526 J. Phys. Chem. A, Vol. 101, No. 4, 1997
Sogoshi et al.
may react, during the dark period, with a hydrogen atom
photogenerated by reaction 2 as follows.
Annealing Period. The continued increase of ethane and
the rapid decay of ethyl radical in Figure 4 may be understood
if reaction 6 is favored at the elevated temperatures, which is
plausible. Since there is no sign of the regeneration of ethyl
iodide and the appearance of absorption of butane,21 neither the
reverse reaction of 1 nor the dimerization of the radical takes
place. As for the two ethylenes in the annealing period,
broadening and distortion of the spectrum prevent meaningful
plotting in Figure 4 so that they are omitted.
CH2dCH2 + ‚H f ‚C2H5
(5)
According to reaction 5 ethyl radical should increase with
the decrease of the low-frequency ethylene. However, Figure
4 shows the decrease of the absorbance of ethyl radical during
the dark period. Figure 4 also demonstrates a continuous
increase of ethane and a slight decrease of the high-frequency
ethylene under dark. In order to elucidate these results the
following mechanism is proposed on the basis of the reported
migration of hydrogen atom in solid parahydrogen at 4.2 K:25
Some of the hydrogen atoms photogenerated by reaction 2 may
escape into the bulk, where some of them recombine to
hydrogen molecule and some encounter ethyl radical to result
in reaction 6.
Concluding Remarks
As in the previous work on methyl iodide, photoreactions
and thermal reactions in the ethyl iodide system are pursued
by observing the vibrational spectroscopic changes. The system
is relatively simple, involving only ethyl iodide, ethyl radical,
ethane, and ethylene. Yet, new findings are obtained such as
the formation of two kinds of ethylene and the reactions
involving the migrating hydrogen atom. These reactions may
have relevance to molecular evolution on hydrogen covered cold
surfaces of dusts in interstellar space. The cryogenic reactions
may also be enticing to theoretical chemists for the study of
tunneling reaction. An important advantage of the solid
parahydrogen matrix is that we are free from the cage effect
inherent in conventional rare gas matrices. This allows the study
of in situ photolytic reactions in detail by means of vibrational
spectroscopy. Utilizing this advantage, we are aiming at
improving the versatility of matrix isolation spectroscopy.
A remaining problem is that no absorption was detected in
the region where hydrogen iodide in several matrices is reported
to absorb, i.e., 2255-2230 cm-1 in argon,27,28 2240-2210 cm-1
in krypton,28 and 2238 cm-1 in nitrogen.28 In this context a
statement is noted that “the absorbance of monomer HI appears
to be significantly weaker than the absorbance of HI that forms
a hydrogen bond to another molecule. It is therefore difficult
to observe monomer HI in a matrix without significant dimer
absorptions.”27
Another comment will be made on reaction 5; Klein and
Scheer did not mention anything about the prototype reaction
5 in their classic work on reactions between various alkenes
and hydrogen atom at temperatures above 77 K, which may be
allusive to the absence of appreciable reaction between ethylene
and hydrogen atom under their experimental conditions.29
However, the environment in the present work is considerably
different from that of the previous workers so that there may
not be serious conflict between the two studies.
Finally, we note the difference of the behavior of methyl
radical in the previously studied methyl iodide/p-H2 system1,2
versus the behavior of ethyl radical in the present system. The
methyl radical in the methyl iodide/p-H2 system did not show
noticeable decay under dark during the experimental time scale,
which is in contrast to the present system. Further comparative
studies on the two systems are now under way.
‚C2H5 + ‚H f C2H6
(6)
The hydrogen atom may also encounter the high-frequency
ethylene produced by reaction 4 to cause the same reaction as
5. However, reaction 6 would proceed more easily than reaction
5 because the former is a barrier free reaction. If the absolute
absorbance of ethyl radical is large, the decrease of observed
absorbance of ethyl radical due to reaction 6 may surmount the
increase due to reaction 5 which proceeds with a barrier. Since
the hydrogen atom produced by reactions 1 and 2 will find near-
lying ethylene of reaction 2 more easily than far-lying ethylene
of reaction 4, the low-frequency ethylene will decrease more
easily than the high-frequency ethylene. The fast and slow
decreases of the low- and high-frequency ethylenes during the
dark period may reflect this difference of the reaction efficiency.
Reillumination Period. The quick recovery of the low-
frequency ethylene shown in Figure 4 (see also Figure 3) is
attributed to reaction 2 coupled with reaction 1, resulting in the
complex between ethylene and iodine atom. After the con-
sumption of ethyl iodide the absorption of 253.7 nm photons
by the ethyl radical in reaction 2 becomes efficient, which causes
the excitation of the radical to a 3s Rydberg state.20 The
recovery of the low-frequency ethylene should be related to the
noticeably accelerated decrease of ethyl radical (compare the
second and third panels of Figure 4). The continued increase
of ethane in the top panel of Figure 4 is attributable to reaction
6, which should proceed irrespective of the light and dark
periods.
As for the high-frequency ethylene, which has survived until
the end of the dark period, it starts to decrease appreciably as
is seen from Figure 4 (see also Figure 3). Simultaneously, the
low-frequency ethylene continues to increase overpassing the
maximum in spectrum IV of Figure 3. Since the low-frequency
ethylene originating from monomeric ethyl iodide in reaction
1 is not available limitlessly, the continued increase of the low-
frequency ethylene from spectrum V to VI of Figure 3 must be
associated with other remaining C2 carriers, that is, the high-
frequency ethylene. With the depletion of ethyl iodide and ethyl
radical, both absorbing 253.7 nm photons, the absorption by
iodine molecule produced from the molecular reaction corre-
sponding to 3 will become more and more significant. The
absorption of iodine molecule is well-known to cause photolysis
into two iodine atoms.26 The iodine atom will find the nearby
ethylene from reaction 4, i.e., the high-frequency ethylene, and
will form a complex between the ethylene and the iodine atom,
which is nothing other than the low-frequency ethylene. This
mechanism explains the increase of the low-frequency ethylene
as shown in spectrum VI of Figure 3.
In the present work, dedicated to Professor Saburo Nagakura,
we put emphasis on dynamical aspects of electronically excited
ethyl iodide. There remain, however, several points worthy of
further investigation on the present system from the viewpoint
of vibrational spectroscopy. These include (1) the elucidation
of the aforementioned incomplete agreement of the vibrational
spectrum of ethyl radical between the present work and the
literature,6,17 (2) the broad radical absorption at 3122.8 in
contrast to the very sharp ones at 3032.6, 2984.3, 2879.1, 2812.1,
and 2716.5 cm-1 as well as the broadness of ethane absorption,
and (3) the conspicuously large spectral shift between the low-
and the high-frequency ethylenes at 948.6 vs 957.3 cm-1
assigned to an in-plane C-H scissoring mode of the ethylenic
unit in the complex, to name a few.