A. D. Jordan et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 12 (2002) 2381–2386
2385
analogue 13 but were more orally active in the in vivo
assays. However, aromatic amine 18 and cyclic amine
19 were less potent in the binding assay and the PTZ in
vivo assay. The 2-pyridylethyl derivative 20 demon-
strated a 2-fold increase in potency (IC50 of 0.9 nM) at
the GABA-A receptor as compared to 13 and was
found to be more orally active in the pentylenetetrazole
and anticonflict biological tests. Imidazolylethyl com-
pound 21 showed comparable in vitro activity and
improved in vivo activity. Highly basic amidine 22
exhibited less activity in the binding assay with larger
G.S. value of 2.1. Similiarly, guanidine 23 revealed
diminished in vitro activity but a lower G.S. value of
1.7. Compounds 22 and 23 showed no improvement in
oral activity in the in vivo tests. Although formation of
the acid addition salts of compounds 14–21 did result in
an increase in their water solubility, the oral activities of
these compounds were not improved enough to warrant
further consideration.
(IC50=126.0 nM) than 24, whereas 6,8-, and 6,7-
difluorophenyl compounds 36 and 37 had 13.3 and 0.5
nM IC50s in vitro. In addition, 37 displayed 3-fold less
activity po in the anticonflict assay. These results sug-
gest that halogen substitution of the 6 and/or 7 posi-
tions are favorable for GABA-A receptor binding. In a
previous report, the A ring naphthyl derivative with 7,8
fusion was found to be the most potent of the three
possible benzo ring fused isomers.3 Incorporation of the
naphthyl ring as a phenyl replacement afforded com-
pound 38, which demonstrated weaker binding affinity
(IC50=2.2 nM) for the GABA-A receptor than 24 and
diminished in vivo activity in the rat anticonflict test.
Lastly, our SAR studies focused on modifications of
ring D (Table 3). The 2,6- and 2,4-difluorophenyl com-
pounds 39 and 40 showed slightly less in vitro activity,
but only 40 exhibited appreciable activity in the anti-
conflict assay. In vitro metabolism of 24 in rat and
human hepatic S9 fractions revealed that para hydro-
xylation on the D ring benzene ring was the major site
for metabolism (viz. 10). In fact, 10 was formed to the
extent of 60 and 30% upon incubation of 24 with rat
and human microsomes, respectively, after 1 h, and all
other metabolites only accounted for 10 and 20% of the
original drug sample. Therefore, 2-fluoro-4-hydroxy
phenyl compound 10 was prepared as shown earlier
(Scheme 2), and was found to be 14-fold less active in
vitro than 24, and 30-fold less active po in the rat con-
flict assay. The 2-fluoro-4-methoxy and 2-fluoro-4-
methoxycarbonyloxy compounds 11 and 12 were syn-
thesized as potential prodrugs of 10. The biological
activity of 11 was 3-fold better in the binding assay and
30-fold more active po in the rat conflict assay. Thio-
phene was utilized as a bioisosteric replacement for the
D ring phenyl. Specifically, N-(3-thienyl) and (2-thi-
enyl)carboxamides 41 and 42 were synthesized and each
was found to be significantly less active in vitro than 24
and less active po in in vivo efficacy tests. Incorporation
of a 5-methyl substituent (viz. 43) and a 3-chloro group
(viz. 44) on the 2-thienyl ring slightly enhanced binding
potency relative to 42 but nonetheless each analogue
was less active in the binding assay and po in the PTZ in
vivo assay than 24.
We then decided to incorporate oxygen-containing
groups at the N5 position of the PBI nucleus. We were
delighted to find that the ethoxymethyl derivative 24
displayed a superior IC50 of 0.1 nM to the GABA-A
receptor with an acceptable G.S.=1.2 as compared to
compound 13. In addition, compound 24 displayed
particularly excellent in vivo activity, including 0.04 mg/
kg MED po in the mouse PTZ and 0.4 mg/kg ED po in
the rat conflict test. Increasing the chain length by one
carbon produced ethoxyethyl compound 25, which was
5-fold less potent in vitro than 24 with an unexpectedly
large G.S. of 3.2. Compound 25 possessed 7-fold less
oral activity in the PTZ test and 3-fold less oral activity
in the conflict test. Ethoxypropyl homologue 26 dis-
played only 3-fold less potency in the binding assay but
7-fold less activity po in the mouse PTZ and 3-fold less
activity in the rat conflict tests. Cyclic ether compounds,
such as tetrahydrofuranyl methyl analogue 27 were
generally less active than acyclic ether 24. Diether 28,
with an IC50=0.8 nM and a rather high G.S. of 2.2, did
show 3-fold less po activity in the PTZ test and an 8-
fold reduction in the rat conflict test. Alcohols 29 and 30
showed an 8-fold reduction in in vitro activity and
exhibited diminished po in vivo activity. Methoxy-
carbonyloxy analogue 31 and acetate 32, designed as
prodrugs of 29, showed comparable in vivo potency of 3
mg/kg po in the Vogel conflict and PTZ tests, but were
generally less active than 24.
The in vivo biological data highlighting efficacy and side
effect testing for PBI compounds 24, 28, 40, and diaze-
pam are shown in Table 4. Several of these compounds
had pharmacological attributes that warranted further
investigation. In fact, compound 24 has excellent oral
efficacy, in both the PTZ (mice) and conflict assays (rats),
while possessing a beneficial separation from the side
effects of motor impairment in the horizontal screen (HS)
assay (mice; see Table 4). Compound 28, shows appreci-
able separation between efficacy in the PTZ assay and the
horizontal screen side effect test. Lastly, compound 40 was
found to display the least separation in the (HS/PTZ) side-
effect profile (Table 4). Among these compounds which
were evaluated in detail, there was no difference in the
relative degree of ethanol sleep time. Given that the
results for 24 are quite favorable relative to close ana-
logue 28 and diazepam, this compound is presently
being investigated more extensively.12
Based on the biological data discussed thus far, incor-
poration of the ethoxymethyl group on the N5 position
of the PBI nucleus was found to impart favorable
anxiolytic activity. The best compound for continued
structure–activity relationship (SAR) studies was 24.
The next region for SAR development in this series
centered on ring A and particularly halogen atom sub-
stitution, with the placement of halogen atoms at var-
ious positions on the phenyl ring (Table 2). Absence of a
fluoro group at position 7 (33) resulted in a ca. 1000-
fold decrease in vitro affinity versus compound 24. The
7-chlorophenyl analogue 34 exhibited in vitro potency
but a higher G.S. than 24. The 8,9-difluorophenyl com-
pound 35 was unexpectedly less active in vitro