Full Paper
doi.org/10.1002/chem.202101752
Chemistry—A European Journal
information from X-ray diffraction analysis was also corrobo-
rated by a complementary group-selective STD NMR method
(GS-STD) used to map the contact points between Gal-1 and
LacNAc in solution.[59] GS-STD confirmed that the conformation
and position of the LacNAc ligand in the binding site of Gal-1 in
solution and the crystal structure are comparable.
two groups.[63] Spatial proximity of His52 to the C2’-H2’ bond
was also suggested on the basis of GS-STD measurement.[59]
Although His52 residue in the apo form of Gal-1 is predom-
inantly present in the neutral Nɛ2-H tautomer, the presence of
1
the protonated form was indicated by H-15N long-range HMQC
experiments.[64] Therefore, deoxyfluorination at C2’ could
strengthen binding to Gal-1 by dipole-dipole or dipole-ion
interaction with neutral or protonated forms of His52, respec-
tively. According to ab initio computation, dissociation energies
of N+À H···FÀ C complexes can reach up to 13.5 kcal/mol.[65]
Moreover, a similar interaction between fluorine and the two
terminal nitrogen atoms of Arg21 residue has been observed in
human neuraminidase hNeu2, trapped in the form of a covalent
intermediate with 3-fluoro-sialic acid possessing a C3 equatorial
fluorine.[66]
Both ELISA and T2 filter screening confirmed that deoxy-
fluorination of the hydroxyl groups at C6 and C3’ resulted in
ligands with the affinity comparable to the non-fluorinated
ligand for both Gal-1 and Gal-3. This is consistent with X-ray
crystallography results suggesting that C6 and C3’ hydroxyl
groups are not engaged in the hydrogen-bonding network.[63]
In this case the agreement between ELISA and T2 filter screen-
ing was only qualitative for Gal-1. In particular, 3’-fluoro
analogue 9 was about a 7-fold weaker ligand than compound 5
(6-fluoro) according to ELISA. However, binding affinities are
assay-dependent and while NMR screening reflects changes in
hydrodynamic mobility of the ligand upon binding to protein,
the ELISA-type assay is based on competition between mono-
valent fluorinated ligand in solution and multiple lactosamine
epitopes attached to asialofetuin.
The complete loss of affinity for Gal-1 corresponds to a
similar loss of affinity previously found for bovine heart
galectin-1 when probed with 4’-fluoro, and 6’-fluoro methyl β-
lactosides.[57a] It is noteworthy that LacNAcβ1-OMe retained an
approximately 2-orders of magnitude weaker but still detect-
able affinity to Gal-3 upon deoxyfluorination at the 3-, 4’- and
6’-positions (ligands 6, 8 and 7, respectively). Very weak binding
of 6, 7 and 8 to Gal-3 determined by ELISA was also
corroborated by NMR from a relative increase in R2 values upon
addition of galectins (Figure 5), underscoring the utility of this
NMR method for sensitive screening of ligand-galectin inter-
actions. Gal-3 has also been recently probed with nanoparticles
carrying deoxyfluorinated lacto-N-biose and the 6’-position has
been confirmed as critical because deoxyfluorination at C6’
abolished binding.[16]
The introduction of a highly polar CÀ F bond can strengthen
noncovalent ligand-protein interaction for example via electro-
static and dipolar interactions with cationic residues (e.g. the
guanidinium group) and protein backbone or side-chain amide
groups.[60] While this strategy to improve affinity of protein
ligands was generally exceptionally fruitful, including galectin
ligands fluorinated at aryl substituents[13,61] or polyfluorinated
carbohydrates,[62] mono-deoxyfluorinated oligosaccharides typi-
cally display similar, attenuated or abrogated affinity to lectins
in comparison with the natural ligands.[57a–d] Exceptions include
approximately 4-fold enhancement of the binding affinity of
immobilized clustered fluorinated trisaccharides NeuAcα2-3(2F) Conclusion
Galß1-4GlcNAc and NeuAcα2-3(2F)Galß1-3GlcNAc over the non-
fluorinated ligands towards adhesive protein TgMIC1 of proto-
zoan parasite Toxoplasma gondii.[15,26] In solution, however, the
fluorinated and non-fluorinated ligands gave comparable
affinities. Also, affinity enhancement reported for selected
fluorinated Galβ1-3GlcNAc (lacto-N-biose) analogues towards
Gal-3 and 7 (Figure 1) was achieved using multivalent presenta-
tion of the fluorinated ligands on nanoparticles. Here, we
observed an unprecedented approximately 8-fold affinity
enhancement for monovalent 2’-fluoro analogue 10 over the
non-fluorinated ligand 63 towards Gal-1 in solution using ELISA
(Table 3) and qualitatively corroborated by NMR screening,
which delivered the highest R2,increase value within the set of
analogues (Figure 5). This enhancement was specific for Gal-1
because the same analogue 10 binds Gal-3 with a similar
affinity to its non-fluorinated counterpart 63.
Despite the highly conserved structure of human galectins
CRDs, subtle structural differences between the binding sites of
Gal-1 and Gal-3 exist.[63] A notable difference is the presence of
the L4 loop containing His52 residue in human Gal-1, which is
absent in human Gal-3 and bovine Gal-1 and Gal-3.[58]
Interestingly, the crystal structure of Gal-1 complexed with
lactose confirmed the close spatial proximity of His52 and C2’-
OH and indicated a possible hydrogen bond between these
In summary, we reported the novel chemical synthesis of a
complete series of mono-deoxyfluorinated methyl N-acetyl-β-d-
lactosaminides and the determination of their affinity to human
galectin-1 and -3 by using 19F NMR T2 filter and ELISA. The set of
fluoro analogues displays a favorable distribution of 19F NMR
chemical shifts (Figure S1) and the results of the T2 filter assay
qualitatively correlate with the ELISA and reported X-ray
crystallography data, thus validating the T2 filtering method for
screening of other galectins with our set of fluoro analogues.
The advantage of this method is providing information on
binding of series of ligands in only one experiment. We also
showed that deoxyfluorination at the C2’ position created a
ligand with improved binding to Gal-1. To our knowledge, this
is the first mono-deoxyfluorinated oligosaccharide monovalent
ligand to exhibit significantly enhanced binding to a lectin.
Although deoxyfluorination of hydroxyls at the positions 3, 4’
and 6’ of the LacNAc scaffold led to the complete abrogation of
binding affinity to Gal-1, both analytical methods confirmed
weak binding of the respective analogues to Gal-3. We envisage
that aside from screening, binding preferences of other
galectins, analogues 5–10 may be employed to study ligand-
lectin interactions in detail by means of 19F-related saturation
transfer difference NMR experiments. This will be particularly
Chem. Eur. J. 2021, 27, 1–13
10
© 2021 Wiley-VCH GmbH
��
These are not the final page numbers!