10.1002/anie.202107947
Angewandte Chemie International Edition
COMMUNICATION
The dehydration of cis-2-McyOH shows a similar volcano-shaped
dependency of the TOF on the ionic strength and the BAS
concentration, respectively (Table 3, Figure 3 A, SI, Figure S3).
The highest TOFs are again obtained at ionic strengths between
1.51 – 2.07 mol L-1. As also in a concerted E2 dehydration
pathway, the β-H abstraction (and simultaneous C-O bond
cleavage) is the kinetically relevant step, the rate enhancement
shows that also transition states in a concerted elimination benefit
from a high ionic strength.
Figure 4 displays that all tested zeolites follow a linear correlation
between the entropy and enthalpy. Remarkably, the correlation
even falls on the same line as all other secondary alcohols
converted over various catalysts as reported recently.[18] This
reflects the significant influence of the position of the OH-group
on the overall catalytic activity (SI, Figure S18).
Furthermore, Figure 4 highlights again that an increasing ionic
strength has a different influence on the enthalpy and entropy
when following an E1 or E2 mechanism. While a pronounced
stabilization of ΔH°‡ is characteristic for the E2 mechanism
(absence of a carbenium ion), this pathway suffers from low or
even negative ΔS°‡ due to a highly ordered and multicomponent
transition state. An increasing ionic strength has, in this case, a
stronger beneficial impact on the entropy and shifts the
parameters towards a more E1-like character (Figure 4, blue
arrow). In contrast, an increasing ionic strength seems to shift an
E1 mechanism more towards E2-like parameters by reducing the
characteristic high enthalpic barrier at the expense of a lowering
in entropy (Figure 4, black arrow).
Interestingly, the drop of the reaction rates occurs at the
symmetric situation as for 4-McyOH and prior for the non-
substituted CyOH,[12] irrespective of the higher steric hindrance
through the position and orientation of the substituted group or the
mechanism pathway. ΔG°‡ is increasing for all three substrates at
the same boundary (Figure 1 B and 3 B), suggesting that the
cyclohexyl ring determines the critical size (distance) after which
the contribution of the repulsions exceeds the gain from the high
local ionic strength. The reorganization penalty seems to have a
less serve impact on the associated-complex than on the
carbenium ion intermediate. This is demonstrated by the not as
sharply decreasing volcano-plot for the E2 compared to the E1
mechanism (TOF decrease from MFI-40 to MFI-45 31 % for E2
vs. 52 % for E1).
Moreover, for the dehydration of cis-2-McyOH, the dependency of
the activation enthalpy and entropy on db-b shows an opposite
trend (Figure 3 C). The enthalpic stabilization is now increasing
for distances below 0.4 nm and above 0.6 nm, while a significant
decrease of the entropy to negative values is observed. This loss
in entropy is caused by the associated complex formed in the
transition state of the concerted elimination consisting of a proton,
the alcohol and water acting as the proton-abstracting base
(Scheme 1).
The adsorption uptake of cis-2-McyOH is reduced, in line with the
TOF decrease, after an ionic strength of 2.07 mol L-1 (SI, Figure
S17, Table S16). This isomer showed an overall lower uptake
than 4-McyOH due to its higher steric hindrance (on MFI-40: 0.34
mmol g-1 for cis-2-McyOH vs. 1.08 mmol g-1 for 4-McyOH).
Nevertheless, the dehydration of cis-2-McyOH results in more
than 2.5-fold higher TOFs (Table 1 and 3). As it was concluded
previously, the antiperiplanar arrangement of the protonated
hydroxyl group and the adjacent -H allows the cis-2-McyOH to
proceed via a concerted E2 mechanism, thereby resulting in an
increased selectivity towards the energetically more favored
Saytzeff-product (1-MCH) and simultaneously avoiding the
energetically demanding formation of a carbenium ion (SI, Table
S17).[13]
In conclusion, we investigated the impact of the concentration of
H3O+
and the intracrystalline ionic strength on the aqueous
hydr.
phase dehydration of 2- and 4-methylcyclohexanol. The increase
of the turnover frequency in the demonstrated volcano-plot is
caused by increasing local ionic strength in the zeolite pores. The
highest dehydration rates were obtained by zeolites of moderate
Si/Al ratios, i.e., on MFI-40 and MFI-60. The decrease, on the
other hand, is arising from the additional work to overcome the
strong repulsions once the void space between neighboring
hydronium ions falls below the critical distance of 0.4 nm and a
reorganization of the ion pairs is required. The position of the
maximum is consistently found regardless of the substitution or
whether the dehydration proceeds via an E1 or E2 mechanism.
The reaction pathway strongly affects the activation entropy and
enthalpy and the mode by which they are influenced by the ionic
strength. While the formation of the carbenium ion primarily
resulted in an enthalpic stabilization at high ionic strength, the
formation of the associated complex was mainly entropically
supported. The significantly higher rates for the cis-2-McyOH over
the 4-McyOH dehydration, despite the higher steric bulkiness, are
a consequence of the E2 pathway and the selective conversion
to the Saytzeff-product.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy
(DOE), Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences (BES),
Division of Chemical Sciences, Geosciences and Biosciences
(Transdisciplinary Approaches to Realize Novel Catalytic
Pathways to Energy Carriers, FWP 47319). Special gratitude is
expressed to Prof. Gary L. Haller for fruitful discussions and P.
Waligorski and P. Pfauser for their help in performing experiments.
Keywords: alcohol dehydration • cyclic alcohols • ionic strength
• volcano • zeolites
[1]
a) W. O. Haag, R. M. Lago, P. B. Weisz, Nature, 1984, 309, 589-591; b)
W. O. Haag, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 1994, 84, 1375-1394.
V. B. Kazanskii, Acc. Chem. Res., 1991, 24, 379-383.
[2]
[3]
Figure 4. Correlation of the activation entropy (ΔS°‡) and enthalpy (ΔH°‡) in the
dehydration of 4-McyOH (E1, black) and cis-2-McyOH (E2, blue).
R. Gounder, E. Iglesia, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2009, 131, 1958-1971.
4
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.