E. Pesce, et al.
Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters 30 (2020) 127473
Fig. 5. Potentiator activity of novel thiazoles. The
bar graphs report F508del-CFTR activity in
CFBE41o-cells, incubated at 32 °C for 24 h to rescue
defective mutant CFTR maturation, after acute
treatment with hits, at the indicated concentrations.
Activity was measured with the HS-YFP assay. The
dotted lines indicate the level of activity in cells
treated with forskolin alone (DMSO, negative con-
trol) and with the positive control, potentiator VX-
7
70 (1 µM). Data are reported as mean
±
SD
(
(
n = 8). **P < 0.01, *P < 0.05 versus control
ANOVA with Dunnett’s post hoc test).
physicochemical parameters, which according to Lipinski’s rule of five
indicate crucial characteristics for oral bioavailability, were evaluated:
molecular weight (MW), calculated logarithm of the octanol-water
partition coefficient (LogP), number of H-bond donors (nHBD), number
of H-bond acceptors (nHBA) and number of rotatable bonds (nRB),
together with the topological polar surface area (TPSA). Lipinski’s rule
of five states that, to be orally active, a small molecule should have
MW ≤ 500 Daltons, LogP ≤ 5, nHBD ≤ 5, nHBA ≤ 10 and
nucleus of these compounds is not adequately decorated to obtain a
corrector activity. On the other hand, considering the potentiator ac-
tivity, two compounds emerged (10 and 11) that, although less effec-
tive than the positive control Ivacaftor™ (VX-770), significantly po-
tentiated F508del-CFTR function. Interestingly, comparing the results
obtained, it is possible to get some insights into the structural re-
quirements necessary to achieve potentiator activity. In particular, the
introduction of a halogen at para position of the phenyl group, led to an
improvement of the activity. Indeed compound 9, bearing an un-
substituted phenyl group, was not active, whereas compounds 10 and
11, having as substituent chlorine and iodine, respectively, gave the
best results as potentiators (Fig. 4). Furthermore, compounds 10 and 11
2
8,29
nRB ≤ 10.
Absorption and membrane permeability are also influ-
2
enced by TPSA, which should be lower than 140 Å to have intestinal
absorption. The results are reported in Table 1 together with the values
obtained for the reference compound VX-770. All the thiazole deriva-
2
tives obey the Lipinski’s rule and have a TPSA lower than 140 Å , thus
showed similar efficacy but slightly different potency (E
= 1.8,
max
suggesting good gastrointestinal absorption.
EC = 1.8 µM for compound 10; E
= 1.9, EC = 3.2 µM for
5
0
max
50
Finally, compounds 1–16 were not recognized by SwissADME
software as PAINS (Pan Assay INterference compoundS), i.e. molecules
containing substructures showing potent response in assays irrespective
of the target. This evidence allows to exclude that the studied thiazole
derivatives interact nonspecifically and yield false positive biological
output.
compound 11), suggesting that both the halogen substituents con-
tribute in enhancing the activity. Very important seems also the si-
multaneous presence of two ethyl groups, the one of the ester function
and the other one at the benzamide nitrogen. Indeed, neither the ethyl
esters 2 and 3, which do not have the benzamide nitrogen ethylated,
nor the acidic derivatives 6 and 7, bearing an ethyl group only at the
benzamide nitrogen, were active (Fig. 4).
Discussion
Conclusion
The results obtained allow to get some information about the effects
of the thiazole derivatives here described as correctors or potentiators
of F508del-CFTR. Although several thiazole-containing correctors have
In conclusion, although in the experimental model adopted the
designed derivatives showed only poor activity as correctors, this pre-
liminary study allowed to identify compounds 10 and 11, which proved
to have the structural requirements necessary to express some biolo-
gical effects as potentiators, thus suggesting that the studied scaffold,
9
,16–18,19–23
been described so far,
when tested as correctors and com-
pared with Lumacaftor™ (VX-809), none of the thiazole derivatives
–16 showed significant effects, thus suggesting that the thiazole
1
Fig. 6. Specific activation of mutant F508del-CFTR
by novel thiazoles. The bar graphs report F508del-
CFTR activity in CFBE41o-cells, incubated at 32 °C
for 24 h to rescue defective mutant CFTR matura-
tion, after acute treatment with forskolin (fsk,
2
0 µM) plus vehicle alone (DMSO) or VX-770 (1 µM)
or thiazoles (10 µM for both) in the absence or in the
presence of inh-172 (15 µM). Activity was measured
with the HS-YFP assay. The dotted lines indicate the
level of activity in cells treated with forskolin plus
vehicle. Data are reported as mean ± SD (n = 8).
*
**P
<
0.001 versus control (ANOVA with
Dunnett’s post hoc test).
5