Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
Table 1: P450-BM3 catalyzed hydroxylation of phenol to hydroquinone
(HQ) by E. coli cells containing P450-BM3 and its mutants, and turnover
rate and coupling efficiency measured using corresponding purified
enzymes.
to note that HQ was reported to be one of several products, in
the mammalian metabolism of benzene.[4] We now report the
preparative one-pot regioselective dihydroxylation of ben-
zene with formation of HQ without any overoxidation,
catalyzed by a semi-rationally evolved mutant of cytochro-
me P450-BM3 (Figure 1B). We have also devised a cascade
conversion of benzene to arbutin by constructing E. coli
designer cells harboring the P450 monooxygenase and
a glucosyltransferase (Figure 1C).
We considered the self-sufficient cytochrome P450 mono-
oxygenase from Bacillus megaterium, P450-BM3,[5] which
catalyzes the oxidative hydroxylation of long-chain fatty acids
as natural substrates, but is essentially inert to small molecules
such as propane, cyclohexane or benzene. When adding per-
fluoro fatty acids as decoys,[6] benzene is hydroxylated with
formation of phenol at a rate higher than the activity observed
when using a P450-BM3 mutant alone.[7] Knowing that mono-
substituted benzene derivatives are hydroxylated by WT
P450-BM3 and mutants solely at the ortho-position,[8] we
chose this enzyme without resorting to additives.
Catalysts Conv. Product distribu- Rate
[%][a] tion[b] [%] [minꢀ1 enzymeꢀ1 [c]
HQ Catechol
TTN[d] CE
[%][e]
]
WT
V78F
A82F
8
95
100
99
100
99
5
0
1
0
1
n.d.
n.d.
3
1910 33
150 8.0
5900 60
n.d.
n.d.
10
67
54
99
0.3ꢁ0.3
191ꢁ1
15ꢁ2
A328F
A82F/
A328F
V78F/
A82F
A78F/
A328F
A82F/
V78F/
A328F
590ꢁ15
33
44
85
100
100
98
0
0
2
19ꢁ2
190
110
13
12
11ꢁ1
348ꢁ15
3480 62
[a] Conditions with cells: 10 mm substrate, 308C, 200 rpm, 5 h. Con-
version was determined by HPLC analysis. For detailed conditions, see
the Supporting Information. [b] Relative amounts based on the concen-
trations of products formed as detected by HPLC analysis. Mean values
are given, standard deviation for conversion is ꢁ5% and for product
distribution ꢁ1%. [c] Conditions with purified enzymes: WT or
P450BM3 mutants (0.5 mm), phenol (10 mm), NADPH (5 mm), 308C,
200 rpm, 10 min. The reaction rate was determined by HPLC analysis
based on the amount of HQ formed. For detailed conditions see the
Supporting Information, mean values and standard errors from
triplicates. [d] Total turnover unmber (TTN): [Hydroquinone formatio-
n]/[Enzyme]. [e] Coupling efficiency (CE): ([Hydroquinone formation]/
[NADPH consumption])ꢁ100. n.d. not detectable.
In our earlier study,[9] exploratory NNK-based saturation
mutagenesis at 8 residues lining the binding pocket of P450-
BM3 harboring a structurally small substrate (cyclohexanone)
revealed a mutational fingerprint for each position. Mutations
at residues A78, A82, and V328 signaled enhanced activity,
especially when phenylalanine was introduced. In the present
study, we learned from directed evolution and generated
mutants in which phenylalanine, a relatively large hydro-
phobic amino acid, is placed at these “hot” spots, namely
A78F, A82F, V328F, A82F/A328F, V78F/A328F, and A82F/
A328F/V78F. Such mutations were expected to reduce the
size of the large binding pocket of P450-BM3, a hypothesis
which we first tested using phenol as substrate. Gratifyingly, in
whole cell reactions, single mutant A82F, double mutant
A82F/A328F, and triple mutant V78F/A82F/A328F showed
notable turnover rates with pronounced regioselectivity in
favor of HQ, with only traces of the regioisomer catechol
being detected (Table 1), and with no overoxidation.
Table 2: Selective dihydroxylation of benzene with almost exclusive
formation of HQ using the respective P450-BM3-containing E. coli
resting cells.
Catalysts
Conv. [%][a]
Product distribution[b] [%]
HQ
Phenol
Catechol
[c]
[c]
[c]
[c]
WT
–
–
–
–
The mutant enzymes were purified so that the turnover
rate and coupling efficiency of phenol hydroxylation could be
determined. The results are noteworthy for several reasons
(Table 1). Unprecedented activity was achieved for variants
A82F, A82F/A328F, and A82F/V78F/A328F, here as well with
no overoxidation. The double mutant A82F/A328F has the
best profile, resulting in a turnover rate of 590 minꢀ1 enzymeꢀ1
with unusually high coupling efficiency (60%). For compar-
ison, the phenol hydroxylation by WT P450-BM3 enabled by
decoy molecules produced a mixture of hydroquinone and
catechol as products at very low turnover rates amounting to
only 70 minꢀ1 enzymeꢀ1 and 15 minꢀ1 enzymeꢀ1, respec-
tively.[6]
We then turned to the crucial question of whether the
mutants also catalyzes the hydroxylation of benzene by
testing mutants A82F, A82F/A328F, and V78F/A82F/A328F.
Indeed, they catalyzed the dihydroxylation of benzene with
formation of HQ with no overoxidation. Among them,
double mutant A82F/A328F shows 97% conversion, account-
ing for > 90% of HQ formation (Table 2). The best double
mutant A82F/A328F was then employed for scale-up reac-
A82F
A82F/A328F
V78F/A82F/A328F
87
97
92
86
93
93
10
6
4
4
1
3
[a] Conditions: 10 mm substrate, 308C, 200 rpm, 5 h. Conversion was
determined by HPLC analysis and is based on the amount of converted
substrate. For detailed conditions, see the Supporting Information.
[b] Relative amounts based on the concentrations of products formed as
analyzed by HPLC analysis. [c] Not determined due to low activity. Mean
values are given, standard deviation for conversion is ꢁ5% and for
product distribution ꢁ1%.
tions starting from benzene or phenol as substrates for the
preparation of HQ, which led to 55–76% product yields.
The mechanism of P450-catalyzed hydroxylation of aro-
matics involves de-aromatizing formation of an epoxide,
followed by its rearrangement into phenol derivatives.[5]
However, nothing was known about the mechanism of
P450-catalyzed selective oxidation of phenol to HQ. To gain
some insight, combined classical molecular dynamics (MD)
simulations and calculations were performed.
2
ꢀ 2018 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2018, 57, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!