81868$/ꢃꢃ5($&7,9,7<ꢃꢃ2)ꢃꢃ ꢈ$0,123$3$9(5,1(ꢃ
ꢀꢁꢍꢃ
IOXRURDFHWLFꢃ DQK\GULGHꢅꢃ ꢋꢆꢆꢃ PPROꢅꢃ ZDVꢃ DGGHGꢃ WRꢃꢃ
DꢃVROXWLRQꢃRIꢃꢋꢆꢃPPROꢃRIꢃ ꢈDPLQRSDSDYHULQHꢃꢉ,ꢌꢃ>ꢋ@ꢃLQꢃ
ꢋꢆꢆꢃ POꢃ RIꢃ DQK\GURXVꢃ HWK\Oꢃ DFHWDWHꢎꢃ 7KHꢃ PL[WXUHꢃ ZDVꢃ
VWLUUHGꢃIRUꢃꢂꢁꢃKꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃSUHFLSLWDWHꢃZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢃRIIꢃDQGꢃ
UHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢎꢃPSꢃꢋꢆꢀ±ꢋꢋꢋ&ꢃꢉIURPꢃDFHWRQHꢌꢎꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃ
VSHFWUXPꢅꢃ ꢅꢃSSPꢒꢃꢍꢎꢇꢊꢃVꢃꢉꢍ+ꢅꢃ&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢍꢎꢐꢊꢃWꢃꢉꢀ+ꢅꢃ
ꢍ2&+ ꢌꢅꢃ ꢊꢎꢆꢍꢃ Gꢃ ꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ + ꢅꢃ -ꢃ ꢃ ꢊꢃ +]ꢌꢅꢃ ꢊꢎꢋꢐꢃ Pꢃ ꢉꢁ+ꢅꢃ
DFHWLFꢃ DQK\GULGHꢎꢃ 7KHꢃ IRUPDWLRQꢃ RIꢃ LPLGD]RTXLQROLQHꢃ
V\VWHPVꢃ IURPꢃ 1ꢈꢉLVRTXLQROLQꢈꢂꢈ\OPHWK\Oꢌꢃ DPLGHVꢃ ZDVꢃ
UHSRUWHGꢃ SUHYLRXVO\ꢃ >ꢂ@ꢑꢃ KRZHYHUꢅꢃ WKHVHꢃ UHDFWLRQVꢃ
UHTXLUHGꢃVXFKꢃVWURQJꢃFRQGHQVLQJꢃꢃDJHQWVꢃDVꢃSKRVSKRU\Oꢃ
FKORULGHꢎꢃ
7KXVꢃZHꢃKDYHꢃGHPRQVWUDWHGꢃWKHꢃSRVVLELOLW\ꢃIRUꢃWKHꢃ
F\FOL]DWLRQꢃ RIꢃ 1ꢈDF\Oꢈ ꢈDPLQRSDSDYHULQHꢃ GHULYDWLYHVꢃ
LQWRꢃPHWK\OLPLGD]RLVRTXLQROLQHVꢃWRꢃRFFXUꢃXQGHUꢃYHU\ꢃ
PLOGꢃFRQGLWLRQVꢎꢃ
+
ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢁꢄꢃVꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢀꢇꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢅꢁ-ꢃ ꢃꢊꢃ+]ꢌꢎꢃ
)RXQGꢅꢃ Hꢒꢃ &ꢃ ꢄꢋꢎꢋꢐꢑꢃ +ꢃ ꢁꢎꢁꢁꢑꢃ 1ꢃ ꢄꢎꢁꢊꢎꢃ & + ) 1 2 ꢎꢃ
&DOFXODWHGꢅꢃHꢒꢃ&ꢃꢄꢋꢎꢋꢋꢑꢃ+ꢃꢁꢎꢁꢍꢑꢃ1ꢃꢄꢎꢁꢐꢎꢃ
ꢅꢁꢆꢇꢃꢈꢁ'LPHWKR[\SKHQ\OꢉꢁꢊꢃꢋꢁGLPHWKR[\ꢁꢇꢁ
PHWK\OLPLGD]R>ꢌꢃꢅꢁD@LVRTXLQROLQHꢀ K\GURFKORULGHꢀ
ꢆ,,D +&OꢉꢂꢃDꢎꢃ$FHW\OꢃFKORULGHꢅꢃꢋꢆꢆꢃPPROꢅꢃZDVꢃDGGHGꢃ
WRꢃDꢃVROXWLRQꢃRIꢃꢋꢆꢃPPROꢃRIꢃ ꢈDPLQRSDSDYHULQHꢃꢉ,ꢌꢃ>ꢋ@ꢃ
LQꢃꢋꢆꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃDQK\GURXVꢃHWK\OꢃDFHWDWHꢎꢃ7KHꢃPL[WXUHꢃZDVꢃ
