.
Angewandte
Communications
Table 1: Transfer of chirality in the cycloisomerization of the enediynes
1a–d.[a]
prised to not detect any of the products which would have
resulted from 2aa undergoing Saito–Myers or Schmittel
cyclization.[10] Instead, the benzofulvene (R,R)-3aa, where
two methyl groups were incorporated, was isolated together
with trace amounts of 3’aa. Much to our delight, (R,R)-3aa
was formed as a single diastereomer, thus showing that
a highly regio- and stereoselective bis(alkylating) cycloiso-
merization had been achieved. The R,R absolute configura-
tion of 3aa was demonstrated by VCD and ECD spectros-
copies combined with DFT calculations (see the Supporting
Information). The 98% ee of the product gave evidence that
the tandem process occurred with a highly efficient trans-
mission of the initial chiral information.[11] It is to be noted
that, under optimized experimental conditions, (S,S)-3aa was
isolated with 97% ee in 55% yield when starting from the
enantiomeric S,S substrate. During the optimization studies it
was observed that performing the reaction at room temper-
ature in ether (or THF) gave the optimal yield. The screening
of different experimental conditions is detailed in the
Supporting Information.
Product (R,R)-3aa belongs to the class of fulvene
derivatives, which constitute an important family of cross-
conjugated olefins. The latter are attractive because their
properties have found applications in important fields.[12–14]
The availability of chiral fulvenes will open new prospects.
The most common method used to access these frameworks is
the condensation of cyclopentadienes onto carbonyl
groups.[15] Other strategies, based on the above-cited Schmit-
tel cyclization of hindered enediynes[16,17] or more recent
metal-catalyzed procedures, have been developed.[18] No
example of chiral fulvene formation through a cycloisomeri-
zation reaction has been reported to date.
Entry R1
R2
1
3[b]
Yield
[%]
(S,S)-1a
(d.r.>95:5)
(R,S)-1a
(d.r.>95:5)
(R,S)-1a
(S,S)-3ab
(d.r.>95:5)
(R,S)-3ac
(d.r.>95:5)
(R,S)-3ad
(d.r.>95:5)
(R,S)-3ae
1
2
nBu
iBu
51
48
3
4
nHex
57
55
(d.r.>95:5)
(R,S)-1a
CH2TMS
(d.r.>95:5) (d.r.=85:15)
(R)-1b
(98 %ee)
(R)-1b
(98 %ee)
(R)-1b
(98 %ee)
(R)-1b
(98 %ee)
(rac)-1b
(R)-3bb
(96 %ee)
(R)-3bc
(95 %ee)
(R)-3bd
(90 %ee)
(R)-3be
(93 %ee)
2bf[d]
5
6
nBu
iBu
42[c]
51
7
8
9
nHex
48
43
45
CH2TMS
tBu
(R)-1c
(90 %ee)
(R)-3cb
(86 %ee)
10
11
nBu
nBu
62
48
(S,S)-1d
(d.r.>95:5)
(S,S)-3 db
(d.r.>95:5)
[a] Reaction conditions: a solution of R2 CuLi·LiI in THF was added
2
We then considered the incorporation of other alkyl
groups as a variable in this cyclization. Dibutyl-, diisobutyl-,
and dihexylcuprates were found to be efficient in triggering
the cycloizomerization. The benzofulvenes 3ab, 3ac, and 3ad
were isolated in 51, 48, and 57% yield, respectively (entries 1-
3, Table 1). A high level of diastereoselectivity (> 95:5) was
observed for each case. The applied bis(alkylating) cyclo-
isomerization also proceeded with the organocuprate pre-
pared from TMSCH2Li. The diastereomeric ratio of the
product was only 85:15 in this case (entry 4).
dropwise to a solution of the enediyne 1 in THF at 08C. The reaction
mixture was warmed to RT for 1 h and quenched with NH4OH/NH4Cl
(10:1). Complete conversion was observed in all experiments. [b] The
configurations were assumed by analogy with the structures of 3aa and
3bb established by VCD and ECD, and XRD, respectively (see the
Supporting Information). [c] The allene 4bb (4%) was also isolated (see
Ref. [19]). [d] The allene 2bf was the only product. THF=tetrahydro-
furan, TMS=trimethylsilyl, Ts=4-toluenesulfonyl.
Because of its remoteness, the chiral auxiliary was
unlikely to participate in the control of the chirality transfer.
To confirm this assumption, we investigated the reactivity of
the Gilmanꢁs reagent prepared from n-butyl lithium with
respect to the carbonate 1b, bearing only one stereocenter in
the propargylic position, so that the formation of a transient
chiral allene could be controlled by chirality transfer without
any suspicion of a possible diastereoselective process.
The cycloisomerization of 1b (entry 5, Table 1) led to 3bb
with both efficient chirality transfer and Z/E control. The
level of chirality transfer (product ee divided by substrate ee)
was close to 98% since 3bb was isolated with 96% ee when
starting from 1b (98% ee). This indicated that a double
transfer of chirality was operative: the first transfer occurring
from the stereogenic center to the axis of chirality of the
transient allene, and the second one from this axis to the new
stereogenic center. It can be noted that the allene 4bb was
also isolated. It is likely to result from the elimination of
a [Cu]N(Ts)Me species from a vinyl copper intermediate.[19]
This side-product was less abundant in THF (this explains
why THF was selected as solvent rather than Et2O). Again,
isobutyl and n-hexyl groups were efficiently transferred (97%
and 91% level of chirality transfer, respectively; entries 6 and
7). The reaction of (TMSCH2)2CuLi·LiI with 1b afforded the
desired product in moderate yield and 93% ee (entry 8).
Interestingly, when di-tert-butylcuprate was used, the
allene 2bf (Figure 1) was the only product (45% yield) and
no further cyclization was observed (entry 9, Table 1). In all
likelihood, the subsequent alkylating cyclization suffers from
steric impediment in this case. This assertion is consistent with
the proposed mechanism (see below). The conversion of 2bf
into benzofulvene by addition of nBu2CuLi·LiI or MeCuI was
not successful, and the starting material was recovered
unreacted.
3228
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 3227 –3231