4
E. Avilés et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. xxx (2015) xxx–xxx
coli LPS-activated microglia TXB2 and OÀ2 generation in vitro. OÀ2
and TXB2 release, as well as short term cell viability, were assessed
as described in the Supplementary data. As shown in Table 3,
Table 2
In vitro antimycobacterial and antiplasmodial activities of compounds 3–8
Compound MABA MICa
g/mL)
3D7
Cytotoxicity
IC50 (nM)
Selectivity
indexc (SI)
(
l
IC50 SEb
(nM)
a
-acylamino amides 4, 5 and 8 (based on the isonicotinic acid
pharmacophore only) inhibited TXB2 generation with IC50’s = 3.0,
0.1 and 1.1 M, respectively, demonstrating minimal effect on
OÀ2 release (IC50 > 10
M) and minimal short-term toxicity
(LDH50 > 10 M). In contrast, 6 and 7, the only derivatives prepared
based on the aminoquinoline pharmacophore, potently inhibited
TXB2 generation (IC50 = 0.8 and 0.9
M, respectively) and O2À
release (IC50 = 1.7 and 5.0 M, respectively), but with evidence of
short-term toxicity (LDH50 = 5.0 M). Thus, in our in vitro
3
3.2
1.2 0.00004 99735
11.5 0.0027 19788
13.0 0.0034 49173
11.1 0.0006 28560
3.6 0.0003 25753
6.3 0.0005 NT
83112
1721
3782
2573
7154
—
l
4
14.9
56.4
17.9
52.0
101.8
—
l
5d
6
l
7
8
CQ
INH
l
6.6 0.0008 234470e
—
35526
—
l
0.44
—
l
a
experimental conditions, it appeared that inhibition of microglia
TXB2 generation by Ugi adducts 4, 5 and 8 resulted from a pharma-
cologic effect, in contrast with that of analogs 6 and 7 that were
toxic to the microglia cells. To summarize, comparison of the
Values are means of three experiments. Minimum inhibitory concentrations
(MIC) in g/mL.
l
b
The IC50 values are reported as means standard errors.
Selectivity index (SI) defined by the ratio: IC50 (in mammalian Vero cell lines)/
c
IC50 values of antiparasitic activity against 3D7 cell line.
d
IC50’s of starting diisocyanide 3 (IC50 ꢀ0.23
lM) and a-acylamino
Tested as a mixture of diastereomers.
Value obtained from Ref. 16. NT indicates that the compound was not tested
e
amides 4–8 supports the observation that the observed bioactivity
is mainly associated with the presence of an amphilectane
diterpenoid core bearing a C-8 isocyanide functionality. Within
the series of semi-synthetic products 4–8, analog 5 displayed the
due to insufficient material. CQ = chloroquine and INH = isoniazid (+Ctrls).
highest antineuroinflammatory activity (IC50 = 0.1
compared to 4, the least active congener bearing the isonicotinic
acid pharmacophore (IC50 = 3.0 M), the presence in 5 of a phenyl
lM), and when
of the
a-acylamino amides obtained from the U-4CC reactions
displayed potent antiplasmodial activity (IC50 values 613.0 nM)
against this strain. Compound 7, which was based on isonicotinic
acid and aminoquinoline pharmacophores, was observed to be
the most active (IC50 = 3.6 nM) of the investigated compounds,
although 8, which was based only on isonicotinic acid, was
nearly as active (IC50 = 6.3 nM) as 7. Compound 5, the only
adduct with a bulky group at C-23 that was analyzed to be a
mixture of diastereomers, was the least active against the 3D7
strain (IC50 = 13.0 nM). However, we speculate that the separa-
tion and testing of each diastereomer may result in a marked
increase in activity of one of the compounds. Inasmuch as
hybrids 4–8 showed excellent in vitro inhibitory activity (IC50
values in the range of 3.6–13.0 nM) when compared to the
standard drug CQ (IC50 = 6.6 nM), they showed more toxicity
(SI values in the range 19788–49173) than the CQ (SI = 35526).
Interestingly, our starting scaffold 3 proved to be the most
promising compound of the series (IC50 = 1.2 nM, SI = 83112),
which was 5.5 times more active and significantly less toxic than
the standard drug. When compared to 3, the observation that the
antiplasmodial activity of the new compounds is comparable to
that of the parent compound raises the question as to whether
the isocyanide group at C-15 in the natural product is responsible
for the observed activity.
l
residue at C-23 seems to further potentiate its biological activity.
On the other hand, substitution of R2 (Scheme 1) with bulkier
functional groups, as observed in compound 7, appears to lower
the activity. Moreover, comparison of the IC50’s of 4 and 8 suggests
that the presence of an isopentyl group (R2) also seems to play a
role in lowering the observed pharmacological activity. Lack of
OÀ2 inhibition in compounds 3–5 and
8 would appear to
suggest that they inhibit TXB2 synthesis through a cyclooxygenase-
dependent mechanism.
To summarize, Ugi IMCRs were used to accomplish four-compo-
nent couplings of amines, aldehydes, acids, and diisocyanide 3,
allowing for the design and construction of a small library of
a-acetylamino amides (4–8) that, while less active than isoniazid
(1), are as potent as the antimalarial drug chloroquine (2)
against the 3D7 strain of P. falciparum. All of the compounds in
our modest library exhibited IC50 values in the low nanomolar
range, with adduct
7 exhibiting the highest antiplasmodial
activity (IC50 = 3.6 nM, SI = 7154). To our delight, this hybrid was
twice as potent as chloroquine against the 3D7 strain (Table 2),
however, it showed the most toxicity. Although some general
trends related to the activities of the compounds are evident,
further exploration, including the synthesis and testing of addi-
tional compounds against multiple parasite strains with various
degrees of sensitivity and resistance, will be needed before definite
conclusions can be drawn. Notwithstanding, the results presented
herein clearly underscore the importance of isocyanide-based mul-
ticomponent reactions in antimalarial drug discovery, particularly
when combined with a rational choice of inputs based on known
antimalarial pharmacophores. Thus, hybrid approaches inspired
by natural products can lead to the rapid generation of novel
chemotypes for the development of diverse, biologically rich SAR
libraries.16 The development of new treatment strategies is of great
importance because parasitic resistance to existing antimalarial
agents is spreading rapidly. In time, this seemingly inevitable
predicament will diminish the effectiveness of the artemisinins,
the current mainstay of treatment against drug-resistant para-
sites.3 Finally, in addition to their pharmacologic effects on
enhanced TXB2 generation and their reduced cytotoxic effects, it
is perhaps of interest to note that derivatives 4–8 are more potent
inhibitors of rat microglia TXB2 generation than acetylsalicylic acid
Derivatives 4–8 along with scaffold 3 were screened further in
order to determine the effect of these compounds on Escherichia
Table 3
Antineuroinflammatory activity of compounds 3–8a
b
Compound
OÀ2 IC50
(
lM)
TXB2 IC50
(l
M)
LDH50
(
lM)
3
4
5c
6
7
8
>10
>10
>10
1.7
5.0
>10
0.23
3.0
0.1
0.8
0.9
1.1
>10
>10
>10
5.0
5.0
>10
a
Effect of compounds 3–8 on LPS-primed rat microglia PMA [1 lM]-stimulated
release of TBX2 [control release: 2555 718 pg/mL/70 min] and OÀ2 [control release:
12.6 2.4 nanomoles/70 min] and LDH. The antineuroinflammatory assay is
described in the Supplementary data. Data correspond to 1–4 independent
experiments.
b
LDH50 represents the concentration of the compound that caused 50% release of
the total LDH content of microglia cells. LDH was measured as described in the
Supplementary data.
(aspirin) (IC50 = 3.12–10.0
l
M)17,18 and flurbiprofen (apparent
IC50 = 100 nM),19 which are two clinically used NSAIDS.
c
Tested as a mixture of diastereomers.