VWLUUHGꢃIRUꢃꢂꢁꢃKꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃSUHFLSLWDWHꢃZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢃRIIꢃDQGꢃ
UHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢎꢃPSꢃꢂꢋꢆ±ꢂꢋꢂ&ꢃꢉIURPꢃHWKDQROꢌꢎꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃ
VSHFWUXPꢅꢃ ꢅꢃ SSPꢒꢃ ꢍꢎꢆꢆꢃ Vꢃ ꢉꢍ+ꢅꢃ &+ ꢌꢅꢃ ꢍꢎꢄꢆꢃ Vꢃ ꢉꢍ+ꢅꢃ
2&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢍꢎꢀꢆꢃVꢃꢉꢀ+ꢅꢃꢍ2&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢋꢋꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢅꢃ-ꢃ ꢃꢃ
ꢊꢃ+]ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢍꢆꢃPꢃꢉꢁ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢁꢊꢃVꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢌꢅꢃꢐꢎꢆꢀꢃGꢃ
ꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢅꢃ-ꢃ ꢃꢊꢃ+]ꢌꢎꢃ)RXQGꢅꢃHꢒꢃ&ꢃꢄꢍꢎꢄꢐꢑꢃ+ꢃꢇꢎꢄꢋꢑꢃꢃ
1ꢃ ꢄꢎꢐꢍꢎꢃ & + &O1 2 ꢎꢃ &DOFXODWHGꢅꢃ Hꢒꢃ &ꢃ ꢄꢍꢎꢄꢀꢑꢃꢃ
+ꢃꢇꢎꢇꢀꢑꢃ1ꢃꢄꢎꢊꢇꢎꢀ
1ꢁ>ꢍꢃꢎꢁ'LPHWKR[\LVRTXLQROLQꢁꢅꢁ\OꢆꢇꢃꢈꢁGLPHWKꢁ
R[\SKHQ\OꢉPHWK\O@DFHWDPLGHꢀ ꢆ,,,Dꢃꢀ 1ꢁDFHW\Oꢁ ꢁ
DPLQRSDSDYHULQHꢉꢂꢃ Dꢎꢃ $FHWLFꢃ DQK\GULGHꢅꢃ ꢍꢆꢃ PPROꢅꢃ
ZDVꢃDGGHGꢃWRꢃDꢃVROXWLRQꢃRIꢃꢋꢆꢃPPROꢃRIꢃR[LPHꢃ,9ꢃ>ꢋ@ꢃLQꢃ
ꢐꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃDFHWLFꢃDFLGꢎꢃ=LQFꢃGXVWꢅꢃꢁꢆꢃPPROꢅꢃZDVꢃWKHQꢃ
DGGHGꢃLQꢃVPDOOꢃSRUWLRQVꢃXQGHUꢃVWLUULQJꢅꢃPDLQWDLQLQJꢃWKHꢃ
WHPSHUDWXUHꢃDWꢃꢁꢆ&ꢎꢃ7KHꢃPL[WXUHꢃZDVꢃKHDWHGꢃWRꢃWKHꢃ
ERLOLQJꢃSRLQWꢅꢃFRROHGꢃWRꢃURRPꢃWHPSHUDWXUHꢅꢃDQGꢃILOWHUHGꢅꢃ
WKHꢃILOWUDWHꢃZDVꢃHYDSRUDWHGꢃXQGHUꢃUHGXFHGꢃSUHVVXUHꢅꢃDQGꢃ
WKHꢃUHVLGXHꢃZDVꢃUHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢎꢃ<LHOGꢃꢊꢆHꢅꢃPSꢃꢋꢐꢀ±
ꢋꢀꢋ&ꢃꢉIURPꢃWROXHQHꢌꢎꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃ ꢅꢃSSPꢒꢃꢃ
