J. I. Manchester et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 22 (2012) 5150–5156
5155
slightly diminished activity in S. aureus. Moving the methoxyl sub-
stituent to the 2-position of the pyridine (20) further increased
logD to 2.9 and produced the best overall antibacterial activity,
with MICs of <0.02 lM in S. pneumoniae and 0.098 and 0.2 lM in
the two strains of S. aureus. The relationships among antibacterial
activity, biochemical potency and hydrophobicity for these com-
pounds are summarized in Fig. 6, which shows strong correlations
between logD and the MIC/IC50 ratios for S. pneumoniae and par-
ticularly S. aureus. Because there is essentially no relationship be-
tween IC50 and logD in Table 1 for either strain, this analysis
suggests that the improvements in antibacterial activity observed
are a result of optimization of physical properties rather than
changes in potency.
The MICs of the optimized azaindoles are low compared to the
topoisomerase inhibitors novobiocin and levofloxacin, and do not
show cross-resistance with the quinolone-resistant strain of S. aur-
eus, further demonstrating that these compounds act through inhi-
bition of GyrB/ParE. Moreover, a representative azaindole did not
show an elevated MIC in a novobiocin-resistant strain of S. aureus,
in which a single mutation (T175A) was mapped to GyrB, suggest-
ing antibacterial activity through ParE, in addition to GyrB. Resis-
tance rates among the azaindoles were 610ꢀ9 at fourfold the MIC
in both S. pneumonia and S. aureus. These rates are low and similar
to those for the fluoroquinolones, known dual-targeting agents.24
Figure 6. The ratio of MIC to IC50 for S. aureus (squares) and S. pneumoniae (circles)
plotted against logD for the azaindoles in Table 1 (excluding indeterminate values).
The ratios for both species show strong correlations with logD, with S. pneumoniae
more tolerant of polarity among these compounds.
the propyl- (11) or isopropylaminocarboxamide (12) resulted in
approximately a 10-fold drop in potency. Cyclopropylaminocarb-
oxamide (13) was equivalent in S. pneumoniae but significantly
worse in S. aureus. In fact it is the only compound that showed
greater than a threefold difference in IC50 between the two iso-
zymes. This is likely due to a single amino acid difference, Ala 52
in S. pneumoniae ParE versus Ser 55 in S. aureus GyrB, which results
in a narrowing of the pocket around the amide substituent unfa-
vorable to the cyclopropyl group. Similarly, addition of a methyl
group to trifluoromethylpyrazole at the azaindole 4-position (14)
resulted in more than a 10-fold loss in potency. Antibacterial activ-
ity (MIC) also declined with increasing substitution at these
positions.
These observations, coupled with the effectively equivalent IC50s
in GyrB and ParE in Table 1, support the dual-targeting nature of
the azaindoles.
We have described the discovery of a novel scaffold for dual
inhibition of bacterial DNA gyrase and Topoisomerase IV through
virtual screening. Using structure-based design inspired by careful
analysis of the SAR of other series which bind the same pocket of
these enzymes, low-nanomolar enzymatic inhibition was rapidly
achieved. Further optimization of physical properties produced po-
tent, broad-spectrum antibacterial compounds. The dual-targeting
nature of these novel and potent compounds is expected to result
in decreased development of antibacterial resistance due to target
mutations.
At the azaindole 5-position, conversion of the nicotinic acid (10)
to nicotinamide (15) maintained biochemical potency and resulted
in a 30-fold improvement in antibacterial activity against S. pneu-
moniae. Alkylation of 15 to the acetamide 16 resulted in a further
twofold drop in MIC against S. pneumoniae, and activities of 6.25
Supplementary data
Supplementary data associated with this article can be found, in
and 12.5 lM against methicillin-sensitive and multidrug-resistant
strains of S. aureus, respectively. The improvements in antibacterial
activity among these compounds were not correlated with
improvements in potency, but rather appeared to track with
changes in their hydrophobicity as assessed by logD. Compound
10 exhibited a logD of ꢀ1.0, whereas 15 and 16 exhibited logDs
of 1.8 and 2.2, respectively. It was therefore hypothesized that
excessive polarity led to poor permeability across the cellular
envelope, limiting the antibacterial activity despite the excellent
potency of these compounds. 3-cyanopyridine was introduced at
the 5-position (17) which increased logD to 2.6. Although inhibi-
tion of enzyme activity was slightly reduced, improved MICs of
References and notes
1. Giske, C. G.; Monnet, D. L.; Cars, O.; Carmeli, Y. ReAct-Action on Antibiotic
Resistance Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2008, 52, 813.
