Angewandte
Chemie
starts with the reduction of a nitro compound at the earliest
reaction steps (Scheme 1A, route a).
caused a notable loss of selectivity due to reduction of 5-
methyl furfural to alcohol 6.
Alternatively, the production of nitrones from a nitro
compound reduced in the presence of aldehydes is a more
direct and atom-efficient route, whereby hydroxylamine
generated in situ reacts with the carbonyl compound in
a cascade-type reaction. This approach circumvents hydroxyl-
amine storage issues and minimizes the number of exper-
imental steps, but requires a catalyst that prevents the
complete reduction of the NO2 group, the hydrogenation of
the aldehyde, and the degradation of the nitrone via
secondary reaction paths (Scheme 1B). The approach has
been proved to work with stoichiometric reagents such as Zn
dust,[18] but then large amounts of waste are generated. The
discovery of a solid catalyst that affords the nitrone in high
yields, directly from nitro compounds, aldehydes, and H2,
would be of interest.
Herein we describe the design of a selective solid metal
catalyst by controlling the characteristics of the support and
the metal particle architecture to avoid other competing
reactions. Specifically, this catalyst consists of platinum
nanoparticles that exclude atoms of high coordination
for interaction with the reactants, as well as supports that
activate the nitroaromatic compound and its reduced deriv-
atives. This control of the catalytic selectivity in complex fine-
chemistry processes by manipulation of a solid catalyst is
unusual.[19]
Remarkably, the nitrone selectivity could be increased
after controlling the structure of the metal active sites and the
characteristics of the support. For example, at 308 K and
5 bar, platinum nanoparticles supported on TiO2 (0.2 wt% Pt)
activated at 573 K in H2 provide 72% selectivity to nitrone 3
at almost complete conversion of the aldehyde, along with the
imine 4 as the main by-product. When the same catalyst was
activated in H2 at a higher temperature (723 K), the nitrone
selectivity dropped to 57% under identical experimental
conditions and similar conversion (the imine was, again, the
most significant by-product). No loss of selectivity due to
hydrogenation of the carbonyl function of 5-methyl furfural
was observed in these cases.
The decay in selectivity as the Pt/TiO2 catalyst is activated
in H2 at the highest temperature (723 K) takes place with the
concomitant appearance of TiOx species on top of the Pt
nanoparticles, as evidenced by HRTEM, EDS analysis, and
IR spectroscopy (Figures S1 and S2). This decoration effect
indicates the occurrence of strong metal–support interactions,
typical of supports that are reducible metal oxides,[23] which
increases the contact area between Pt and TiO2. The
detrimental effect of the metal/support boundary on nitrone
selectivity is consistent with the role attributed to TiO2 in
minimizing the formation of hydroxylamine during the
hydrogenation of nitro compounds[24] and, thus, in minimizing
the hydroxylamine–aldehyde condensation path (Scheme 1).
Table 1 summarizes the catalysts that we tested using the
coupling of nitrobenzene with 5-methylfurfural as
a model reaction. We investigated Au/TiO2, Pt/TiO2,
and Pt/C catalysts, which, properly prepared,[20a–c] are
Table 1: Catalytic performance[a] of various catalysts for the reductive coupling of
nitrobenzene and 5-methyl furfural to nitrone 3.
highly selective for the hydrogenation of NO2
groups, together with other common supported
metal catalysts. The percentage value that accom-
panies each catalyst in this paper refers to a nominal
weight percent metal content. Selectivities and
conversions mentioned in the text are calculated
based on gas chromatography data. Yields of isolated
products are also reported in Table 2.
Catalyst[b]
Metal
[%][g]
t
[h]
Conv.
[%]
Selectivity [mol%][h]
nitrone imine amine alcohol
Despite their expected tolerance of the carbonyl
function,[20a] gold nanoparticles supported on TiO2
showed low selectivity to nitrone formation (15%)
and, instead, the imine 4 was obtained preferentially
(Table 1), in agreement with previous reports.[21] The
reaction temperature required with the Au/TiO2
catalyst is relatively high (373 K) due to the limited
capacity of gold for activating H2 in the presence of
the nitroaromatic compound.[22] We noticed that the
use of high temperatures causes the selectivity to
nitrone 3 to decrease (Table S1).
By switching from gold to platinum we were able
to tackle the reaction at lower temperatures (298–
308 K). Unfortunately, attempts to use typical (com-
mercially available) supported metal catalysts to
obtain the nitrone were fruitless. For example, the
reaction with 5 wt% Pt/Al2O3 (Aldrich) at 308 K and
5 bar of H2 gave nitrone 3 with low selectivity (6%;
Table 1) and the secondary amine 5 as the predom-
3
4
5
6
[c,d]
1% Au/TiO2
0.50
2.5
3.0 95
2.0 97
0.7 99
0.5 98
1.7 98
1.3 97
1.1 100
0.9 80
4.3 95
0.7 93
2.0 54
3.0 93
15
6
69
4
25
42
3
5
3
4
14
8
11
57
3
3
15
0
0
6
13
0
6
0
0
5% Pt/Al2O3-CM
[e]
0.2% Pt/TiO2
0.2% Pt/TiO2
0.11
0.20
0.20
1.01
0.18
72
57
78
51
97
74
84
82
0
[f]
1
0.2% Pt/Al2O3
5% Pt/Al2O3
0.2% Pt/C
12
30
0
14
0
8
61
93
0.2% Pt/graphite 0.12
2% Ru/C
0.2% Pd/C
1.95
0.10
5% Pd/Al2O3-CM 4.6
1% Pd/C-CM 0.48
0
0
39
1
6
[a] Reactions performed at 308 K and 5 bar of H2, unless otherwise indicated. Feed
composition (mol%): 90.5% ethanol, 6% nitrobenzene, 3% 5-methyl furfural, 0.5%
o-xylene. [b] Catalysts activated in H2 flow at 723 K, unless otherwise indicated. The
notation CM refers commercially available samples. Metal content given as
a nominal weight percent. [c] Activated in air at 673 K. [d] Tested at 373 K and 8 bar.
[e] Activated in H2 at 473 K. [f] Activated in H2 flow at 723 K, leading TiOx-decorated
Pt nanoparticles. [g] (mol of metal)/(mol of 5-methyl furfural)ꢂ100 [h] Determined
inant reaction product. This catalyst, moreover, by GC analysis. Balance corresponds to small amounts of unidentified products.
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 9306 –9310
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim