Communication
enantioselectivity in the cleavage of UpU. The ability to display
enantioselective catalysis brings these synthetic nanosystems
another step closer to mimicking enzymes.
Abstract: Enantioselectivity in RNA cleavage by a synthetic
metalloenzyme has been demonstrated for the first time.
Thiols containing chiral ZnII-binding head groups have
been self-assembled on the surface of gold nanoparticles.
This results in the spontaneous formation of chiral bimet-
allic catalytic sites that display different activities (kcat) to-
wards the enantiomers of an RNA model substrate. Sub-
strate selectivity is observed when the nanozyme is ap-
plied to the cleavage of the dinucleotides UpU, GpG, ApA,
and CpC, and remarkable differences in reactivity are ob-
served for the cleavage of the enantiomerically pure dinu-
cleotide UpU.
We have prepared two batches of NPs (Figure 1), each
coated with a self-assembled monolayer of enantiomerically
pure thiols where the chirality of the head group is derived
from either l or d serine.[8] To ensure nanoparticle uniformity,
Chemists have long been fascinated with the complexity and
efficiency of Nature’s enzymes. This has led to the develop-
ment of numerous synthetic systems that try to emulate the
properties of this natural machinery.[1] Recently, gold nanoparti-
cles (AuNPs) passivated by thiols which terminate with metal
complexes[2] have been shown to possess many features of
metalloenzymes.[3] These include the cooperativity between
neighboring metal ions and Michaelis–Menten kinetics in the
cleavage of phosphodiester bonds.[2b] These AuNPs have thus
emerged as an attractive platform for the development of syn-
thetic enzymes[4] and, in particular, as a model[5] for nucleases.
However, despite the large body of work dedicated to synthet-
ic metalloenzymes for RNA cleavage,[2,5,6] there are to the best
of our knowledge no studies aimed at enantiodifferentiation.
This is a remarkable fact considering that enantioselectivity is
one of the hallmarks of enzyme catalysis.
Figure 1. Schematic representation of the self-assembly of thiols containing
chiral head groups on the surface of dioctylamine-passivated gold nanopar-
ticles to form (+)-1 and (À)-1 NPs, which are active for the catalysis of
CF3HPNP. CF3HPNP=2-hydroxypropyl p-nitro-m-trifluoromethylphenyl phos-
phate. Only one hemisphere of the (+)-1 and (À)-1 NPs is shown.
Our aim was to employ AuNPs as a platform on which to
self-assemble chiral precursors and generate an active catalyst
capable of enantiodiscrimination. This goal is fundamentally
different to the immobilization of known and established chiral
catalysts onto gold nanoparticles (or other solid supports).[7] In
our proposed system, the individual thiols only represent half
the catalytic site, and its self-assembly on the surface of the
gold nanoparticle is essential for formation of the active cata-
lyst. In fact, it has been shown previously that the individual
metal complexes are poorly active for the transphosphoryla-
tion of a RNA model substrate when free in solution,[2c] giving
further importance to the self-assembly process. Herein, we
report that chiral metal-binding thiols are indeed able to self-
assemble on the surface of AuNPs to form active catalysts and
exhibit different reactivity for the enantiomers of a pure RNA
model substrate. Subsequently, by taking advantage of the
multivalent nature of the nanozyme, additional binding inter-
actions with dinucleotides were exploited to induce substrate
selectivity in the cleavage of UpU, GpG, ApA, and CpC and
the two batches of NPs (+)-1 and (À)-1 were synthesized from
a single batch of dioctylamine-coated NPs prepared using
a modified version of the procedure by Peng et al.[9] This in-
volved initial stabilization of the gold nanoparticles by
a weakly coordinating ligand, which allowed for uniform size
distribution, prior to final stabilization by the addition of thiols.
The resulting well-distributed sub-2 nm gold NPs were split
into two, before introduction of the corresponding enantio-
meric thiols to each batch. The final NPs (+)-1 and (À)-1 were
analyzed by 1H NMR, UV spectroscopy, transmission electron
microscopy (TEM), and dynamic light scattering (DLS) and
found to be identical (see the Supporting Information). Ther-
mogravimetric analysis also confirmed that the loading of
thiols onto (+)-1 and (À)-1 NPs were the same. Critically, circu-
lar dichroism (CD) measurements displayed equal and opposite
signals at 204 nm for NPs (+)-1 and (À)-1, reflecting the pres-
ence of thiols of opposite chirality on the NP surface.
The thiols employed in the above-mentioned self-assembly
terminate with triazacyclononane (TACN) metal-binding units.
The resulting complexes with ZnII are the crucial elements for
cleaving the phosphodiester moiety of an RNase substrate.
Previous studies have shown that at least two neighboring
metal ions work cooperatively (see Figure 1).[5f] At this point,
we needed to synthesize enantiomerically pure RNA model
[a] Dr. J. L.-Y. Chen, Dr. C. Pezzato, Prof. Dr. P. Scrimin, Prof. Dr. L. J. Prins
Department of Chemical Sciences, University of Padova
Via Marzolo 1, 35131 Padova (Italy)
Supporting information for this article and ORCID for the corresponding
author are available on the WWW under
Chem. Eur. J. 2016, 22, 7028 – 7032
7029
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim