Communication
this issue (Figures S10–S12 in the Supporting Information). We
first measured the FIR spectra of the reference samples, M–
contrary, according to a recent study of Bakr and co-workers,
the central Ag atom of Ag25 would be replaced by a Au atom
I
[14a]
SPhMe (M=Au, Ag, or Pt, see Figure S10a–c in the Supporting
when alloying with [Au (PPh )Br].
Regarding the formation
2
3
Information) and Br–M–PPh3 (M=Au or Pt, see Figure S12a
and b in the Supporting Information), for the MÀS and MÀP
mechanism, Bakr et al. suggest that the Au atom first replaces
one Ag atom on the icosahedral surface of the Ag25 NC, and
then immediately diffuses into the center due to the thermo-
dynamic stability of the resultant configuration. In this context,
bond vibration energies. For Pt Au Ag , the FIR spectrum
1
x
24Àx
À1
clearly shows the bands centered at 343 cm (i.e., an AuÀS
bond according to the FIR spectrum of Au–SPhMe ) and
the structural arrangements of the Pt Au Ag
and
Pt Au Ag NCs imply that the Pt atom in Pt Ag is stable
2
1
x
24Àx
À1
3
81 cm (i.e., AgÀS), whereas no band can be identified
2
10
13
1
24
À1
around 323 cm
(i.e., PtÀS). The results indicate that
enough to hold the central position (compared to the Ag
Pt Au Ag
consists of both AuÀS and AgÀS bonds, but no
atom in Ag ). Note that the stability of the central Pt atom is
1
x
24Àx
25
PtÀS bonds. Hence, the absence of PtÀS bonds implies that
the only plausible location for the Pt atom is the central posi-
tion. On the other hand, the presence of AuÀP bonds
also supported by both DFT calculations and experiments on
[22a,23a]
Pt Ag and Pt Au NCs.
The difference in alloying pro-
1
24
1
24
cess of the Ag25 and Pt Ag NCs is most likely controlled by
1
24
À1
À1
(
436 cm ) and absence of PtÀP bonds (394 cm ) in
the intrinsic electronic structure and the thermodynamic stabil-
ity of the NCs. Applying this rule would provide a promising
strategy to engineer the heteroatoms into the designated posi-
tion.
Pt Au Ag indicate that the two Pt atoms are exclusively lo-
2
10
13
cated at the central positions of two icosahedrons. In other
words, the central position for the Pt atom in the precursor
nanocluster is retained, rather than displaced by Au dopant
atoms, regardless if the shape changes or not.
Based on the well-defined structures of these NCs, we pro-
I
pose a plausible mechanisms of alloying Pt Ag with [AuSR]
1
24
3
1
I
I
The P NMR spectra of both Pt Au Ag and the precursor
or [Au (PPh )Br] complexes (Figure 3). In Figure 3a, the [Au SR]
2
10
13
3
3
(
[PPh AuBr]) were measured. As shown in Figure S13 in the
complexes diffuse to the surface of the icosahedral Pt Ag
1
12
31
Supporting Information, the narrow P NMR signals of the NCs
indicate high purity of the final product.
core, and then replace the Ag atoms. These processes are simi-
lar to those reported in previous studies on alloying Au with
2
5
I
To further confirm the position of the Pt atoms in the trime-
tallic NCs, DFT calculations were performed. Three possible Pt
positions were considered, that is, the center of the icosahe-
dron (M1), the shell of the icosahedron (M2), and a staple
motif (M3). For each scenario, the ten lowest-energy isomer
structures were used as parent structures. To illustrate the fa-
vorable position of the Pt atom, the position of the Au or Ag
atom is mutually exchanged for a Pt atom. According to the
relative electronic energies of the different isomer structures
[Ag SR]. The alloying processes occur and eventually stabilize
in the thermodynamically favorable state with a tristratified ar-
rangement, that is, [Pt(center)@Au/Ag(shell)@Ag(exterior)]. Re-
garding Pt Au Ag (Figure 3b), the Ag atoms on the icosahe-
2
10
13
dral Pt Ag core are exchanged by the Au atoms of the
1
12
I
[Au(PPh )Br] complexes (the thiolates binding to these Ag
3
atoms are simultaneously peeled away), and the PPh ligands
3
keep in connection with Au atoms in this process. Meanwhile,
À
the Br ions link to the Ag atoms neighboring the Au atoms,
(
Figure 2), the Pt atom favors the central position. Moving the
and the AgÀS bond dissociates simultaneously (because of the
stronger AgÀBr). As a consequence, the icosahedral Pt Ag
Pt atom to the shell of icosahedral core or to the staple motif
significantly increases the electronic energy. This energy ten-
dency agrees with the FIR spectral analysis and confirms the
1
12
core is peeled away from the surrounding six [Ag (SR) ] motifs
2
3
and the Pt@Au–Ag NCs, co-protected by PPh and Br ligands,
3
central position of the Pt atom in Pt Au Ag .
24Àx
are generated. Finally, two icosahedral Pt@Au–Ag NCs, couple
together by sharing the Ag atom in vertex and five Br atoms,
are formed. The Pt atom maintain the central position in the
final biicosahedral structure and the neck sites are completely
occupied by Au atoms to form a symmetric structure.
1
x
Structurally, the central Pt atom in the M13 core of the two
synthesized trimetallic alloy NCs was unexceptionally retained
compared to the positions in the Pt Ag precursor. On the
1
24
To investigate the correlation between the composition/
shape and the optical properties, the absorption spectra on
the energy scale and photoluminescence (PL) of all samples
were analyzed. The energy-scale UV/Vis spectra of the homosil-
ver, Ag , bi-metallic, Pt Ag , and trimetallic, Pt Au Ag , as
25
1
24
1
x
24Àx
well as the Pt Au Ag NCs are shown in Figure 4a. The optical
2
10
13
energy gap of Ag25 occurs at 1.57 eV and significantly blue-
shifts to 1.72 and 1.93 eV in Pt Ag and Pt Au Ag , respec-
1
24
2
10
13
tively. On the other hand, a slight blueshift by 0.05 eV (1.62–
.57 eV) is determined from the spectrum of Pt Au Ag . The
1
1
x
24Àx
results indicate an increase of energy gap in Pt Au Ag ,
1
x
24Àx
Pt Ag , or Pt Au Ag NCs. Meanwhile, the three NCs with the
1
24
2
10
13
Figure 2. Left: M1 is the central atom in the icosahedral core. M2 is the shell
atoms of icosahedral core. M3 is the metal atoms in the motif. Right: The rel-
ative energies of isomers with Pt atoms located at different positions in
same framework (i.e., Pt Au Ag , Pt Ag , and Ag ) vary in
1
x
24Àx
1
24
25
color from greenish yellow to green and orange, indicating
Pt
1 x
Au Ag24Àx (x=5–8).
that the doped heteroatoms significantly affect the electronic
Chem. Eur. J. 2016, 22, 1 – 7
3
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
&
These are not the final page numbers! ÞÞ