P. Alfonso-Súarez et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 56 (2015) 6863–6867
6865
total number of electrons passed in the electrochemical reaction.
Table 2
The effect of varying F/mole. Potential held at +1.8 V in all cases
Once the amount of charge (C/mol) is known, the chronocoulometry
experiment can be performed. Through monitoring the charge, one
can determine how long the reaction will take to go to completion.
In order to decrease this time, large surface area electrodes and
mechanical stirring of the solution are typically employed.
Table 1 demonstrates the percentage conversions obtained for 1
to 2 using a range of voltages (+1.5 to +2.4 V) around the known
oxidation potential (+1.65 V). In all cases the temperature was
fixed at 0 °C, 4 F/mole was used and identical surface area elec-
trodes were used. All reactions were performed on the same scale
and upon reaction completion, the solvent was evaporated and the
Entry
F/mole
Time (min)
Normalised % conversion to 2
1
2
3
4
2
3
4
5
17
23
36
43
29
36
95
n.d.
a
a
Decomposition was observed in the 1H NMR spectrum, indicative of over-
reaction to 5 amongst other side products; n.d. = not determined.
O
-e-
O
-
+
O
O
-e , -H
deprotonation
Ph
N
Ph
N
Ph
N
Ph
N
residue was dissolved in 0.60 mL d
.0 ppm internal reference).12
It was found that as the voltage of the electrosynthesis reaction
increased from +1.5 V to +2.4 V a clear maxima was observed at
1.9 V. However, discoloration of the electrodes (from black to grey
6
-DMSO (with TMS as the
1
4
5
0
+
-
MeOH
+
- MeOH
H
>
> V
O
OMe
or >> F/mol
or strongly
protic solvent
+
Ph
N
5 + decompostion
products
and then blue) suggested over reaction and deposition on the elec-
trode surface at this potential which would require replacement of
the electrode materials for every reaction, limiting the green
potential of this method. As the potential (V) was increased, the
potential approaches and becomes outside of the potential window
at which point solvent decomposition/degradation occurs. In this
instance, the electrosynthetic process becomes complicated by
solvent degradation products which affect the efficiency of the
formation of the desired product 2.
In conclusion, based on modification of the voltage parameter,
as shown above (Table 1) it is pertinent to hold the potential for
the electrosynthetic reaction at +1.9 V. Therefore, a simple formula
based on cyclic voltammetry can be proposed for this example:
Potentiostat voltage = CV oxidation potential (E/V) + a suitably
applied over potential voltage (E/V). However, for the following
experiments we decided to use +1.8 V for the following variation
of the F/mole to reduce electrode attrition and reduce the severity
of solvent degradation.
The Shono two-electron process should only necessitate the use
of 2 F/mole, however the use of an excess, often 4 F/mole is used.
We next investigated whether the reaction can indeed be per-
formed at a lower charge (Table 2).
It was evident from Table 2 that 4 F/mole was optimal to
achieve the highest conversion. The exact reason as to why this
experimental value was twice that required theoretically (see
Scheme 2 for the formation of the intermediate N-acyliminium
ion 4) is not fully understood but could possibly be due to the con-
comitant oxidation of solvent breakdown and/or over-reaction; the
exact reason will be considered in future reactions. Scheme 2
highlights this issue.
2
Scheme 2. Postulated mechanism to form 2 via N-acyliminium intermediate 4 and
possible routes to the side-reaction product, enamide 5 amongst others.
Removal of a single electron from the lone pair of the amide
nitrogen atom generates an unstable radical cation. Removal of
the second electron via the concomitant expulsion of a proton gen-
erates the N-acyliminium ion 4 which can be intercepted by
methanol to yield 2. As expected in an acidic environment it is pos-
2
sible for 2 to revert to 4 via an E mechanism. N-acyliminium 4
may also deprotonate to enamide 5 via either 2, 4 or 5 to give a
variety of other decomposition products. It was noted that the
presence of compounds other than amide 1 or the desired oxida-
tion product 2 could be influenced via increasing the protic
strength of the solvent and/or electrolyte (see later), increased
charge or the over-voltage applied to the reaction system.
We next considered whether the choice of electrolyte influ-
enced the outcome of the reaction (Table 3). Interestingly, the orig-
inally selected electrolyte, tetrabutylammonium perchlorate
1
3
(
TBAP), afforded the highest conversion and yield despite using
the same conditions of charge and voltage. Of note, it was found
that changing both the electrolyte and solvent resulted in a quan-
titative conversion to enamide 5 (comparison with Ref. 14) in 100%
MeOH. Enamide 5 was not isolated due to instability on silica gel
chromatography.
At this point, it was considered whether the perchlorate counter
ion accelerated or caused a background chemical oxidation event
independent of the electrical voltage applied. It could be seen both
from entry 1 in Table 1 and from a control experiment of 1 in TBAP
at 0 °C, that this caused no detectable change to 2. Therefore, we
next sought to optimise the concentration of TBAP employed
(
Table 4).
Table 1
It was found, that in all cases, conversion of 1 to 2 was achieved
Variation of potential at a fixed F/mole on the percentage conversion of 1 to 2
but halving the concentration resulted in doubling the time
Entry
Voltage (V)
F/mole
Time (h)
Normalised % conversion to 2a
1
2
3
3
4
5
6
7
8
+1.5
+1.6
+1.7
+1.8
+1.9
+2.0
+2.1
+2.2
+2.4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
2.6
2.0
3.2
2.2
2.3
1.7
0.9
1.4
0.2
0
26
93
95
100
99
77
75
Table 3
Changing the electrolyte based on the optimal +1.8 V and 4 F/mole conditions using
MeCN/MeOH; (10:1) unless otherwise stated to convert 1 to 2
Entry
Electrolyte
Time (min)
Normalised % conversion to 2
1
2
3a
Bu
Me
4
NClO
NClO
4
(TBAP)
36
—
60
218
—
99%
Not soluble
20%
0% (99% 5)
Limited solubility
Not soluble
Not soluble
4
4
(TMAP)
b
n.d.
Et
Et
4
NOTs
NOTs
a
3
4
5
6
b
4
a
The maximal integration of the diagnostic proton at 4.78 ppm is ca. 0.75H due
to the existence of rotamers around the amide bond accentuated by unsymmetrical
NaBF
NaOSO
Bu NI (TBAI)
4
2
Ph
—
—
methoxylation of one of the ethyl chains.
4
b
New aromatic protons were observed in the 1H NMR spectrum suggesting
a
formation of enamide 5 amongst other side products; n.d. = not determined.
Using 100% MeOH as solvent.