Angewandte
Chemie
DOI: 10.1002/anie.201410233
Electrocatalysis
A Highly Selective Copper–Indium Bimetallic Electrocatalyst for the
Electrochemical Reduction of Aqueous CO2 to CO**
Shahid Rasul, Dalaver H. Anjum, Abdesslem Jedidi, Yury Minenkov, Luigi Cavallo, and
Kazuhiro Takanabe*
Abstract: The challenge in the electrochemical reduction of
aqueous carbon dioxide is in designing a highly selective,
energy-efficient, and non-precious-metal electrocatalyst that
minimizes the competitive reduction of proton to form hydro-
gen during aqueous CO2 conversion. A non-noble metal
electrocatalyst based on a copper-indium (Cu-In) alloy that
selectively converts CO2 to CO with a low overpotential is
reported. The electrochemical deposition of In on rough Cu
surfaces led to Cu-In alloy surfaces. DFT calculations showed
that the In preferentially located on the edge sites rather than on
the corner or flat sites and that the d-electron nature of Cu
remained almost intact, but adsorption properties of neighbor-
ing Cu was perturbed by the presence of In. This preparation of
non-noble metal alloy electrodes for the reduction of CO2
provides guidelines for further improving electrocatalysis.
special attentions because it is a metal that produces hydro-
carbons during the CO2 reduction reaction.[3–13]
CO is one of the desired products from the reduction of
CO2 with high selectivity because CO can be further reduced
to oxygenates and hydrocarbons electrochemically.[14–16]
Recently, Li and Kanan reported the superior performance
of oxide-derived Cu (OD-Cu) in aqueous CO2 reduction
compared to polycrystalline Cu under the identical condi-
tions.[7] The OD-Cu electrocatalyst, however, suffers from low
product selectivity, co-generating H2.[7,13] Additionally,
although the morphology changes by the oxidation treatment
are prominent, the effective active sites on Cu-based surfaces
are still under debate, despite a large number of previous
studies.[3–16] On the other hand, noble metals, including Au
and Ag, are electrocatalysts that can efficiently reduce
aqueous CO2 to CO, with selectivities approaching
100%,[17,18] but their high cost remains a concern. Non-
noble metal bismuth-based electrode necessitates the pres-
ence of ionic liquids and non-aqueous phase to demonstrate
high performance to generate CO from CO2, and the effects
of the active components and of the electrolyte remain
unclear.[19]
Designing a CO2-reducing electrocatalyst should thus be
focused on the use of non-noble-metals that are selective and
energy-efficient. Recently, various strategies have been
reported for the conversion of CO2, including alloying of
copper with other metals,[20–23] and for the electrochemical
reduction reaction using density functional theory (DFT)
calculations to obtain higher selectivity and energy effi-
ciency.[24–27] The general trend is that the binding strengths of
the intermediates on the catalyst surface need to be adequate
and thus the importance of the surface coordinately unsatu-
rated sites has been addressed.[6,9,11,14,15] Bimetallic
approaches have also been explored by DFT calculations,
which may change the conventional electronic structure
associated with d-center theory,[24,25] and/or geometric and
ensemble effects of the metal active sites.[27] The competitive
interaction of H+/water with two metal centers may control
the reaction pathway during the electrochemical reduction of
CO2, promoting the reduction of CO2 on one or both of the
metal centers, thereby resulting in better selectivity. This
study focused on an indium electrodeposited Cu electro-
catalyst, which resulted in the formation of a Cu-In alloy that
works at moderate overpotentials with exclusive selectivity
for CO and excellent stability.
T
he development of an artificial photosynthesis process that
converts CO2 and stores the energy in the form of chemical
bonds is one of the grand challenges in modern chemistry.[1,2]
However, the limited choice of electrocatalysts that are
energy-efficient, selective, and stable increases the complex-
ity of this process.[3] Conventionally, metal electrodes have
been utilized as electrocatalysts for the aqueous CO2 reduc-
tion reaction, and the product distribution strongly depends
on the nature of the electrode surface and the electrolyte.[3]
Hori and co-workers observed that the CO2 reduction
reaction reproducibly yields CO, CH4, HCOOH and other
hydrocarbon products and that the selectivity of the products
is determined by the nature of the metallic electrode.[3,4]
Among the various metallic electrodes, copper has attracted
[*] Dr. S. Rasul, Dr. A. Jedidi, Dr. Y. Minenkov, Prof. L. Cavallo,
Prof. K. Takanabe
Division of Physical Sciences and Engineering
KAUST Catalysis Center (KCC)
King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST)
4700 KAUST, 23955-6900 Thuwal (Saudi Arabia)
E-mail: kazuhiro.takanabe@kaust.edu.sa
Dr. D. H. Anjum
Advanced Nanofabrication Imaging and Characterization Core Lab
King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST)
4700 KAUST, 23955-6900 Thuwal (Saudi Arabia)
[**] The research reported herein was supported by the King Abdullah
University of Science and Technology. L.C. and A.J. are grateful to
the KAUST Supercomputing Laboratory for the resources provided
under the project k199.
OD-Cu substrate was obtained by thermally oxidizing
a Cu metal sheet at 773 K for 2 h in static air.[13] This
treatment led to the formation of a hairy CuO nanowire
structure on Cu2O-Cu layers,[13] resulting in a surface rough-
Supporting information for this article (including experimental and
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 1 – 6
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
1
These are not the final page numbers!