Communication
doi.org/10.1002/chem.202005438
Chemistry—A European Journal
was an equilibrium between a 5-coordinate anti-isomer and a
4-coordinate syn-isomer.
escape of ethylene gas from the reaction mixture.[34] Reactions
in closed vials exhibited a lower conversion of 2 to 3 in all
cases (entries 1–5, Table 1), confirming the catalyst’s limited
stability in the presence of ethylene. The slow addition of a
stock solution of 1e to 2 over a period of 1.7 hours in an open
vial allowed ethylene to escape from the reaction mixture. As a
result, a 95% conversion to 3 was achieved (entry 6, Table 1).
The reaction of 2b with ethylene gas revealed slow decom-
position of the alkylidene with formation of free phosphine,
The imido methine resonances of the anti-isomer appear as
two broad signals at 228C and two sharp septets at À408C
(Figure 2), suggesting that rotation of the arylimido group is
restricted at reduced temperatures. The inequivalent methine
resonances coalesce when coordinated PMe3 begins to ex-
change rapidly with free PMe3 at 808C, which results in broad-
ening of the anti-alkylidene proton. In contrast, both methine
protons in the syn-isomer appear as one sharp septet at 228C,
which broadens at À408C. We conclude that rotation of the ar-
ylimido group occurs in a four-coordinate complex,[32] which is
more accessible for the less Lewis acidic syn-isomer due to the
agostic interaction mentioned above.
vinylTMS, propene, and
a new paramagnetic complex
(Scheme 3). The formation of propene can be explained by b-
hydride elimination of the metallacyclobutane 6.[35]
The catalyst 1d is relatively stable in the solution. Thus, we
observed only 35% decomposition of 1d (0.023m, C6D6) at
558C after 11 days, showing that 1d is more thermally stable
compared to Ru(CHPh)(PCy3)2(Cl)2 (50% decomposition after 8
days under the same conditions).[33]
The metathesis activity of complexes 1a–e in the RCM reac-
tion with diallyl N-tosylamide 2 is summarized in Table 1.
Table 1. RCM of 2 catalyzed by 1a–e.
Scheme 3. The reaction of 1b with ethylene.
Notably, the stability of the active species depends on the
catalyst concentration; thus, TON for 1d increases with lower
catalyst loading (entries 4, 7–9, Table 1), suggesting that a bi-
molecular decomposition should be considered as a catalyst
degradation pathway. The methylidene 5 (Scheme 2) is argua-
bly the least sterically hindered complex and thus the most
prone to bimolecular decomposition.[36] However, a 15-fold in-
crease of the catalyst concentration did not lead to a signifi-
cant decrease of TON (9.0 vs. 5.3, entries 7 and 9, Table 1). We
conclude that b-hydride elimination of metallacyclobutane 6,
and not bimolecular decomposition, is the primary degrada-
tion pathway for our system, as is observed for V alkoxide com-
plexes.[23,24]
Entry
Cat.
Cat., mol%
Conv., %[a]
TON
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1a
1b
1c
1d
1e
1e
1d
1d
1d
5
5
5
5
5
5
1
10
15
10 (8)[b]
63 (42)[b]
32 (29)[b]
40 (22)[b]
59 (54)[b]
95[c]
9
72
80
2.0
12.6
6.4
8.0
11.8
19
9.0
7.2
5.3
1
[a] by H NMR. [b] closed vial. [c] slow addition of 1e, 1.7 h.
We have also explored the RCM activity of 1a–e toward sub-
strates containing crotyl groups (Scheme 4). The second prod-
uct of the reactions is but-2-ene (usually, with E:Z ratio ꢀ7:3),
which does not lead to catalyst decomposition. Thus, com-
pound 3 was obtained with high conversion in all cases. The
reaction proceeds slowly at room temperature (42% conver-
sion to 3 in 24 h with catalyst 1d).
Products containing a tosylate (3, 7), an ether (7, 8), a terti-
ary amide (9), a tertiary amine (10), or an ester (11) were also
accessed. However, an alkene capable of chelating to the V
center (11) reacted with low yield in all cases. The metathesis
activity depends on both catalyst and substrate. In particular,
1a gives the highest conversion for 8 while 1c exceeds other
catalysts in the reaction to produce 10. Although 1b and 1e
have a similar activity toward 2; 1b outperforms 1e in the re-
actions containing disubstituted olefins, presumably due to
the steric hindrance resulting from two isopropyl groups and a
large phosphine in 1e. Thus, less sterically demanding 1d ex-
Vanadium chloride alkylidene phosphine complexes are
active catalysts in the RCM reaction of 2. Variations in the
imido group have a significant effect on catalytic activity. Thus,
an increase in imido group size and electron-donating proper-
ties in the order 1a-1c-1d leads to a corresponding increase
in the turnover number (TON, entries 1, 3, and 4, Table 1). An
increase in phosphine size has an even more pronounced
effect on the catalytic activity, as 1b and 1e are the most
active of the five synthesized catalysts (entries 2 and 5,
Table 1).
Following the catalytic reactions by 1H NMR (entry 9,
Table 1), we observed the formation of a new alkylidene spe-
cies (see Supporting Information). Both syn- and anti-alkylidene
signals of 1d and the new alkylidene slowly disappeared over
a few hours, suggesting decomposition of the active species.
Catalytic reactions were conducted in open vials to allow
Chem. Eur. J. 2021, 27, 4578 –4582
4580
ꢀ 2020 Wiley-VCH GmbH