ꢋꢎꢀꢁꢃVꢃꢉꢍ+ꢅꢃ&2&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢍꢎꢊꢋꢃVꢃꢉꢄ+ꢅꢃ2&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢍꢎꢀꢋꢃVꢃꢉꢄ+ꢅꢃ
2&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢄꢎꢊꢇꢃGꢃꢉꢂ+ꢅꢃ+
ꢅꢃ-ꢃ ꢃꢐꢃ+]ꢌꢅꢃꢄꢎꢐꢄꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃꢃ
Eꢀꢃ$ꢃ PL[WXUHꢃ RIꢃ ꢋꢆꢃ PPROꢃ RIꢃ 1ꢈDFHW\Oꢈ ꢈDPLQRSDꢈ
SDYHULQHꢃ,,,DꢃDQGꢃꢇꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃSKRVSKRU\OꢃFKORULGHꢃZDVꢃ
KHDWHGꢃIRUꢃꢋꢂꢃKꢃXQGHUꢃUHIOX[ꢎꢃ7KHꢃPL[WXUHꢃZDVꢃHYDSꢈ
RUDWHGꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃSUHFLSLWDWHꢃZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢃRIIꢃDQGꢃUHFU\Vꢈ
WDOOL]HGꢎꢃ<LHOGꢃꢊꢆHꢎꢃꢃ
ꢈ&+1+ꢅꢁ-ꢃ ꢃ ꢐꢃ +]ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢆꢍꢃ Vꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ + ꢌꢅꢃ ꢊꢎꢂꢍꢃ Vꢃ ꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ
+
ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢁꢐꢃVꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢇꢍꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢅꢁ-ꢃ ꢃꢄꢃ+]ꢌꢅꢃ
ꢐꢎꢂꢀꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢅꢃ-ꢃ ꢃꢄꢃ+]ꢌꢅꢃꢐꢎꢄꢇꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ1+ꢅꢃ-ꢃ ꢃꢃ
ꢐꢃ+]ꢌꢎꢃ &ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃ ꢅꢃSSPꢒꢃꢂꢍꢅꢁꢄꢃꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃꢇꢀꢎꢀꢋꢃ
ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢇꢄꢎꢋꢇꢃ ꢉꢁ&ꢅꢃ 2&+ ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢆꢍꢎꢐꢀꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢆꢄꢎꢋꢐꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ
ꢋꢋꢂꢎꢋꢄꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢋꢂꢎꢊꢇꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢋꢀꢎꢊꢄꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢂꢆꢎꢊꢄꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ
ꢋꢂꢋꢎꢀꢂꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢍꢍꢎꢊꢆꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢍꢇꢎꢆꢊꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢁꢆꢎꢂꢇꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ
ꢋꢁꢐꢎꢄꢍꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢁꢀꢎꢍꢆꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢇꢆꢎꢄꢂꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ ꢋꢇꢍꢎꢋꢍꢃ ꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃ
ꢋꢇꢊꢎꢆꢄꢃꢉꢋ&ꢌꢅꢃꢋꢄꢐꢎꢄꢆꢃꢉꢋ&ꢅꢃ&2&+ ꢌꢎꢃ0DVVꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃꢃ
Pꢏ]ꢃꢉ, ꢅꢃHꢌꢒꢃꢍꢀꢄꢃꢉꢇꢋꢌꢃ>0@ ꢅꢃꢍꢇꢍꢃꢉꢋꢆꢆꢌꢅꢃꢂꢋꢇꢃꢉꢂꢆꢌꢅꢃꢋꢄꢄꢃ
ꢉꢂꢁꢌꢅꢃꢁꢍꢃꢉꢂꢂꢌꢎꢃ)RXQGꢅꢃHꢒꢃ&ꢃꢄꢄꢎꢊꢆꢑꢃ+ꢃꢄꢎꢂꢄꢑꢃ1ꢃꢊꢎꢋꢁꢎꢃ
& + 1 2 ꢎꢃ&DOFXODWHGꢅꢃHꢒꢃ&ꢃꢄꢄꢎꢄꢇꢑꢃ+ꢃꢄꢎꢋꢆꢑꢃ1ꢃꢊꢎꢆꢊꢎꢃ
Fꢎꢃ$ꢃ PL[WXUHꢃ RIꢃ ꢋꢆꢃ PPROꢃ RIꢃ 1ꢈDFHW\Oꢈ ꢈDPLQRSDꢈ
SDYHULQHꢃ,,,DꢅꢃꢂꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃꢍꢊHꢃK\GURFKORULFꢃDFLGꢅꢃDQGꢃꢃ
ꢁꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃZDWHUꢃZDVꢃKHDWHGꢃIRUꢃꢋꢂꢃKꢃXQGHUꢃUHIOX[ꢎꢃ7KHꢃ
PL[WXUHꢃ ZDVꢃ HYDSRUDWHGꢅꢃ DQGꢃ WKHꢃ UHVLGXHꢃ ZDVꢃ UHFU\Vꢈ
WDOOL]HGꢎꢃ<LHOGꢃꢀꢆHꢎꢃꢃ
ꢅꢁꢆꢇꢃꢈꢁ'LPHWKR[\SKHQ\OꢉꢁꢊꢃꢋꢁGLPHWKR[\ꢁꢇꢁ
PHWK\OLPLGD]R>ꢌꢃꢅꢁD@LVRTXLQROLQHꢀꢆ,,Dꢉꢂꢃ$ꢃPL[WXUHꢃRIꢃ
ꢋꢆꢃPPROꢃRIꢃFRPSRXQGꢃ,,,DꢃDQGꢃꢇꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃDFHWLFꢃ
DQK\GULGHꢃZDVꢃKHDWHGꢃIRUꢃꢇꢃKꢃXQGHUꢃUHIOX[ꢎꢃ7KHꢃPL[WXUHꢃ
ZDVꢃSRXUHGꢃLQWRꢃZDWHUꢃDQGꢃPDGHꢃDONDOLQHꢃE\ꢃDGGLQJꢃ
DTXHRXVꢃDPPRQLDꢅꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃSUHFLSLWDWHꢃZDVꢃILOWHUHGꢃRIIꢃ
DQGꢃ UHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢎꢃ <LHOGꢃ ꢀꢇHꢅꢃ PSꢃ ꢋꢋꢂ±ꢋꢋꢁ&ꢃ ꢉIURPꢃ
WROXHQHꢌꢎꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃ ꢅꢃSSPꢒꢃꢂꢎꢄꢂꢃVꢃꢉꢍ+ꢅꢃ&+ ꢌꢅꢃ
