European Journal of Organic Chemistry
10.1002/ejoc.201601270
COMMUNICATION
Can Accelerated Reactions in Droplets Guide Chemistry at Scale?
Michael Wleklinski, Caitlin E. Falcone, Bradley P. Loren, Zinia Jaman, Kiran Iyer, H. Samuel Ewan,
Seok-Hee Hyun, David H. Thompson*, and R. Graham Cooks*
Abstract: Mass spectrometry (MS) is used to follow chemical
reactions in droplets. In almost all cases, such reactions are
accelerated relative to the corresponding reactions in bulk, even
after correction for concentration effects, and they serve to predict
the likely success of scaled up reactions performed in microfluidic
flow systems. The particular chemical targets used in these test
studies are diazepam, atropine and diphenhydramine. In addition to
a yes/no prediction of whether scaled up reaction is possible, in
some cases valuable information was obtained which helped in
optimization of reaction conditions, minimization of by-products and
choice of catalyst. In a variant on the spray-based charged droplet
experiment, the Leidenfrost effect was used to generate larger,
uncharged droplets and the same reactions were studied in this
medium. These reactions were also accelerated but to smaller
extents than in microdroplets and they gave results that
corresponded even more closely to microfluidics data. The fact that
MS was also used for on-line reaction monitoring in the microfluidic
systems further enhances the potential role of MS in exploratory
organic synthesis.
differ from ESI based droplets in that they are i) larger ii) net
neutral and iii) involve elevated temperatures. The difference in
droplet size means that larger amounts of reagent can be
studied, but the surface/volume ratio is greatly decreased. The
measured reaction acceleration factors for three previously
studied Leidenfrost reactions, hydrazone formation, Katritsky
pyrylium to pyridinium conversion and 5C] laisen-Schmidt
[
condensation, are about an order of magnitude.
Note that we do not expect to be able to transfer optimized
conditions exactly from the droplet scale to the microfluidics
scale, in part because of uncertainty about the origins of
acceleration effects in the two systems. We do expect that
these optimized conditions will represent a starting point for
efficient optimization of the conditions in the microfluidics
reactor. We also expect that information on reaction
intermediates and mechanisms might be acquired from the
study of droplet reactions. This information is already being
obtained in experiments in which the degree of desolvation of
the initial droplets is varied by changing the distance that the
[1b]
droplets travel before analysis. Information obtained from the
droplet reactor on experimental parameters including solvent,
catalyst, pH, etc. is also readily acquired and we examine how
transferable this information is in optimizing the microfluidics
flow reactor.
The identification of suitable pathways to target molecules is
just one step towards an online, automated flow-through
synthesizer, for which the groundwork has been laid by several
groups. Notable are the mole-scale, end-to-end, continuous
Introduction
This study is part of a larger project, the overall goal of which is
to develop an automated scalable and continuous synthesis
system. A key objective is to test possible synthetic pathways
quickly on a small scale seeking a go/no-go result. We “spot
test” particular routes using a chemical pruning step which
employs reaction acceleration in droplets with independent mass
spectrometric analysis. A simple yes/no answer to product or (in
multistep reactions) intermediate formation is sought using the
charged droplet reactor. We use electrospray (ESI) for both
synthesis and analysis with careful control of parameters to
[
6]
manufacturing pilot plant developed by MIT/Novartis,
the
refrigerator sized, reconfigurable, on demand synthesizer of
[
7]
pharmaceuticals of MIT,
the nanomole-scale robotic high-
[8]
throughput synthesizer of Merck and the automated synthesis
laboratory of Eli Lilly. The mole-scale MIT synthesizer was
used to produce aliskiren hemifumarate in tablet form, from a
[
9]
[
6]
complex intermediate in a continuous fashion. The Merck
nanomole system was used to screen 1,500 reactions per day to
identify potential candidate reactions for large scale synthesis.
The Lilly system combined automated synthesis with analysis
performed remotely controlled in real-time, to produce gram-
scale products.
[
1]
avoid unwanted reaction during analysis.
Charged microdroplets are produced by ESI. It is known
that reaction rates increase as the solvent evaporates because
of changes in concentration, pH, surface/volume ratios, and
interfacial effects.
remarkably large.
accelerated reactions in droplets, including evidence that partial
solvation of reagents at interfaces contributes to the orders of
magnitude reaction rate acceleration that can be seen.
The main question underlying this study is whether droplet
reactions may be used to predict chemical reactivity in flow
chemistry systems, in particular in microfluidics. The mechanism
for acceleration observed in microdroplets is certainly different
from that in microfluidics in that evaporation is not significant in
microfluidics; however, interfacial effects may still play an
[
1b, 1c, 2]
The acceleration factors can be
recent review covers the topic of
[
3]
A
[
1a]
The
[10]
important role especially in droplet microfluidics. The speed of
data acquisition in droplets makes this approach attractive. Note
that false negatives (predict no reaction, but reaction can be
observed) is not expected to be a serious problem because
there are usually many available routes to test. On the other
hand, a false positive result will lead to wasted effort in seeking
an analogous flow reaction. Note, too, that use of droplets for a
simple yes/no regarding occurrence of reaction represents only
one level of enquiry, even though it is the most important one.
As will be seen in the results now to be discussed, information
on reaction conditions is also obtained, although the quality of
this information remains to be evaluated further by studying
more cases.
hypothesis investigated here is that the accelerated reactions
that occur in droplets might assist in rapidly evaluating reactivity
in microfluidic systems.
A second method of producing droplets is based on the
[4]
Leidenfrost effect. It has recently been shown that accelerated
[5]
organic reactions occur in Leidenfrost droplets. These droplets
[*]
M. Wleklinski, C. E. Falcone, B. P. Loren, Z. Jaman, K. Iyer, H. S.
Ewan, Dr. S. Hyun, Prof. D. H. Thompson*, and Prof. R. G. Cooks*
Department of Chemistry, Purdue University
E-mail: davethom@purdue.edu
Homepage: http://aston.chem.purdue.edu
Results and Discussion
Supporting information for this article is given via a link at the end of
the document.
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved