Cyclic Vinyl Sulfones to Transposed Vinyl Phosphonates
A R T I C L E S
Scheme 6. Proof of the Reversibility of the First Step in the Vinyl
Sulfone to Vinyl Phosphonate Transposition
26 required 2 h. Substituted vinyl sulfone 10 underwent smooth
conversion to the vinyl phosphonate. However, unwanted
elimination of the methoxy group leads to dienyl phosphonate
23 if excess base is present. Vinyl sulfone 26 proved to be quite
resistant to the transformation due to hindrance of both faces
of the substrate. The reaction showed no conversion for 12 h
after which the starting material underwent slow decomposition.
The phosphonate anion adds regiospecifically to epoxide 31 in
a 1,4-addition fashion to afford the addition product in 85%
yield. It is worth mentioning that the regio- and stereoselective
phosphite addition to 31 could also be catalytic in the base.
Employing 8 mol % KHMDS in THF resulted in roughly the
same yield of the sole product. Vinyl sulfones 32-35 test
protecting group compatibility with this conversion. These
substrates have two substituents trans to each other and close
to the sulfone moiety presumably reflecting the somewhat longer
reaction times (∼30-50 min). Nevertheless, the conversion was
clean with no side products being observed. Substrates 3214 and
3
3, bearing acyl functionality, undergo the reaction without
difficulty to give the corresponding vinyl phosphonates in 63-
2% and 83% yield, respectively. Hydroxy vinyl sulfones 27
8
in the absence of HMPA, using even 3 equiv of LiHMDS
resulted in the starting material being completely recovered after
and 28 (entries 10 and 11, respectively) bearing unprotected
alcohol groups proved to be quite challenging substrates.
Nevertheless, the desired vinyl phosphonates were detected via
NMR as minor products while the major products were the
elimination products/caged phosphonates (depending on the
position of -OH on the substrate). This is presumably because
the initially formed alpha-sulfonyl anion is immediately quenched
by the free hydroxyl group (Table 2, entry 28), thus preventing
advancement to the vinyl phosphonate. The thus formed
24 h.
Effect of Reaction Concentration
Initial runs were performed at 0.1 M or 0.2 M concentrations.
It was observed that 0.1 M reactions consistently have 10-
2
0% of the starting material remaining. On the other hand,
reactions at 0.2 M or higher result in almost complete consump-
tion of the starting material.
1
5
O-anion then attacks the phosphonate moiety to afford the
This begged the question of whether the first step in the
mechanism was reversible. To explore this possibility, purified
adduct 22 was treated with 0.9 equiv of NaHMDS in THF at
room temperature. Vinyl sulfone 10 was regenerated along with
the formation of vinyl phosphonate 21 in almost a 1:1 ratio
upon rapid quenching of the reaction (Scheme 6). This confirms
that the first step is reversible and that both the sulfone and the
phosphonate moieties are competent as leaving groups. How-
ever, the final sulfonate elimination is irreversible, consistent
with the reported pKa values for diethylphosphite and benze-
nesulfinic acid; 1312 and 2.1 respectively. Since the initial
addition/elimination of phosphonate is reversible while the final
elimination of sulfonate is irreversible, 0.2 M reactions perform
better than 0.1 M ones due to increased local concentrations of
starting materials. Also, this concentration effect explains why
1
6
caged product 28a (see Supporting Information). In contrast,
vinyl sulfone 27 gave the transposed product 27b after elimina-
tion of the -OH group. This is presumably because the initially
formed alpha-sulfonyl anion suffers immediate E1cb elimination
of the -OH group and gives a new vinyl sulfone. In the basic
medium, this vinyl sulfone is rearranged to an allyl sulfone that
is transposed to 27b (see Supporting Information). To overcome
the free hydroxyl limitation, it was appealing to transiently
protect the -OH with a labile protecting group which would
be cleaved during the postreaction workup. The first strategy
attempted protecting the alcohol function as the monoanions
13
27a and 28b using a sodium, potassium, or lithium base at -78
°C. This was followed by the cannulation of the phosphite anion
at -78 °C and then warming to room temperature. Initial trials
utilized NaHMDS and KHMDS as bases. To our surprise, even
using 1 equiv of either base resulted in complete and immediate
decomposition of the vinyl sulfones. Next, LiHMDS was
employed with hopes that the oxidolithium intermediate might
be more stable. Indeed, treating the free hydroxyl vinyl sulfone
28 with 1 equiv of LiHMDS resulted in a stable LiO moiety
and no decomposition was observed. Unfortunately, however,
cannulation of the potassium salt of diethylphosphite anion to
the reaction again yielded the elimination product 28c as the
sole product.
2
.3 equiv of the phosphite anion are needed in the case of
NaHMDS since it is a weaker nucleophile than KHMDS
however, the NaOP(OEt)2 nucleophilicity is somewhat com-
(
pensated by the reaction concentration).
Reaction Scope and Limitation
Table 2 shows the data for using NaHMDS as a base. Vinyl
sulfones 24, 25, and 18 underwent the transposition smoothly
to the corresponding vinyl phosphonates in excellent yields
while the addition products were detected only in trace amounts
(
Table 2, entries 1-3). While transposition of five- and seven-
14) 1H NMR of vinyl sulfone 32 shows the acetate methyl at δ 1.57 ppm, an
(
interesting deviation from the expected value around δ 2.5 ppm.
15) X-ray structure of caged product 28a suggests that the O-anion is formed
through an intermolecular proton transfer rather than an anticipated
intramolecular proton transfer (see Supporting Information for suggested
mechanism).
membered substrates was complete in 10-20 min, vinyl sulfone
(
(
12) Guthrie, J. P. Can. J. Chem. 1979, 57, 236.
(
13) Burkhard, R. K.; Sellers, D. E.; DeCou, F.; Lambert, J. L. J. Org. Chem.
1
959, 24, 767.
(16) Structure confirmed by X-ray crystallography (see Supporting Information).
J. AM. CHEM. SOC. VOL. 129, NO. 36, 2007 11245
9