5
Liu et al. Sci China Chem
The cycling performances of the two CP-based anodes
were investigated at 200 mA g−1. As shown in Figure 3(c, d),
the two CPs exhibited remarkable cycling stability with high
reversible capacity. After 150 cycles, the discharge capa-
cities of CPs 1 and 2 still retain at 815 and 536 mA h g−1 with
relatively high capacity retention, which are higher than the
theoretical capacity of commonly used graphite
(372 mA h g−1). After the specific capacities decrease for the
first 10 cycles caused by the formation of Li2O, the capacities
of electrodes increase from the 10th to the 80th cycle and
then maintain stable up to 150 cycles. This phenomenon of
the capacities increasing should be related to the gradually
electrochemical activation of the SEI film accompanied by
better Li-diffusion kinetics during cycling [41], which was
also observed in other CPs or MOFs [17,27,42]. When per-
formed at 500 mA g−1, the reversible capacities of CPs 1 and
2 are 615 and 410 mA h g−1 after 400 cycles, respectively
(Figure S6(a, b)). The rate performances of the electrodes are
illustrated in Figure 3(e, f). When the rates are gradually
changed from 100 to 200, 300, 500, 1000 and 2000 mA g−1,
the corresponding discharge capacities are 845, 743, 698,
656, 558 mA h g−1 for 1 and 668, 483, 420, 365, 273,
211 mA h g−1 for 2, respectively. When the current rate is
reduced back to 100 mA g−1, the reversible capacities swiftly
recover to the initial stage without apparent decay, demon-
strating the excellent cycling stability to tolerate the current
change. In comparison with the organic ligand H4pztc (Fig-
ure S7) and other pristine CPs as anode materials (Table S4),
the two isostructural CPs in this work possess high reversible
capacity and excellent electrochemical cycling stability and
outperform all the reported 2D-CP-based anode materials.
To investigate the electrochemical redox reaction me-
chanism, cyclic voltammetry (CV) measurement was per-
formed first. As shown in Figure S8, in the first cycle, the CV
curves are different from the subsequent cycles, which can be
related to the formation of SEI layers in both CPs 1 and 2. In
the subsequent scans, two apparent catholic peaks at 0.68 and
1.30 V, as well as two anodic peaks at 1.49 and 1.92 V are
observed for 1 (Figure 4(a)), coinciding well with the gal-
vanostatic charge-discharge profiles. The former pair of re-
dox peaks can be clearly attributed to the redox process
between Co2+ and Co0, while the latter redox peaks result
from lithiation and delithiation of the carboxylate groups
[43]. For 2, a reversible delithiation potential was remained
at 1.47 V (Figure 4(b)). Lithiation process took place at 0.61
and 1.28 V, indicating that similar two-step redox reactions
as that in 1 are happening during the discharging process.
The results of CV and galvanostatic charge-discharge
measurements have demonstrated the two-step lithiation/
delithiation redox processes in the metal centres and carbo-
nyl groups. To further confirm the electrochemical reaction
mechanism, we tracked the change of valence and chemical
bonding state of electrode materials during discharging/
charging processes by ex-situ XPS experiments. The two
typical characteristic peaks at 781.3 and 797.2 eV corre-
spond to Co 2p1/2 and Co 2p3/2 in Co2+; the two main peaks at
856.4 and 873.6 eV can be assigned to Ni 2p1/2 and Ni 2p3/2 in
Ni2+ (Figure 4(c, d)). The signals at 785.1, 801.7 eV, for Co
2p, and 860.9 and 879.5 eV for Ni 2p are satellite peaks.
After being fully discharged, the characteristic Co 2p peaks
shift toward 778.3 and 793.0 eV and the characteristic Ni 2p
peaks shift toward 852.2 and 870.1 eV, confirming the ex-
istence of Co0 and Ni0 (Figure 4(e, f)) [44]. The C 1s and O
1s spectra were also investigated to study the redox in-
volvement of the organic ligand during lithiation-delithiation
processes (Figures S9 and S10). The C 1s and O 1s spectra
peak shifts and conversions of CPs 1 and 2 are analogous on
account of the identical organic moieties. The C1s spectra
after Li-ions insertion process can be divided into three peaks
at (Figure S9(c, d)), i.e., 284.6 eV for the C=C bond of the
pyrazine ring, 285.9 eV for carboxyl groups, and 289.8 eV
for C–C bond of the enol structures, respectively [45]. The
results indicate that the carboxyl groups of pztc4− trans-
formed into the enol structures after discharging process. In
the O 1s spectra of the discharged electrodes (Figure S10(c,
d)), the peaks at 529.6 (or 529.4) and 531.1 eV are attributed
to the lattice oxygen and the Li–O bond [46]. In addition,
theoretical studies and electron paramagnetic resonance
(EPR) measurements have concluded that the N atoms on the
aromatic ring can participate in the electrochemical redox
reaction during cycling [18,19], as observed in the Zn-ODCP
Based on the above observations and discussions, the re-
markable LIBs performances of two CPs are achieved by the
synergistic Li-storage reactions of metal ions and organic
linkers (Figure S11).
But obviously, the electrochemical performance of 1 is
much better than that of 2, which could be ascribed to the
coordination affinity difference to organic ligands as well as
the electrochemical property of the metal ions [50]. The
performance inferiority of 2 over 1 could result from the
following reasons: (1) Ni2+ has a larger ion radius than Co2+,
leading to stronger steric hindrance in 2 toward Li-ions; (2)
the Li-ions migration kinetics of 2 after 150 discharge-charge
cycles is lower than that of 1 (Figures S12 and S13); (3) the
calculated b-values of the anodic and cathodic peaks for 2
(0.56, 0.61) indicate a relatively weak surface-controlled
capacitive contribution to total capacity when compared with
1 (Figure S14).
Structural stability is a significant characteristic of CPs or
MOFs as electrode materials during the electrochemical re-
actions. SEM, PXRD and FT-IR measurements were con-
ducted to analyse the chemical and structural durability of
the active materials after the cycling test. From the SEM
images, PXRD patterns and FT-IR spectra, the active mate-
rials after 10 cycles can maintain chemical and structural