ꢍꢎꢇꢀꢃVꢃꢉꢍ+ꢅꢃ2&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢍꢎꢐꢇꢃVꢃꢉꢀ+ꢅꢃꢍ2&+ ꢌꢅꢃꢄꢎꢊꢀꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ
Eꢀꢀ$FHWLFꢃDQK\GULGHꢅꢃꢋꢆꢃPPROꢅꢃZDVꢃDGGHGꢃWRꢃDꢃVRꢈ
OXWLRQꢃ RIꢃ ꢋꢆꢃ PPROꢃ RIꢃ ꢈDPLQRSDSDYHULQHꢃ ꢉ,ꢌꢃ >ꢋ@ꢃ LQꢃꢃ
ꢋꢆꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃHWK\OꢃDFHWDWHꢎꢃ$IWHUꢃꢂꢁꢃKꢅꢃWKHꢃSUHFLSLWDWHꢃRIꢃ
DPLGHꢃ ,,,Dꢃ ZDVꢃ ILOWHUHGꢃ RIIꢃ DQGꢃ UHFU\VWDOOL]HGꢎꢃ <LHOGꢃ
ꢀꢀHꢅꢃPSꢃꢋꢐꢀ±ꢋꢀꢋ&ꢃꢉIURPꢃWROXHQHꢌꢎꢃ
1ꢁ>ꢍꢃꢎꢁ'LPHWKR[\LVRTXLQROLQꢁꢅꢁ\OꢆꢇꢃꢈꢁGLPHWKꢁ
R[\SKHQ\OꢉPHWK\O@ꢁꢏꢃꢏꢃꢏꢁWULIOXRURDFHWDPLGHꢀ ꢆ,,,Eꢃꢀ
1ꢁWULIOXRURDFHW\Oꢁ ꢁDPLQRSDSDYHULQHꢉꢂꢃ 7ULIOXRURꢈ
DFHWLFꢃDQK\GULGHꢅꢃꢋꢆꢃPPROꢅꢃZDVꢃDGGHGꢃWRꢃDꢃVROXWLRQꢃRIꢃ
ꢋꢆꢃPPROꢃRIꢃ ꢈDPLQRSDSDYHULQHꢃꢉ,ꢌꢃ>ꢋ@ꢃLQꢃꢋꢆꢆꢃPOꢃRIꢃ
HWK\OꢃDFHWDWHꢎꢃ$IWHUꢃꢂꢁꢃKꢅꢃWKHꢃPL[WXUHꢃZDVꢃHYDSRUDWHGꢃ
XQGHUꢃ UHGXFHGꢃ SUHVVXUHꢅꢃ WKHꢃ UHVLGXHꢃ ZDVꢃ GLVVROYHGꢃ LQꢃ
DFHWRQHꢅꢃDQGꢃꢇꢃPOꢃRIꢃDTXHRXVꢃDPPRQLDꢃZDVꢃDGGHGꢃWRꢃ
WKHꢃ VROXWLRQꢎꢃ 7KHꢃ SUHFLSLWDWHꢃ ZDVꢃ ILOWHUHGꢃ RIIꢃ DQGꢃ UHꢈ
FU\VWDOOL]HGꢎꢃ<LHOGꢃꢇꢆHꢅꢃPSꢃꢋꢂꢀ±ꢋꢍꢋ&ꢃꢉIURPꢃ0H2+ꢌꢎꢃ
+
ꢅꢁ-ꢃ ꢃꢊꢃ+]ꢌꢅꢃꢄꢎꢀꢀꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢅꢃ-ꢃ ꢃꢊꢃ+]ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢆꢀꢃVꢃ
ꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢋꢐꢃPꢃꢉꢂ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢌꢅꢃꢊꢎꢇꢋꢃVꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢌꢅꢃ
ꢊꢎꢄꢀꢃGꢃꢉꢋ+ꢅꢃ+ ꢅꢃ-ꢃ ꢃꢊꢃ+]ꢌꢎꢃ0DVVꢃVSHFWUXPꢅꢃPꢏ]ꢃꢃ
ꢉ, ꢅꢃHꢌꢒꢃꢍꢊꢐꢃꢉꢋꢆꢆꢌꢃ>0@ ꢅꢃꢍꢄꢍꢃꢉꢍꢍꢌꢅꢃꢋꢐꢀꢃꢉꢁꢆꢌꢎꢃ)RXQGꢅꢃHꢒꢃ
&ꢃꢄꢀꢎꢀꢍꢑꢃ+ꢃꢇꢎꢀꢐꢑꢃ1ꢃꢊꢎꢍꢐꢎꢃ& + 1 2 ꢎꢃ&DOFXODWHGꢅꢃHꢒꢃ
&ꢃꢄꢀꢎꢐꢍꢑꢃ+ꢃꢇꢎꢐꢄꢑꢃ1ꢃꢊꢎꢁꢆꢎꢃꢃ
ꢅꢁꢆꢇꢃꢈꢁ'LPHWKR[\SKHQ\OꢉꢁꢊꢃꢋꢁGLPHWKR[\ꢁꢇꢁWULꢁ
IOXRURPHWK\OLPLGD]R>ꢌꢃꢅꢁD@LVRTXLQROLQHꢀꢆ,,Eꢉꢂꢃ7ULꢈ
5866,$1ꢃꢃ-2851$/ꢃꢃ2)ꢃꢃ25*$1,&ꢃꢃ&+(0,675<ꢃꢃꢃ9ROꢎꢃꢃꢁꢂꢃꢃꢃ1Rꢎꢃꢃꢄꢃꢃꢃꢂꢆꢆꢄꢃ