9ꢍꢃ.29*$1.2ꢆꢃꢃ1ꢍꢃ.29*$1.2ꢃ
ꢀꢁꢎꢃ
&RPSRXQGꢃ9,ꢃZDVꢃFKDUDFWHUL]HGꢃE\ꢃXSILHOGꢃVKLIWꢃRIꢃWKHꢃ YLEUDWLRQꢃEDQGVꢃLQꢃWKHꢃUHJLRQꢃꢀꢂꢅꢅ±ꢀꢄꢅꢅꢃFP ꢆꢃDQGꢃQRꢃ
PXOWLSOHWꢃVLJQDOVꢃIURPꢃꢀꢈ+ꢃDQGꢃ& + ꢃꢊ ꢃꢀꢍꢎꢅꢃDQGꢃꢉꢍꢎꢋ± 2+ꢃSURWRQꢃVLJQDOVꢃZHUHꢃREVHUYHGꢃLQꢃWKHLUꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃ
ꢉꢍꢏꢎꢃ SSPꢆꢃ UHVSHFWLYHO\ꢌꢃ UHODWLYHꢃ WRꢃ WKHꢃ FRUUHVSRQGLQJꢃ VSHFWUDꢍꢃ7KHꢃꢀꢈ+ꢃVLJQDOVꢃLQꢃWKHꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUDꢃRIꢃ
,;D±,;Fꢃ DSSHDUHGꢃ aꢅꢍꢉꢃ SSPꢃ GRZQILHOGꢃ UHODWLYHꢃ WRꢃꢃ
WKHꢃFRUUHVSRQGLQJꢃVLJQDOVꢃRIꢃDOFRKROVꢃ9,,D±9,,Fꢍꢃ7KHꢃ
REVHUYHGꢃ YDULDWLRQꢃ RIꢃ WKHꢃ FKHPLFDOꢃ VKLIWꢃ LVꢃ W\SLFDOꢃ RIꢃ
UHSODFHPHQWꢃRIꢃK\GUR[\ꢃJURXSꢃE\ꢃFKORULQHꢃDWRPꢍꢃ,Qꢃ
DGGLWLRQꢆꢃ VLJQDOVꢃ IURPꢃ WKHꢃ & + ꢃ EHQ]\OLFꢃ SURWRQVꢃ
FKDQJHGꢃ WKHLUꢃ PXOWLSOLFLW\ꢃ DQGꢃ SRVLWLRQꢃ E\ꢃ ꢅꢍꢉꢇ±ꢃ
ꢅꢍꢉꢁꢃSSPꢃXSILHOGꢍꢃ
VLJQDOVꢃLQꢃWKHꢃVSHFWUXPꢃRIꢃGLROꢃ9ꢍꢃ
:LWKꢃDꢃYLHZꢃWRꢃREWDLQꢃOLTXLGꢃFU\VWDOOLQHꢃFRPSRXQGVꢃ
ZLWKꢃVLGHꢈFKDLQꢃK\GUR[\ꢃJURXSꢃDQGꢃꢉꢆꢀꢈGLROꢃPRLHW\ꢆꢃ
DOFRKROVꢃ9ꢃDQGꢃ9,ꢃZHUHꢃVXEMHFWHGꢃWRꢃEHQ]\ODWLRQꢃDWꢃWKHꢃ
SKHQROLFꢃK\GUR[\ꢃJURXSꢃZLWKꢃVXEVWLWXWHGꢃEHQ]\Oꢃ
FKORULGHVꢍꢃ:HꢃWKXVꢃEXLOWꢃXSꢃWKHꢃFHQWUDOꢃSRO\F\FOLFꢃSDUWꢃ
RIꢃ OLTXLGꢃ FU\VWDOOLQHꢃ FRPSRXQGVꢃ ZLWKꢃ EULGJLQJꢃ 2&+ ꢃ
PRLHW\ꢍꢃ7UHDWPHQWꢃRIꢃSKHQROꢃ9ꢃZLWKꢃVXEVWLWXWHGꢃEHQ]\Oꢃ
3KDVHꢃWUDQVLWLRQꢃVWXG\ꢃVKRZHGꢃWKDWꢃDOOꢃEHQ]\OꢃHWKHUVꢃ
FKORULGHVꢃLQꢃWKHꢃSUHVHQFHꢃRIꢃSRWDVVLXPꢃFDUERQDWHꢃDQGꢃ 9,,±,;ꢃH[KLELWꢃPHVRPRUSKLFꢃSURSHUWLHVꢃDQGꢃJLYHꢃULVHꢃ
VRGLXPꢃ LRGLGHꢃ OHGꢃ WRꢃ IRUPDWLRQꢃ RIꢃ WKHꢃ FRUUHVSRQGLQJꢃ WRꢃVPHFWLFꢃPHVRSKDVHꢃꢊVHHꢃWDEOHꢌꢍꢃ$PRQJꢃWKHVHꢆꢃRQO\ꢃ
EHQ]\OꢃHWKHUVꢃ9,,,D±9,,,FꢃZLWKꢃDꢃVLGHꢈFKDLQꢃꢉꢆꢀꢈGLROꢃ FRPSRXQGꢃ 9,,,Dꢃ IRUPHGꢃ PRQRWURSLFꢃ VPHFWLFꢃ SKDVHꢆꢃ
PRLHW\ꢃ LQꢃ KLJKꢃ SUHSDUDWLYHꢃ \LHOGVꢍꢃ 8QGHUꢃ WKHꢃ JLYHQꢃ ZKLOHꢃWKHꢃRWKHUꢃFRPSRXQGVꢃIRUPHGꢃHQDQWLRWURSLFꢃOLTXLGꢃ
FRQGLWLRQVꢆꢃ RQO\ꢃ WKHꢃ SKHQROLFꢃ K\GUR[\ꢃ JURXSꢃ ZDVꢃ FU\VWDOOLQHꢃ SKDVHꢍꢃ +\GUR[\ꢈꢃ DQGꢃ FKORURꢈVXEVWLWXWHGꢃ
LQYROYHGꢃLQꢃHWKHULILFDWLRQꢆꢃZKLOHꢃWKHꢃDOFRKROLFꢃK\GUR[\ꢃ HWKHUVꢃ9,,D±9,,FꢃDQGꢃ,;D±,;FꢃJDYHꢃVPHFWLFꢃSKDVHꢃ8ꢃ
JURXSVꢃUHPDLQHGꢃLQWDFWꢍꢃ/LNHZLVHꢆꢃIURPꢃSKHQROꢃ9,ꢃZHꢃ LQꢃDꢃIDLUO\ꢃEURDGꢃWHPSHUDWXUHꢃUDQJHꢍꢃ,QꢃDGGLWLRQꢆꢃFRPꢈ
REWDLQHGꢃꢎꢎ±ꢏꢄ:ꢃRIꢃEHQ]\OꢃHWKHUVꢃ9,,D±9,,FꢃFRQWDLQꢈ
LQJꢃRQHꢃK\GUR[\ꢃJURXSꢃLQꢃWKHꢃVLGHꢃFKDLQꢍꢃꢃ
7KHꢃ VWUXFWXUHꢃ RIꢃ EHQ]\Oꢃ HWKHUVꢃ 9,,D±9,,Fꢃ DQGꢃ
9,,,D±9,,,FꢃZDVꢃFRQILUPHGꢃE\ꢃ,5ꢃDQGꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃVSHFꢈ
WURVFRS\ꢍꢃ7KHꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃVSHFWUDꢃRIꢃ9,,D±9,,FꢃDQGꢃ
9,,,D±9,,,FꢃFRQWDLQHGꢃDꢃVLQJOHWꢃDWꢃ ꢃꢇꢍꢅꢏ±ꢇꢍꢉꢁꢃSSPꢆꢃ
SRXQGVꢃ 9,,Eꢆꢃ 9,,Fꢆꢃ DQGꢃ ,;D±,;Fꢃ IRUPHGꢃ VPHFWLFꢃ
SKDVHꢃ6ꢍꢃ$VꢃIROORZVꢃIURPꢃWKHꢃGDWDꢃLQꢃWDEOHꢆꢃUHSODFHPHQWꢃ
RIꢃWKHꢃK\GUR[\ꢃJURXSꢃLQꢃ9,,ꢃE\ꢃFKORULQHꢃDWRPꢃQRWꢃRQO\ꢃ
UHGXFHVꢃWKHꢃWHPSHUDWXUHꢃRIꢃIRUPDWLRQꢃRIꢃVPHFWLFꢃSKDVHꢃ
EXWꢃDOVRꢃH[WHQGVꢃLWVꢃWHPSHUDWXUHꢃUDQJHꢍꢃꢃ
7KLVꢃ VWXG\ꢃ ZDVꢃ SHUIRUPHGꢃ XQGHUꢃ ILQDQFLDOꢃ VXSSRUWꢃ
EHORQJLQJꢃ WRꢃ WKHꢃ EHQ]LOLFꢃ &+ 2ꢃ JURXSꢍꢃ 7KHꢃ SRVLWLRQꢃ E\ꢃWKHꢃ%\HORUXVVLDQꢃ5HSXEOLFDQꢃ)RXQGDWLRQꢃIRUꢃ%DVLFꢃ
