Organic Letters
Letter
as 3-hexyne, 4-octyne, diphenylethyne, and but-2-yn-1-ol, but
the reactions did not provide the desired products.
two cases, intermediate III contains a thermodynamically
stable five- or six-membered chelation ring, respectively. In
contrast, alcohols 2a−2c and 2d form less stable four-
membered chelation rings.
In all cases, except the reaction with propargyl amine (4g),
the full consumption of 3 was observed, which led us to an
assumption that 3 can undergo [2 + 2 + 2]-homocyclotrime-
rization. Thus, subjecting triyne 3 to the standard reaction
conditions in the absence of the external alkyne led to full
consumption of the starting material. Analyses (MS and NMR)
of crude reaction mixtures as well as isolated material revealed
the presence of inseparable mixtures of compounds corre-
sponding to the dimers of 3. The formation of similar species
was also observed in cyclotrimerizations with internal alkynes.
For the sake of accuracy, it cannot be excluded that some
aromatic side products could be formed by dehydro-Diels−
Alder reaction of triyne 3.23
In accordance with the recently proposed mechanism
involving coordination of Lewis basic functionalities by
Tanaka24 and Dudley25 as the means of regiocontrol, we
offer the following rationalization of the observed regioselec-
tivity. After the initial formation of rhodacyclopentadiene I
(Scheme 2), two competing reaction pathways can take place:
Moreover, steric hindrance in the case of 2-methylbut-3-yn-
2-ol (2d) can lead to further destabilization of the intermediate
and loss of the regioselectivity and the desired reactivity as
well. The higher Lewis basicity of amides increases the ability
to coordinate to the metal center compared to that of esters
and can account for the higher regioselectivity: compare the
reaction with N-propargyl benzamide (2h) and propargyl
benzoate (2c) (entries 8 and 3). On the other hand, for
sterically hindered terminal alkynes or the terminal alkynes
without the polar moiety the homodimerization (pathway B) is
mostly observed. Internal alkynes proved to be not suitable
alkynes for the desired transformation regardless of the polar
moiety’s presence or absence, perhaps due to the steric
hindrance.
Then, we turned our attention to the synthesis of
selaginpulvilins to demonstrate the versatility of the method
(Scheme 3). We chose as synthetic targets selaginpulvilin C
Scheme 2. Mechanistic Rational of the Observed Reactivity
and Selectivity
Scheme 3. Formal Synthesis of Selaginpulvilin C
(1c), bearing the methyl group at C2 position, and
selaginpulvilin D (1d), which does not bear any substitution
at the C2 position. We commenced with the selaginpulvilin C
(1c) synthesis by using compound 2a bearing the hydrox-
ymethyl group (Scheme 3). The initial attempts to directly
reduce the hydroxymethyl moiety to the methyl group under
various conditions failed. Pd-catalyzed reduction with
triethylsilane26 gave rise to a mixture of products that consisted
of species with the reduced benzyl alcohol moiety and the
reduced triple bond. Also, the use of a nickel chloride/sodium
borohydride27 system gave a complex reaction mixture. An
attempt to employ Kursanov−Parnes reduction (triethylsilane/
formic acid) gave rise to an intractable reaction mixture.28
Finally, the reduction was brought about in the two-step
process. First, the benzyl alcohol 2a was converted to bromide
7 in 43% yield via the Appel reaction29 (bromide 7 was not
stable and underwent partially unspecified decomposition
upon the chromatographic purification). Its immediate
reduction with the zinc powder in a water/THF solution of
NH4Cl and subjecting the crude product to oxidation with
PCC provided ketone 8 in 36% yield (after two steps). Ketone
8 is the known advanced intermediate in the synthesis of
the desired pathway A leading to regioisomers 2 and pathway
B giving rise to homodimers. It seems that the nature of the
external alkyne 4 strongly influences the course of the reaction.
The terminal alkynes containing in their structure a Lewis basic
functionality bearing lone electron pairs undergo preferably the
desired pathway A. Two aspects can rationalize the high
preference of the formation of the “ortho” regioisomers 2. First,
the insertion of the external alkyne takes place in a less
sterically demanded C4−Rh vs C1−Rh bond (the fluorenol
numbering, intermediate II, Scheme 2). Second, precoordina-
tion of the alkyne causes the correct orientation of the alkyne
II and leads to the formation of the intermediate III, which
upon the reductive elimination furnishes the desired product.
This model reasonably explains exclusive “ortho” regioselectiv-
ity in the cyclotrimerization of homopropargyl alcohol (2e)
and pent-4-ynol (2f) (entries 5 and 6) in comparison with
propargyl alcohol (2a), its protected derivatives 2b and 2c, and
2-methylbut-3-yn-2-ol (2d) (entries 1−3 and 4). In the former
C
Org. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX