ACCEPTED
4
MANUSCRIPT
µM). Chlorine was also found to improve activity at positions R
DNA complex structure is a major improvement over our
5
and R . Compounds 18 and 17 were about four times more potent
than their unsubstituted counterpart (compound 24, ST IC50 of
.8 µM). Chlorine substitution at R position in compound 17
also improved selectivity (nine-folds) for the ST step. The reason
for the dramatic loss of potency for both ST and 3′-P with
compound 15 is not apparent. It might be due to ineffective metal
chelation by the β-diketo acid functionality considering, the
electron withdrawing effect of the adjacent fluorine substituent.
The improvement of activity of compound 16 (ST IC50 = 8.0
µM), relative to compound 15, implies a favorable effect of the
fluoro substituent at the R position. This may be one of the
reasons why compound 17, having a more hydrophobic Cl at the
position, had improved activity over compound 16; also
implying that hydrophobic interaction at this position may be an
important contributing factor to activity. Compound 22, with an
electron donating methoxy group at the R position, and the
diketo acid moiety at R showed an IC50 of 3 µM against ST.
This is a significant loss of activity when compared to its parent
previous studies on partial IN structure without DNA and provide
more detailed insights into the binding modes of the target
phenanthrene β-diketo acids. More importantly, there were no
significant interactions with Gln148 and Asn155, key residues
implicated in viral resistance.
20
5
4
The novel binding mode of these compounds could be
exploited to develop agents active against the current drug-
resistant strains of HIV. Since, compound 15 exhibited a
significant loss of activity (ST IC50 of 63 µM), its binding pose
was also evaluated. It was observed that compound 15
5
predominantly docked in
a
different binding mode
5
(Supplementary material, Figure S1). In this orientation, while
the phenanthrene ring interacted with Thr66, His67, and Leu68,
only the acid and the enolic oxygen of the β-diketo acid motif
R
2+
1
chelated the two Mg ions. The loss of potency may be
7
attributed to a disruption of chelation by an adjacent electron
withdrawing fluorine substituent. The structurally similar
derivative 16 had a similar binding pose as compound 15
(Supplementary material, Figure S2). However, the improved
activity of compound 16 might result from a favorable contact
unsubstituted diketo acid analog 25 (ST IC50 of 0.38 µM) that our1
20
laboratory has previously reported. This suggests that the R
position is sensitive to modifications and could be further
exploited to determine the structure activity relationship around
this novel class of IN inhibitors.
5
that the R position fluoro makes with the side chain of Leu68.
Figure 2.
Table 1.
In summary, a series of new phenanthrene-β-diketo acid
derivatives bearing mostly halogen substituents were synthesized
and evaluated as HIV-1 integrase inhibitors. In general,
compounds were active against the ST catalytic step but some
also showed good activities against 3′-P as well. Selected
compounds were also found to moderately inhibit HIV-1
replication. Docking studies with a more refined structure than
we previously used to dock earlier parent phenanthrene DKAs
suggest that these derivatives bind to a potential novel region in
the IN active site. In particular, the bulky phenanthrene ring
system does not dock into the cavity characteristically occupied
by the halobenzyl groups of IN inhibitors in clinical use, and
does not appear to interact with Gln146 and viral DNA.
Furthermore, no contacts with two of the most critical residues
implicated in viral resistance, Asn155 and Gln148, were
observed. This series of compounds could be further optimized to
develop agents to overcome viral resistance against currently
used HIV-1 IN inhibitors.
Next, to determine their potential as anti-HIV agents, potent
analogs of the series, compounds 18, and 17 were tested for their
ability to inhibit HIV-1 replication in primary human peripheral
blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) according to the previously
30
reported procedure.
Both compounds showed moderate
inhibition of HIV replication with IC50s of 20.7 and 27.5 µM,
respectively (Table 2). The reduced antiviral potency might be
because of poor solubility, binding to serum proteins and/or
31,32
cellular distribution factors. Cytotoxicity assays
showed that
the selected compounds, 17 and 18, have toxicities when tested
against PBMC, human CEM lymphoblastic leukemia cells and
African green monkey Vero cells. However, the non-halogenated
compound 23, had an EC50 of 8.0 µM for inhibition of HIV
replication in cell culture and a selectivity index of 10 against
PBMCs in our previous study suggesting that there is potential
for optimization to improve selectivity index along with their
anti-viral activities.
2
0
Acknowledgments
Table 2.
Financial support from the National Institute of Allergy and
Infectious Diseases (NIAID), NIH Grant No. AI084710, the
Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences, and Department of
Veterans Affairs is gratefully acknowledged.
After synthesis and biological evaluation, a homology model
of the structure of full HIV-1 integrase bound to DNA that we
recently constructed based on the foamy virus crystal structure,
21
was used to determine binding modes of the compounds. The
docking studies revealed two distinct poses. The docked
conformations of compound 18, active against both ST and 3′-P,
are shown in Fig. 2. In both orientations, the β-diketo acid
Supplementary data
Supplementary data (Docking poses of compounds 15 and 16
and Chemistry experimental data) associated with this article can
be found, in the online version, at
2
+
chelating pharmacophore interacted with the two Mg ions in the
IN active site, thus contributing to IN inhibition in accordance
with the proposed mechanism of action of ST inhibitors. The
phenanthrene ring in one binding mode interacted with residues
Glu92, Ser119, Asn120, and Phe121 in a possible novel binding
region in the IN active site. In the other mode, the phenanthrene
ring made contacts with Pro142, Tyr143, Asn117, and Gly118. It
is important to note that because of steric hindrance, the
phenanthrene ring does not dock into the DNA-IN interface
References and notes
1. Curran, J. W. N. Engl. J. Med. 1983, 309, 609.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Curran, J. W. R. I. Dent. J. 1984, 16, 19, 21.
Von Hentig, N. Drugs Today 2008, 44, 103.
MacArthur, R. D.; Novak, R. M. Clin. Infect. Dis. 2008, 47, 236.
Clavel, F.; Hance, A. J. N. Engl. J. Med. 2004, 350, 1023.
21
cavity into which the characteristic halobenzyl moieties of
clinically used IN inhibitors insert; thus making no contacts with
Gln146 or viral DNA. The present docking simulation on HIV-
6. Moyle, G.; Gatell, J.; Perno, C. F.; Ratanasuwan, W.; Schechter,
M.; Tsoukas, C. AIDS Patient Care STDs 2008, 22, 459.