DQGꢃPXOWLSOLFLW\ꢃRIꢃVLJQDOVꢃIURPꢃSURWRQVꢃLQꢃWKHꢃVLGHꢃ
FKDLQꢃRIꢃWKHVHꢃFRPSRXQGVꢃZHUHꢃDOPRVWꢃWKHꢃVDPHꢃDVꢃLQꢃ
WKHꢃVSHFWUDꢃRIꢃSDUHQWꢃSKHQROVꢃ9,ꢃDQGꢃ9ꢍꢃ
5HVHDUFKꢃꢊSURMHFWꢃQRꢍꢃ.Kꢅꢋ0ꢈꢉꢉꢎꢌꢍꢃ
(;3(5,0(17$/ꢃ
%HQ]\OꢃHWKHUVꢃ9,,D±9,,FꢃZHUHꢃWUHDWHGꢃZLWKꢃWKLRQ\Oꢃ
FKORULGHꢃWRꢃREWDLQꢃQHZꢃOLTXLGꢃFU\VWDOOLQHꢃFRPSRXQGVꢃ
KDYLQJꢃDꢃFKORULQHꢃDWRPꢃLQꢃWKHꢃVLGHꢃFKDLQꢍꢃ$VꢃDꢃUHVXOWꢆꢃ
FRPSRXQGVꢃ ,;D±,;Fꢃ ZHUHꢃ LVRODWHGꢃ LQꢃ ꢂꢏ±ꢎꢅ:ꢃ \LHOGꢍꢃ
7KHꢃ,5ꢃVSHFWUDꢃRIꢃ,;D±,;FꢃODFNHGꢃ2+ꢃVWUHWFKLQJꢃ
7KHꢃ ,5ꢃ VSHFWUDꢃ ZHUHꢃ PHDVXUHGꢃ IURPꢃ VROXWLRQVꢃ LQꢃ
FKORURIRUPꢃRQꢃDꢃ6SHFRUGꢃꢁꢇ,5ꢃVSHFWURPHWHUꢍꢃ7KHꢃ89ꢃ
VSHFWUDꢃZHUHꢃUHFRUGHGꢃIURPꢃVROXWLRQVꢃLQꢃHWKDQROꢃRQꢃꢃ
Dꢃ6SHFRUGꢃ0ꢈꢋꢅꢃVSHFWURSKRWRPHWHUꢍꢃ7KHꢃ +ꢃ105ꢃ
VSHFWUDꢃZHUHꢃREWDLQHGꢃRQꢃDꢃ%UXNHUꢃ$YDQFHꢃꢋꢅꢅꢃLQVWUXꢈ
PHQWꢃꢊꢋꢅꢅꢃ0+]ꢌꢃXVLQJꢃS\ULGLQHꢈq ꢃDVꢃVROYHQWꢃDQGꢃ
+0'6ꢃDVꢃLQWHUQDOꢃUHIHUHQFHꢍꢃ7KHꢃSURJUHVVꢃRIꢃUHDFWLRQVꢃ
ZDVꢃ PRQLWRUHGꢆꢃ DQGꢃ WKHꢃ SXULW\ꢃ RIꢃ SURGXFWVꢃ ZDVꢃ
FKHFNHGꢆꢃE\ꢃWKLQꢈOD\HUꢃFKURPDWRJUDSK\ꢃRQꢃ.LHVHOJHOꢃ
ꢂꢅꢃ) ꢃSODWHVꢃꢊ0HUFNꢌꢍꢃ7KHꢃPHOWLQJꢃSRLQWVꢃDQGꢃSKDVHꢃ
WUDQVLWLRQꢃWHPSHUDWXUHVꢃZHUHꢃGHWHUPLQHGꢃXVLQJꢃDꢃPHOWꢈ
LQJꢃ SRLQWꢃ DSSDUDWXVꢃ FRXSOHGꢃ ZLWKꢃ Dꢃ SRODUL]LQJꢃ PLFURꢈ
VFRSHꢍꢃ 0HVRSKDVHVꢃ ZHUHꢃ LGHQWLILHGꢃ E\ꢃ FRPSDULQJꢃ WKHꢃ
REVHUYHGꢃ WH[WXUHꢃ ZLWKꢃ WKHꢃ FRUUHVSRQGLQJꢃ VWDQGDUGVꢃ
>ꢉꢁ@ꢍꢃ7KHꢃSKDVHꢃWUDQVLWLRQꢃWHPSHUDWXUHVꢃRIꢃFRPSRXQGVꢃ
9,,±,;ꢃDUHꢃJLYHQꢃLQꢃWDEOHꢍꢃ
3KDVHꢃWUDQVLWLRQꢃWHPSHUDWXUHVꢃRIꢃFRPSRXQGVꢃ9,,±,; ꢃ
&RPSꢍꢃ
QRꢍꢃ
