Angewandte
Chemie
(
entry 12). Homocoupling by-products such as 2 are typically
product 2 is formed initially but does not increase with
formed in the classical Stille reactions where a slow coupling
a prolonged reaction time. With added LiCl the homocou-
[
11h,12,17]
results in undesired transmetalations.
In our experi-
pling disappears (entry 6)and the reaction with PPh is as
3
ence the hydrolysis by-products like 4 are also observed in
efficient as that with AsPh , although noticeably slower
3
processes frustrated at the coupling step (e.g. [Pd(C F ) L ]
(entry 2 versus 6 and 1 versus 7). The reactions with PPh still
6
5
2
2
3
hardly undergoes reductive elimination to C F -C F and
continued slowly after 110 hours. This effect is well known in
the classic Stille process, and results from the facile displace-
ment of weaker ligands during the associative transmetalation
6
5
6
5
formation of C F H is observed). Thus, it appears that the
6
5
unsuccessful cocatalysis in entry 11 of Table 2 is due to the
difficulty with the final reductive elimination, rather than at
any of the two successive transmetalation steps.
Furthermore, experiments were carried out to check the
influence of the added LiCl, the ligand L, and other effects
[
10a]
to palladium.
Other positive effects of a large excess of
LiCl are that it exchanges I for Cl in the metal complexes. This
reduces the energetic barrier of the tin to palladium trans-
[
10a,20]
metalation step.
Also, excess LiCl helps to keep the gold
[
21]
(
Table 3). The reactions can be carried out with similarly good
cocatalyst in the [AuCl(AsPh )] form, which, as shown in
3
yields using either [PdCl (AsPh ) ] or the intermediate
Table 1, shifts the tin to gold transmetalation equilibrium
towards the gold arylated compound. Furthermore, LiCl
improves the overall thermodynamic balance of the coupling
(whether it be the classical or the gold cocatalyzed) because of
the higher stability of SnCl(nBu)3.
2
3 2
Table 3: Results of the cross-coupling experiments between p-CF C H I
3
6
4
[
a]
and mesityltributyltin under other reaction conditions.
Entry
1
Pd catalyst
cocatalyst, LiCl)
t
[h]
Yield
[%]
Finally, it is interesting that under similar experimental
conditions, [AuCl(AsPh )] and [AuCl(PPh )] were much
(
3
3
[PdCl (AsPh ) ]
24
84
2
3
2
more efficient cocatalysts than CuCl (Table 3, entries 1, 2, 6,
and 7 versus 8), as shown by the yields achieved for entries 2
and 8 (84% for the gold complex versus 13% for CuCl).
The ability of gold to promote the cross-coupling of
sterically encumbered aryltin derivatives is remarkable. Thus
far, these cross-coupling processes required the use of bulky
and strong s-donor phosphanes to facilitate the reaction going
[
AuCl(AsPh )], LiCl
3
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
[Pd(C H CF )I(AsPh ) ]
24
84
6
4
3
3 2
[
AuCl(AsPh )], LiCl
3
[Pd(C H CF )I(AsPh ) ]
24
<1
33
6
4
3
3 2
[
AuI(AsPh )], no LiCl
3
[
22]
through tricoordinated palladium intermediates.
Appa-
[PdCl (AsPh ) ]
24
2
3 2
rently, when gold (and expectedly when Cu) complexes act
as intermediates in the transmetalation, the steric hindrance
for direct transmetalation with tetracoordinated tin and
palladium compounds is circumvented via the less sterically
demanding linear gold complexes. Moreover, in the direct Sn/
[
AuCl(AsPh ), no LiCl
3
[Pd(C H CF )I(PPh ) ]
110
110
84
58(+5)
75
6
4
3
3 2
[
AuI(PPh )], no LiCl
3
[Pd(C H CF )I(PPh ) ]
6
4
3
3
2
Pd transmetalation the bulky group (Sn(nBu) ) is directly
3
[
AuI(PPh )], LiCl
3
involved in the bridging system, producing a very encumbered
high-energy transition state, whereas with gold the bulky
substituent on gold (the ancillary ligand) is one bond away
from the bridging system , further relaxing the steric
encumbrance and reducing the energy of the corresponding
transmetalation transition state (see below and Figure 1). This
improvement allows the process to occur using palladium and
gold complexes with inexpensive common ligands.
[PdCl (PPh ) ]
83
2
3 2
[
AuCl(PPh )], LiCl
3
[Pd(C H CF )I(AsPh ) ]
24
13
6
4
3
3 2
CuCl, LiCl
[a] General reaction conditions as in Table 2, except for the catalysts used
and for the addition or not of LiCl, as indicated.
Our hypothesis was confirmed by DFT calculations, which
estimated the energy of the transmetalation transition states
from tin to palladium (involved in the direct Stille reaction),
or from tin to gold and from gold to palladium (involved in
the gold cocatalyzed pathway). The calculations were per-
formed for the formation of (2-methyl-1-(4-(trifluoromethyl)-
phenyl)naphthalene (Table 2, entry 7) with the real mole-
formed after the first oxidative addition to Pd, [Pd-
[18]
(
C H CF )I(AsPh ) ], prepared independently,
as far as
6
4
3
3 2
excess LiCl is used (entries 1 and 2; also entries 6 and 7). The
suppression of added LiCl is very detrimental to the gold
cocatalyzed reaction with AsPh . The reaction still works
3
albeit poorly when chloride is introduced in the catalytic
system because it is part of the Pd and Au catalysts (entry 4),
but it fails completely when the catalysts are iodide complexes
and there is no other chloride source in the system (entry 3).
This chloride effect is clearly related to the fact that the
cules, except for the Sn(nBu) group, which was simplified to
3
SnMe . The transmetalation mechanisms from tin to palla-
3
dium and from gold to palladium have been studied before for
[
3,23]
sterically nondemanding groups.
The transmetalation
mechanism from tin to gold has not been studied so far, and
is depicted in Scheme 2. The structures of the three rate-
determining transition states and their free energies in
0
oxidative addition step to Pd complexes with weak ligands
such as arsanes does not take place without the addition of
[
9,10a,19]
[24]
chloride.
runs perfectly in the absence of chloride, although very slowly
entry 5). In this case a 5% of undesired homocoupling
In fact, a similar reaction using PPh catalysts
vacuum and in MeCN are shown in Figure 1.
3
The transition energies very clearly show that there is
a considerable difference in favor of the bimetallic pathway,
(
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2013, 52, 2189 –2193
ꢀ 2013 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
2191