Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
the vibrational spectra. Although the crystallographically
determined CꢁC bond lengths in the alkynyl groups of 1 and 3
are statistically indistinguishable, the CꢁC stretch of the
alkynyl ligand exhibits the same blue shift on fluorination
observed in the alkyne analogues. These data support the
suggestion that the compound is best viewed as containing
a fluorinated alkynyl ligand and that the CꢀF bond in 3 is
closely related to the fluoroalkynes.
To assess whether the stability of 3 arises from a thermo-
dynamic stabilization of the CꢀF bond, the bond dissociation
energies (BDEs) for a range of CꢀH and CꢀF bonds with sp,
2
3
sp , and sp hybridization have been calculated (see Support-
[
13]
ing Information for methodology and calibration).
The
resulting data are shown graphically in Figure 1, in which the
Scheme 3. a) DFT-calculated ((RI-)PBE0-D3/def2-TZVPP//(RI-)BP86/
SV(P) level in CH Cl (e=8.93) using the COSMO model) energies for
2
2
alkynes and their corresponding diradical dimerization products. The
data for R =R =H and R =F and R =H show good agreement with
1
2
1
2
[
5]
those previously reported. b) Calculated structure of the diradical
arising from the dimerization of 3.
Figure 1. Plot of calculated CꢀF bond dissociation energy versus
calculated CꢀH bond dissociation energy. The dotted line represents
a 1:1 relationship between the parameters. Insert shows expansion
tions observed in the metal-free analogues. This is supported
by preliminary mechanistic investigations, which showed that
ꢀ1
between 510–560 kJmol
.
°
DG298 for dimerization of the sterically less encumbered
5
model complex [Ru(CꢁCF)(h -C Me )(PH C H PH )] is
5
5
2
2
4
2
ꢀ1
dotted line represents a 1:1 relationship between CꢀH and Cꢀ + 80 kJmol , similar to that for the dimerization of FCꢁCF
2
3
ꢀ1
F BDEs. Systems with sp - and sp -hybridized bonds appear
above the line, indicating that, as expected, the CꢀF bonds in
these systems are stronger than the corresponding CꢀH
(+ 68 kJmol ). However, potential energy surface scans (at
the PBE0/def2-TZVPP//BP86/SV(P) level) suggest that when
the full dppe ligands are included, this creates a sterically
more crowded transition state for dimerization of 3, with an
bonds. However, the same trend in relative BDEs is not
predicted for compounds containing CꢁCH and CꢁCF
groups: in these cases, the calculated BDE for the CꢀH and
CꢀF bonds are essentially identical. This is also true for
ꢀ1
electronic energy barrier around 50 kJmol higher in energy
than the model system.
To rationalize the structural and spectroscopic changes
observed upon the introduction of fluorine into alkynyl
systems, the electronic structures of FCꢁCF, HCꢁCF, HCꢁ
compounds 1 and 3.
The similarity between the spectroscopic parameters and
CꢀF BDE of 3 and compounds RCꢁCF presumably indicates
5
5
CH, [Ru(h -C H )(PH ) (CꢁCF)], and [Ru(h -C H )(PH ) -
5
5
3
2
5
5
3 2
that the enhanced stability of the ruthenium-substituted
compound is not thermodynamic in nature. This is supported
by additional calculations which demonstrate that the puta-
tive diradical arising from the dimerization of 3 (Scheme 3) is
(CꢁCH)] were optimized using explicitly correlated Brueck-
[20]
ner coupled cluster theory (BCCD(T)-F12).
Brueckner
orbitals (BOs) derived from these calculations were qualita-
tively similar to the Kohn–Sham orbitals obtained from
ꢀ
1
5
thermodynamically more stable (DG298 = ꢀ18 kJmol ) than
two molecules of 3. The corresponding dimerization of 1 is
a treatment of FCꢁCF, HCꢁCF, HCꢁCH, [Ru(h -C H )-
5
5
5
(PPh ) (CꢁCF)], and [Ru(h -C H )(PPh ) (CꢁCH)] at the
3
2
5
5
3 2
ꢀ
1
thermodynamically disfavored (DG298 =+ 131 kJmol ), mir-
(RI)-PBE0/def2-TZVPP level, although the energies
obtained from the BOs were closer to those expected on
the basis of photoelectron spectroscopy giving confidence
that the resulting wavefunctions were effectively modeling
the electronic structure of the molecules (Figure 2).
[
5]
roring the behavior of alkynes RCꢁCF and RCꢁCH. We
therefore suggest that the presence of the bulky dppe and Cp*
ligands kinetically stabilize the CꢁCF linkage by inhibiting
the intermolecular dimerization and oligomerization reac-
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 1 – 7
ꢀ 2017 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!