Communications
water), anhydromevalonolactone (AMLL), and b-methyl-d-valer-
olactone (BMVL). Under conditions similar to those used for
the reduction of MGBL (1008C, 140 bar H2), we found that the
reduction of MLL resulted in 3-methyl-1,3,5-pentanetriol
(MPTO) with high selectivity (91%). Additionally, the reduction
of BMVL and AMLL both gave 3-methyl-1,5-pentanediol
(MPDO) with similarly high selectivities (86 to 91%). A more
detailed description of this work is available in the Supporting
Information.
that stop at MGBL formation. If this first reaction was conduct-
ed with bimetallic catalysts that contained Re or Ru, then only
a small amount of ring opening of MGBL would occur, as the
thermodynamic equilibrium ratio of [MBDO]/([MBDO]+
[MGBL]) approaches zero at this temperature. The high tem-
perature exacerbates the entropic penalty of combining MGBL
and two hydrogen molecules to produce MBDO (Figure S4).
Moreover, the high reaction temperature would lead to unde-
sirable hydrogenolysis reactions of the little amount of MBDO
that was produced. Alternatively, a single low temperature for
the entire process (MA to MGBL to MBDO) would lead to negli-
gibly slow overall rates that are limited by the conversion of
MA into MGBL.
Pd/C was previously demonstrated to be active for the con-
version of IA into MGBL by Li et al., who examined the effects
of active carbon pretreatment on selectivity for MGBL forma-
tion.[22] Here, we show the effect of temperature and pressure
on the TOF for MGBL formation, demonstrating TOFs of
1.2 minꢀ1 at 2408C and 140 bar. The ability of palladium to in-
corporate hydrogen into its crystal lattice is possibly the
reason why its performance is superior to that of other tested
catalysts. Pd was highly active for both hydrogenation of the
double bond in IA or MA and the reduction of the free carbox-
ylic acid present in MSA, yet Pd/C did not catalyze the facile
conversion of MGBL into MBDO. Studies of succinic acid hydro-
genation by using Pd-based catalysts led to similar results, for
which a low concentration of the diol was formed by using
Pd-only catalysts.[13]
To demonstrate the potential of these branched alcohols as
monomers, we prepared a variety of aliphatic polyesters by
using condensation polymerization with tin(II) 2-ethylhexa-
noate as a catalyst. As described in detail in the Supporting In-
formation, BDO, MBDO, and MPD were each treated with
either SA or MSA to prepare each of the six possible polyes-
ters. As summarized in Figure 4, the addition of a methyl sub-
In the final step, thermodynamic calculations (Figure S5) in-
dicated that at 140 bar, the conversion of MGBL into MBDO is
only favorable at temperatures below approximately 1408C (at
higher H2 pressures, the threshold temperature is higher); thus,
a low-temperature-active catalyst was required for the final
process step. Bimetallic catalysts composed of Pd-Re have
been proposed for the conversion of closely related g-butyro-
lactone into BDO.[9–11] Here, we found that monometallic Ru/C
effectively promoted the conversion of MGBL into MBDO in
approximately 80% yield, as shown in Figure 3. The rate of Ru
leaching from Ru/C was sufficiently low, demonstrating process
viability (i.e., the rate of leaching was three to four orders of
magnitude lower than a viable rate[24]) and that the reaction
was catalyzed heterogeneously (complete details in the Sup-
porting Information).
Figure 4. Differential scanning calorimetry traces comparing the effect of
methyl substitution on glass-transition temperature of methyl-substituted
poly(butylene succinate) with non-methyl-substituted poly(butylene succi-
nate); the molar masses of these four samples are similar (each is ꢁ10 to
15 kgmolꢀ1). Neither methylsuccinic acid nor 2-methyl-1,4-butanediol is sym-
metric, and the two monomers may be oriented head-to-tail, head-to-head,
tail-to-tail, or tail-to-head within the polymer backbone.
Previous work addressing the conversion of g-valerolactone
into 1,5-pentanediol with homogeneous Ru-based catalysts
suggests that the intermediates for lactone hydrogenation to
diols are the lactol and open-chain hydroxy aldehyde; the re-
maining carbonyl group is then hydrogenated to yield the
diol.[15] It is apparent from the experiments performed here
that Ru/C promotes the CꢀO bond breaking that is necessary
for lactone ring opening. Re could also promote the ring-open-
ing mechanism given the results obtained with Re for succinic
acid and itaconic acid hydrogenation.[8,23] The undesired hydro-
genolysis of MBDO to isobutyl alcohol and n-butanol over Ru/
C catalysts is known; generically, RCH2OH+2H2!RH+CH4 +
H2O.[14] For MBDO, the end products of hydrogenolysis are
C3H8 +2CH4 +2H2O.
stituent to either the diacid or diol had a significant impact on
the thermal properties of the resulting polyester.[25,26] Whereas
polybutylene succinate, the polymer resulting from the poly-
merization of succinic acid and 1,4-butanediol, is semicrystal-
line with a melting point of Tm =114 8C, the methyl-substituted
polyesters were all fully amorphous with low glass-transition
temperature values (Tg below ꢀ358C for each sample). These
soft, rubbery polyesters may be appropriate for numerous ap-
plications, including use in coatings, adhesives, sealants, elasto-
mers, and foams.[27,28]
Splitting the overall process into two sequential steps with
monometallic catalysts enabled efficient production of MBDO
from IA or MA in high yield. The initial hydrogenation of IA or
MA at high temperatures (2408C) produces high TOFs on Pd/C
As illustrated here as well as in previous examples, biomass-
derived feedstocks can be utilized in hybrid fermentation/ther-
mocatalytic processes to produce drop-in replacements or en-
&
ChemCatChem 2016, 8, 1 – 6
4
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ÝÝ These are not the final page numbers!