An efficient catalytic system for the formation of linear aldehyde
a
Table 3. Hydroformylation of styrene derivatives by Rh/ligand 1
ꢀ
ꢁ
b
L
LþB
c
d
ꢁ1 b
TOF (h )
Entry
Substrates
Aldehyde (%)
L/B
; %
Conversion (%)
1
2
3
4-Methylstyrene
4-Methoxystyrene
4-Chlorostyrene
a-Methylstyrene
97.7
96.6
95.7
97.4
81.2/15.9 (83.6)
78.8/16.0 (83.1)
78.8/16.4 (82.8)
90.6/0.4 (99.6)
99.4
98.1
99.5
93.4
994
981
995
47
c
4
a
3
ꢂ
[
Rh] = 1.7 mmol, olefin (1.0 ml), S/C = 10 , L/[Rh] = 5, T = 90 C, t = 1 h, p = 1 MPa, toluene (4.0 ml) as solvent.
b–d
See Table 1.
b
Moles of converted olefin per mole rhodium per hour.
c
3
ꢂ
[
Rh] = 1.7 mmol, olefin (1.0 ml), S/C = 10 , L/[Rh] = 5, T = 90 C, t = 20 h, p = 1 MPa, toluene (4.0 ml) as solvent.
the ratio of 81.6/14.5 obtained by the system with ligand 1.
Clearly, the bidentate ligand 1 was not just a simple sum of the
monodentate ligand 6, and its performance was much superior
to ligand 6. Comparing bidentate ligand 4 with its corresponding
summarized in Table 3. The presence of an electron-donating
or an electron-withdrawing group in position 4 on the phenyl
ring did not affect the reactivity of the aryl alkenes very obviously
(see Table 3, entries 1–3). But a trend that the substrate with
electron-withdrawing groups led to lower L/B than the substrate
with electron-donating groups was observed. Zhang et al. also
revealed this phenomenon when they used ligand (III) in the
monodentate ligand 7,
a positive backbone impact on
regioselectivity was also observed. In addition, the monodentate
ligand 6 showed a higher L/B ratio than monodentate ligand 7
[
9]
(Table 1, entries 6 and 7), likely because the size of the
Rh-catalyzed aryl alkene hydroformylation. It is worth noting
naphthanyl group is larger than that of the phenyl group. To
sum up, in order to obtain high linear aldehyde regioselectivity
in the hydroformylation of styrene, the bidentate phosphite 1
containing the rigid binaphthol skeleton and electron-
withdrawing group is the best choice among the ligands tested.
To better compare the activity and selectivity of these catalysts,
hydroformylation was performed under milder conditions so that
styrene conversion was controlled to be lower than 30%
that the steric hindrance of the substrates remarkably influences
[
9]
the regioselectivity. In our case, when a-methylstyrene was
used as the substrate, few branched aldehydes were yielded
(Table 3, entry 4), but the reaction rate decreased obviously. This
might be explained by steric hindrance inhibiting the formation
of the benzylic Rh species (Scheme 2b), which would tend to pro-
[
25]
duce branched aldehyde.
(see supporting information). The results illustrated a similar
trend for linear aldehyde selectivity as in Table 1, which increased
at higher conversion.
Conclusions
Reaction conditions play an important role in
hydroformylation; thus we set out to find the optimal conditions
within the system of ligand 1/Rh. The representative results of li-
gand/Rh molar ratio and initial pressure and temperature are
shown in Table 2. It can be seen that the ligand/Rh molar ratio
has a dramatic effect on hydroformylation. Molar ratios ranging
from 3.0 to 10.0 were scanned for the optimal value (see Table 2).
A yield of 75.5% of 3-phenylpropanal was obtained at a ligand/Rh
In summary, the influence of the steric and electronic properties
of ligands on activity and regioselectivity was investigated in the
hydroformylation of styrene. The results demonstrated that
the rigid binaphthyl skeleton and electron-withdrawing
dipyrrolylphosphino group were very important in obtaining
high activity and high linear aldehyde selectivity. Thus the 2,
2 -bis(dipyrrolylphosphinooxy)-1,1 -(ꢀ)-binaphthyl ligand (1) can
effectively improve the reaction activity and linear aldehyde
selectivity in the Rh-catalyzed hydroformylation of styrene and
its derivatives. Satisfactory activity and good regioselectivity
to the linear aldehyde were therefore obtained in the
hydroformylation of styrene or its derivatives when (Rh(acac)
0
0
ꢂ
ratio of 5 at 110 C. Further increasing or decreasing the ligand/
Rh molar ratio did not significantly influence the yield of the lin-
ear aldehyde. The product selectivity of styrene hydroformylation
[
24]
strongly depends on the reaction temperature. Thus the tem-
perature impact on the activity and selectivity of ligand 1/Rh
(CO)
2
/ligand 1) was used as catalyst at lower syngas pressure
ꢂ
(
acac)(CO) -catalyzed styrene hydroformylation was investigated
(1 MPa) and relatively moderate temperature (90 C). More
applications of this ligand are under further investigation.
2
ꢂ
in the range 80–120 C, and a good yield of 96.3% aldehydes
was achieved, with an excellent regioselectivity of 85.4% at
ꢂ ꢂ
0 C. Hence the optimum reaction temperature was near 90 C.
9
The total pressure of syngas (CO/H : 1/1) was also a key element Supporting information
2
in the hydroformylation of styrene. As shown in Table 2, pressure
Supporting information may be found in the online version of
this article.
had less impact on catalytic activity and chemoselectivity, but the
enhanced pressure from 1 to 3 MPa greatly decreased the
ꢂ
regioselectivity. The optimal conditions (toluene, 90 C, 1 MPa
Acknowledgment
CO/H , substrate/L/Rh 1000/5/1) through systematic investiga-
2
tions were chosen for the following substrate screening.
We thank the Young Teachers Scientific Research Foundation of
Sichuan University (2011SCU11084) for financial support.
Referring to the results of styrene hydroformylation under op-
timal conditions, it was found that the most active catalyst was a
combination of the rhodium complex and bidentate phosphite li-
gand 1. To evaluate the scope of the reaction, various aryl alkenes
were applied to this catalysis system and the results are
References
[1] R. Franke, D. Selent, A. Borner, Chem. Rev. 2012, 112, 5675.
Appl. Organometal. Chem. 2013, 27, 474–478
Copyright © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/aoc