2. Boucher, H. W.; Talbot, G. H.; Bradley, J. S.; Edwards, J. E.; Gilbert, D.; Rice, L. B.;
Scheld, M.; Spellberg, B.; Bartlett, J. Clin. Infect. Dis. 2009, 48, 1.
3. Spellberg, B.; Guidos, R.; Gilbert, D.; Bradley, J.; Boucher, H. W.; Scheld, W. M.;
Bartlett, J. G.; Edwards, J., Jr Clin. Infect. Dis. 2008, 46, 155.
4. Charifson, P. S.; Grillot, A. L.; Grossman, T. H.; Parsons, J. D.; Badia, M.; Bellon,
S.; Deininger, D. D.; Drumm, J. E.; Gross, C. H.; LeTiran, A.; Liao, Y.; Mani, N.;
Nicolau, D. P.; Perola, E.; Ronkin, S.; Shannon, D.; Swenson, L. L.; Tang, Q.;
Tessier, P. R.; Tian, S. K.; Trudeau, M.; Wang, T.; Wei, Y.; Zhang, H.; Stamos, D. J.
Med. Chem. 2008, 51, 5243.
5. Basarab, G. S.; Bist, S.; Manchester, J. I.; Sherer, B. 2008, U.S. Patent Appl. Publ.
US20080132546A1.
6. Boriack-Sjodin, A.; Carcanague, D. R.; Dussault, D. D.; Hatoum-Mokdad, H.;
Hull, K. G.; Ioannidis, G.; Manchester, J. I.; McGuire, H. M.; McKinney, D. C.;
Stokes, S. 2010, PCT Int. Appl. WO2010038081A2.
7. East, S. P.; White, C. B.; Barker, O.; Barker, S.; Bennett, J.; Brown, D.; Boyd, E. A.;
Brennan, C.; Chowdhury, C.; Collins, I.; Convers-Reignier, E.; Dymock, B. W.;
Fletcher, R.; Haydon, D. J.; Gardiner, M.; Hatcher, S.; Ingram, P.; Lancett, P.;
Mortenson, P.; Papadopoulos, K.; Smee, C.; Thomaides-Brears, H. B.; Tye, H.;
Workman, J.; Czaplewski, L. G. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 2009, 19, 894.
8. Wigley, D. B.; Davies, G. J.; Dodson, E. J.; Maxwell, A.; Dodson, G. Nature 1991,
351, 624.
3.13 and 1.56 lM against the methicillin-sensitive and multi-
drug-resistant strains of S. aureus were seen. Replacement of the
nitrile with the weakly acidic oxadiazolone hetereocycle in 18
lowered logD to 1.7, but restored biochemical potency in
S. pneumoniae ParE and improved it to <1 nM in S. aureus GyrB. This
boost in potency is likely due to improved interactions with Arg 81
and Arg 140, as the oxadiazolone extends further into the arginine
binding region. In that compound, MICs were further improved to
<0.03 lM in S. pneumoniae, and 0.4 and 1.10 lM in the sensitive
and multi-drug resistant strains of S. aureus. Incorporation of
3-oxadiazolo,4-methoxypyridine (19) restored logD to 2.3 and pre-
served biochemical and antibacterial activity in S. pneumoniae, but
9. Lafitte, D.; Lamour, V.; Tsvetkov, P. O.; Makarov, A. A.; Klich, M.; Deprez, P.;
Moras, D.; Briand, C.; Gilli, R. Biochemistry (N.Y.) 2002, 41, 7217.