T. Stoll et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 56 (2015) 772–774
773
O
N
Cl
N
Cl
N
a
b
N
N
N
N
O
Cl
NH
Cl
2a
99%
81%
Cl
N
O
3a
1a
82%
c
Scheme 2. Reagents and conditions: (a) i-PrCOCl (2.2 equiv), Et3N (2.7 equiv), DCM, rt; (b) solvent, reagent, 80 °C, 4 h, best conditions: Cs2CO3 (2 equiv), DMF; (c) best
conditions without purification of 2a.
intermediates was less of an issue. Although compound 2a was
chromatographed and crystallized for X-ray analysis, the material
decomposed within several days at room temperature.
O
N
Cl
N
Regarding the scope of the reaction, different R1 substituents
were tolerated (entries 1–4). Access to compound 3e through the
PMB-cleavage of 3d using TFA/TfOH at 110 °C may allow the intro-
duction of a variety of R1-substituents at a later stage, for example,
by alkylation or arylation. Unfortunately, when at least one of R2 or
R3 was hydrogen, the reaction failed (entry 10), chlorine was not
tolerated (entry 12), and two bulky substituents also prevented
product formation (entry 13).
Cl
2a
N
O
Figure 1. Structure of b-spirolactam 2a confirmed by X-ray.
In order to shed light on the reasons for this, an idea about a
putative mechanism of this reaction may be helpful. A mechanism
has been proposed for a similar reaction.4 The isolation and charac-
terization of b-spirolactam 2a is especially interesting and con-
firms one proposed intermediate.
The formation of b-lactams from imines under these conditions
is known as the Staudinger Ketene–Imine Cycloaddition reaction
for more than a century.5
Table 1
Scope of the reaction
O
R2
Cl
R1
N
N
Cl
R3
N
N
N
O
Cl
NH
R1
Cl
R2
Our own experiments provide some clues toward a possible
mechanism of the transformation (Table 2).
R3
Entry
Starting Material
3-Substituents
Product
Yield+ (%)
When only acid chloride was used without a base no reaction
occurred (no ketene formation, entry 1). The same was observed
when an acid chloride which is unable to form a ketene was
employed (entry 2). These results indicate that formation of a
ketene is needed to start the reaction.
Using a mixture of both acid chlorides gave only the known
b-lactam 2a (entries 3 and 4). This suggests that in all steps of
the reaction only the ketene reacts rather than the acid chloride.
It is also important to note that even when an enantiomerically
pure acid chloride was employed (Table 1, entry 11), the product
was obtained as racemate.
Based on these results we propose a putative mechanism
(Scheme 3) where the acid chloride serves only as the precursor
of the ketene and does not have any other role in the reaction.
The ketene on the other hand is involved both in first: Formation
of the amide on the pyridazine nitrogen creating the imine (inter-
mediate B) and second: The b-lactam formation.
No
R1
R2
R3
No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
1a
1b
1c
1d
1e
1a
1a
1a
1a
1a
1a
1a
1a
c-Pr
Me
Ph
PMB
H
c-Pr
c-Pr
c-Pr
c-Pr
c-Pr
c-Pr
c-Pr
c-Pr
Me
Me
Me
Me
Me
Me
3a
3b
3c
3d
3e
82
68
Me
Me
Me
Me
41
62++
0*
c-Pr
0***
68
c-Bu
c-Pent
4-THP
4a
5a
6a
63
69
0
H
H, Me, Ph
Me
Cl
Ph
Ph
Me, Cl
Ph
7a
39+++
0***
0**
+
++
Isolated yields are reported.
PMB group can be cleaved using TFA/TfOH to give compound 3e in 77% yield.
(S)-(+) enantiomer of acid chloride used, 7a isolated as racemate.
N-acetylaction was observed.
+++
*
**
First step failed.
Second step failed.
The Staudinger Ketene–Imine Cycloaddition is believed to pro-
ceed by first the attack of the imine nitrogen on the ketene (inter-
mediate B to C) and a subsequent conrotatory electrocyclization
leading to the b-lactam.6
***
It is noteworthy that performing just an aqueous workup after
the first step led to major advantages. Besides circumventing
possible purification problems when having diastereomeric
b-spirolactams (e.g., entries 10 and 11), instability of the resulting
The formation of the pyrrolo[2,3-c]pyridazin-6-one (Scheme 4)
will likely happen by attack of the base at either the
a-hydrogen or
the carbonyl group of the amide, leading to re-aromatization and
Table 2
Experiments around b-lactam formation
Entry Conditions
Result
1
2
3
1a, i-PrCOCl 2.2 equiv, no base, DCM
1a, t-BuCOCl 2.2 equiv, Et3N 2.7 equiv, DCM
1a, i-PrCOCl 1 equiv, t-BuCOCl 1 equiv, Et3N 2.7 equiv, Exclusive formation of b-lactam 2a
No reaction
No reaction
DCM
4
1a, i-PrCOCl 2.2 equiv, t-BuCOCl 10 equiv, Et3N
13 equiv, DCM
Formation of b-lactam 2a, small amounts of byproducts which did not incorporate reaction with
pivaloyl chloride