Organic Letters
Letter
reduction of fluorinated pyridines with rhodium catalysts,21
pyridines with titanium catalysts22 and α,β-unsaturated ketones
with a B(C6F5)3/phosphine intermolecular FLP.23
In the event, introducing PhSiH3 into the reaction mixture
dramatically improved the reduction of 2-phenyl-6-methylpyr-
idine (7a) (Table 1).24 Adding 2 equiv of PhSiH3 to the
hydrogenation because of the electron-donating triazolylidene
and the decreased steric hindrance provided by the presence of
one C−H bond adjacent to the nascent borenium ion. In situ
activation of this precatalyst is accomplished by hydride
Table 1. Optimization of the Reaction Conditions for 2,6-
Disubstituted Pyridine 7a
a
−
abstraction with Ph3C+B(C6F5)4 . The high reactivity of the
borenium ion generated in this manner requires the use of
solvents with low coordinating ability, such as 1,2-dichloro-
ethane (DCE) or toluene (Table S1). With these preliminary
activation parameters in hand, we investigated the hydro-
genation of 2,6-diphenylpyridine (3), which is a bulky Lewis
base known to form FLPs with Lewis acids such as B(C6F5)3
(eq 1).19
b
equiv of
silane
pressure
(bar)
temp.
yield
entry
solvent
(°C)
(conv)
c
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
0
0
DCM
DCE
DCE
103
90
50
50
50
50
50
RT
90
90
RT
RT
RT
40
33
40 (41)
84 (100)
52 (61)
52 (69)
67 (65)
87 (96)
Reaction of 3 with catalyst 1+ under a high pressure of
hydrogen gave the desired piperidine product 4 in 36−48%
the temperature, catalyst loading, or reaction time did not
significantly increase the yield of the product, suggesting issues
with product inhibition or catalyst decomposition. To test this
2.0
1.5
1.1
1.5
1.5
DCE
PhMe
PhMe
PhMe
a
All of the reactions were carried out on a 0.125 mmol scale of 7a
over 19 h. Yields are based on H NMR analysis in the presence of
b
1
i
hypothesis, we treated 1+ with Pr2NH as a surrogate for the
c
an internal standard. Entry 1 was taken from ref 16.
reaction product (Scheme 2A). Heating this mixture at 90 °C
Scheme 2. Borenium Ion Deactivation Pathway
reaction mixture resulted in complete conversion to piperidine
8a in 84% yield and full conversion (entry 3), compared with
only 40% yield without silane (entry 2), while decreasing the
required dihydrogen pressure by almost half (90 bar vs 50 bar).
Even at room temperature with a lower number of equivalents
of silane (entry 6), we were able to achieve 67% yield at 50 bar
H2. Increasing the temperature to 40 °C gave our optimal
conditions, resulting in 87% yield of the product with 96%
conversion (entry 7).
for 4 days resulted in complete decomposition of 1+. A broad
With viable conditions in hand, we examined the scope of
this transformation. Electron-neutral and electron-rich sub-
strates were reduced in excellent yields (7a−c), but electron-
deficient pyridines required elevated temperatures. Heating to
90 °C was sufficient for the reduction of trifluoromethylated
substrate 7d and chlorinated arylpyridine 7e. It is important to
note that for 7d we did not observe hydrodefluorination, which
has been observed with highly electrophilic silicon and
aluminum cations.25 π-Extended derivative 7f was reduced
without concomitant reduction of the naphthyl group. Less
sterically demanding 2,6-lutidine (7g) was also reduced to give
8g in 47% yield, and 50% of 7g was recovered. Unfortunately,
pyridine substrates containing very large substituents such as
2,4,6-triisopropylphenyl in 7h or lacking steric protection
around nitrogen as in 7i are not amenable to reduction with
the current protocol. In the case of 7h, the starting material
was recovered largely intact, with only trace protodebromina-
singlet at 47.8 ppm in the 11B NMR spectrum is assigned to
1
amino borane 5. A singlet at 8.95 ppm in the H NMR
spectrum of the crude reaction mixture indicates the presence
of triazolium salt 6. The presence of both 5 and 6 in the
reaction mixture was confirmed by high-resolution mass
spectrometry (HRMS).
Although our group has not previously observed catalyst
decomposition of this type, this reactivity is not unprece-
dented. Bourissou and co-workers reported C−B bond
protonolysis in a phosphine-stabilized borenium ion in the
presence of Ph2NH.20 A two-step mechanism was proposed, in
which coordination of the amine to the boron center takes
place, followed by boron−carbon bond scission.
To decrease the likelihood of amine-promoted catalyst
decomposition, we examined a combined hydrosilylation and
hydrogenation approach. We envisioned two possible
beneficial effects of the silane. First, the weaker, more polarized
Si−H bond might be more easily activated by the FLP,
resulting in a milder process. Second, the silyl group would
increase the steric bulk of the Lewis basic product, deterring
adduct formation with the catalyst, facilitating catalyst
turnover, and decreasing catalyst decomposition.
1
tion detected by H NMR spectroscopy.
The reaction was found to be highly diastereoselective in all
cases, giving the cis-2,6-arylmethylpiperidine products with
typically greater than 97:3 selectivity (Scheme 3). DFT
calculations by Li et al. indicated that this high degree of
stereoselectivity is a result of a lower energy barrier for the final
hydrogenation step as well as the stability of the final product,
in which both the methyl and phenyl substituents occupy
equatorial positions.26
The concept of dearomatization/hydrogenation cascades has
been explored with other catalysts and has been shown to be a
useful tool for sensitive or difficult substrates, including the
B
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX