhibitor of the mitochondrial synthase. A number of investiga-
tion demonstrated that the mitochondrial content of ATPIF1
increases significantly in carcinomas, suggesting the participation
of ATPIF1 in oncogenesis.10,11
The expression of ATPIF1 varies significantly in cancer cell lines.
Overexpressed ATPIF1 seemed to activate NF-kB via reactive oxy-
gen species generated from mitochondria in a retrograde fashion.13
The present study evaluated the tumoricidal activities of chry-
sin derivatives which we have chemically synthesized in the con-
text of relative expression of both HO-1 and ATPIF1, which are
known to frequently overexpress in various tumors.5,14 We have
found that the chemical(s) which could upregulate both protein
expressions in cells paradoxically trigger cell death and further
confirmed in colon cancer cell lines, HT29 and HCT116 cells.
First, we have examined the induction of HO-1 in MRC5 cells
with four synthetic chrysin derivatives15 (Fig. 1A). The MRC5 cells
were chosen because the cells are very sensitive to several stimuli,
including heme, lipopolysaccharide and hypoxia treatment, result-
ing in robust induction of HO-1 (Supporting information SI Fig. 1
and not shown). Among four synthetic flavonoids inspired by nat-
ural product from honey, chrysin,1 a substantial induction of HO-1
was demonstrated in MRC5 cells treated with compounds 1 and 4
(Fig. 1B).
concentration-dependent manner (SI Fig. 2). Unexpectedly, how-
ever, compound 4 induced cell death at a 30 M dose (Fig. 1C),
l
with which the induction of HO-1 was nicely achieved with con-
comitant expression of ATPIF1. Despite stronger induction of HO-
1 by compound 1 than compound 4, this flavonoid did not affect
cell viability upon oxidative stress.16 This initial result led us to
hypothesize that upregulation of both HO-1 and ATPIF1 would
affect the cytotoxicity synergistically.17 To test the cytotoxic effect
of C(5), C(7), and C(40)-phenolic hydroxyls in compound 4 and to
confirm the relationship between induction of HO-1/ATPIF1 and
cytotoxic effect of analogues of compound 4, we synthesized ten
derivatives of the flavonoid 4 by methylation of three phenolic
hydroxyl (7–13) or B or D ring modification (5, 6 and 14) in 4
(Fig. 2A). These analogues were easily prepared through the proce-
dures previously developed by Kim and co-workers.15 With those
ten analogues, we have repeated the experiments described above,
and found that compounds 8, 11, and 12 exhibited remarkable
upregulation both HO-1 and ATPIF1 (Fig. 2B and SI Fig. 3). These
structure–activity relationship analysis suggested that protection
of C(7) hydroxyl is crucial for the upregulation both HO-1 and
ATPIF1 and also indicated that C(5) and (or) C(40) hydroxyl are
required for the upregulation both proteins. Modification of B or
D ring in compound 4 (5, 6, and 14) did not affect the co-induction
of HO-1 and ATPIF1 expression. Compound 8 showed most cyto-
toxicity among four synthetic chrysin derivatives (Fig. 2C). How-
ever, compound 14 with robust expression of ATPIF1 but not HO-
1 did not affect cell viability in MRC5 cells (Fig. 2B and C). Cellular
damage upon treatment with compound 8 was accompanied by
the downregulation of anti-apoptotic proteins, Bcl2 and Bcl-xL
(Fig. 2D).
Collectively, these data suggest that some of synthetic chrysin
derivatives selectively induced cell death via inducing apoptosis
in MRC5 cells. The balance between the synthesis and turnover
of ATP might be differentially influenced by these flavonoids.
Indeed the expression of ATPIF-1 was remarkably augmented by
compound 8, but not by compound 1 (Figs. 1B and 2B). Since the
overexpression of ATPIF-1 turns out to diminish ATP production
and impairs mitochondrial membrane potential, reduced ATP pro-
duction by compound 8 may exacerbate the cellular integrity if not
supported by alternative essential components such as heme.
Heme is quintessential factor for many enzymes and electron
transport chains in the mitochondria.18 Heme degradation by
HO-1 activity results in the consumption of the important mole-
cules for diverse cellular processes.18 In this regard, we propose
that the overexpression of both HO-1 and ATPIF1 may trigger cel-
lular damage by synthetic, chrysin derivatives and alteration of cel-
lular energetics by cytotoxic chrysin derivatives can mediate cell
death.
However, the expression of ATPIF1 by compound 1 was negligi-
ble while the expression of the protein by compound 4 was mod-
erate (Fig. 1B). Since it is generally accepted that induction of HO-1
confers cytoprotection against noxious stimuli,4 we tested the
activity of those flavonoids in MRC5 cells primed with low dose
of H2O2. Cell death upon H2O2 treatment was increased in a
1RO
(A)
OMe
D
H
OBn
MeO
B
2RO
O
A
C
O
O
3RO
O
OBn O
2: R1 = Bn, R2 = H, R3 = Bn
1
: R = Bn, R2 = Bn, R3 = Bn
1
3
4
1
: R = H, R2 = H, R3 = H
To gain insights for the activity of chrysin-derived synthetic
flavonoids, we examined the expression of antioxidant enzyme,
HO-1 and cellular energetics in colon cancer cells. The basal
expression of HO-1 was markedly high in HCT116, moderate in
HT29 cells but little in SW480 cells (Fig. 3A and not shown).
HO-1 expression seemed cell-specific since the expression of
DOR-1 was almost same among the colon cancer cells (Fig. 3A).
We sought that administration of chrysin derivatives which aug-
mented ATPIF1 expression could effectively induce cell death in
the context of basal HO-1 expression. Treatment of compound 8
in both HT29 and HCT116 cells exhibited contrasting responses
(B)
(C)
20 μM
30 μM
p<0.05
C
1
2
3
4
p<0.01
HO-1
1.0 3.0 1.1 0.6 1.7
1.0 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.3
β-actin
IF-1
in cell death. Compound 8 at 20 lM evoked cell death only in
−
veh
1
4
μM)
HCT116 cells which basally expressed high levels of HO-1
(Fig. 3B) and exhibited cell death in a time- and dose-dependent
fashion (SI Fig. 4A and B). In addition, compound 8 increased in
ATPIF1 expression as expected (Fig. 3C). To validate the role of
HO-1 in our experimental settings, we did downregulate the activ-
ity or expression of the protein by a chemical inhibitor, zinc
β-actin
H2O2 (100
Figure 1. Upregulation of both HO-1 and ATPIF1 confers sensitivity to MRC5 cells
against H2O2-primed cell death by a chrysin derivative, compound 4. Four synthetic
chrysin derivatives (A). Expression of HO-1 and ATPIF-1 (B). Cytotoxicity of MRC5
cells were treated with chrysin derivatives (C).