PSꢆꢃ&ꢃ6PHFWLFꢃSKDVHꢃ U ꢆꢃ&ꢃ6PHFWLFꢃSKDVHꢃ U ꢆꢃ&ꢃ
8 ꢊ6P8ꢌꢃ
6ꢃꢊ6P6ꢌꢃ
ꢉꢉꢏꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢄꢎꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢉꢎꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢄꢇꢍꢇꢃ
ꢉꢋꢂꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢋꢂꢍꢇꢃ
ꢅꢇꢂꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢅꢋꢍꢅꢃ
ꢅꢏꢉꢍꢅꢃ
ꢃ
±ꢃ
ꢉꢀꢏꢃ
ꢉꢋꢇꢃ
±ꢃ
±ꢃ
ꢉꢄꢎꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢋꢄꢍꢇꢃ
ꢉꢋꢁꢍꢅꢃ
±ꢃ
ꢉꢋꢁꢍꢇꢃ
ꢉꢇꢉꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢅꢏꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢀꢎꢍꢅꢃ
ꢉꢋꢀꢍꢇꢃ
9,,Dꢃ
9,,Eꢃ
9,,Fꢃ
9,,,Dꢃ
9,,,Eꢃ
9,,,Fꢃ
,;Dꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃꢊ6PYꢌꢃ
±ꢃ
ꢃ
±ꢃ
±ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢃ
±ꢃ
±ꢃ
ꢃ
ꢉꢅꢄꢃ
ꢉꢀꢄꢃ
ꢉꢀꢋꢃ
ꢃ
ꢂꢃꢄꢅꢃ+\GUR[\SKHQ\OꢆRFWDQHꢃꢂꢇꢈꢃGLRO ꢄ9ꢆꢀꢃ $ꢃ VXVꢈ
SHQVLRQꢃRIꢃꢉꢃJꢃRIꢃ5DQH\ꢃQLFNHOꢃLQꢃꢄꢅꢃPOꢃRIꢃPHWKDQROꢃ
ZDVꢃVDWXUDWHGꢃZLWKꢃK\GURJHQꢃRYHUꢃDꢃSHULRGꢃRIꢃꢉꢃKꢃXQGHUꢃ
VWLUULQJꢍꢃ.HWRQHꢃ,9ꢆꢃꢄꢍꢋꢀꢃJꢃꢊꢉꢅꢍꢀꢃPPROꢌꢃ>ꢋ@ꢃDQGꢃꢄꢅꢃPOꢃ
RIꢃPHWKDQROꢃZHUHꢃDGGHGꢆꢃDQGꢃWKHꢃPL[WXUHꢃZDVꢃVWLUUHGꢃ
ꢃ
,;Eꢃ
ꢃ
,;Fꢃ
ꢃ U ꢃLVꢃWUDQVLWLRQꢃWHPSHUDWXUHꢆꢃU ꢃLVꢃFODULILFDWLRQꢃWHPSHUDWXUHꢆꢃDQGꢃ
ꢃ 6PYꢃLVꢃLQGHILQLWHꢃPRQRWURSLFꢃVPHFWLFꢃSKDVHꢒꢃGLDVWHUHRLVRPHUꢃ
ꢃ UDWLRVꢃLQꢃDQDO\WLFDOꢃVDPSOHVꢃRIꢃGLROVꢃ9,,,ꢓꢃꢁꢓꢋꢃꢊDꢌꢆꢃꢎꢓꢉꢃꢊEꢌꢆꢃꢇꢓꢉꢃꢊFꢌꢍꢃꢃ IRUꢃꢎꢍꢇꢃKꢃLQꢃDꢃK\GURJHQꢃDWPRVSKHUHꢆꢃDGGLWLRQDOꢃSRUWLRQVꢃꢃ
5866,$1ꢃꢃ-2851$/ꢃꢃ2)ꢃꢃ25*$1,&ꢃꢃ&+(0,675<ꢃꢃꢃ9ROꢍꢃꢃꢋꢄꢃꢃꢃ1Rꢍꢃꢃꢀꢃꢃꢃꢄꢅꢅꢂꢃ