E. Burchacka et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 22 (2012) 5574–5578
5575
derivatives of
a-aminophosphonate diaryl esters. They are highly
binding pocket, but also extended interactions within the S2 and
S3 pockets.11–13,17
specific towards the target serine protease and do not react
with acetylcholinesterase, cysteine proteases, or threonine prote-
ases of proteasome, and do not inhibit metallo and aspartyl prote-
ases.11–13 The design of such inactivators of serine proteases is
straightforward—the replacement of the C-terminal amino acid of
the substrate of best fit by a structurally corresponding diaryl
aminophosphonate analogue leads to generation of a potent inhib-
itor.13,14 The best substrate is the one with the highest kcat/KM sec-
ond order hydrolysis rate of the peptide bond, where the Km value
reflects only initial noncovalent binding of the substrate in the
ground state. The initial step of inhibitor binding, the formation
of a noncovalent reversible complex, is very likely similar to the
binding of the substrate. In the next step, an irreversible reaction
at the active site catalytic serine side chain nucleophile occurs.
One of the aryl ester groups leaves the phosphorus phosphonate
atom through nucleophilic substitution with a formation of the tri-
gonal bipyramid transition state, in which the leaving group occu-
pies the apical position in relation to the attacking serine
hydroxylate. The resulting mixed diester undergoes hydrolysis
(in a process called ‘complex aging’) and a final tetrahedral mono-
ester (phosphonate-O-serine) complex is formed. Such a complex
resembles the transition state tetrahedral intermediate observed
during peptide bond hydrolysis by serine proteases. Therefore, a
complex of phosphonate-based inhibitors with serine protease is
extremely stable, with a half-life of hydrolysis in the range of a
few hours to a few days.12,13 The second order inhibition rate con-
stant is the function of the initial noncovalent binding (Ki) and the
rate of the irreversible step (k2). Although its relation to Ki is evi-
dent and substrate mapping provides sufficient data for the inhib-
itors design, the influence of k2 is more complex and depends on
phosphorus atom electrophilicity. The Ki of phosphonate type
inhibitors are not identical to the substrate KM due to the fact that
they are structurally different. The irreversible step (k2) represents
the energy of activation for the phosphonylation reaction of serine-
Oꢀ or stabilization of TS (transition state) for such a reaction—
trigonal bipyramid. Such stabilization is provided by interaction
with enzyme and by the electrophilicity of the phosphorus atom
of the phosphonate molecule. The phosphorus atom of the inhibi-
tor should possess some basic electrophilicity, since phosphonic
dialkyl esters are devoid of reactivity with serine proteases.11–13
The introduction of some electrowithdrawing substituents within
the phenyl ester ring, such as NO2, SO2CH3, COOR, significantly in-
creases the electrophilic character of the phosphorus leading to ex-
tremely potent irreversible inhibitors of serine proteases.15,16
However, increased electrophilicity results in decreased stability
and higher susceptibility to water hydrolysis, which excludes them
from practical application.
Herein, we present the first synthetic procedure for the genera-
tion of 1-aminophosphonate diaryl esters—phosphonic analogues
of glutamine and their peptidyl derivatives; structures which were
based on the optimal SplB substrate sequence (Glu-Leu-Gln/P3-P2-
P1). In addition to our synthetic approach, we determined the
inhibitory activity of these novel compounds against the SplB pro-
tease, including simple Cbz-protected phosphonates as well as
their peptidyl derivatives.
The rate of SplB protease (100 nM, expressed and purified as
previously described8) inhibition was measured in 0.1 M Tris–
HCl, 0.01% Triton X-100 buffer (pH 7.6) at 37 °C. The inhibition of
chymotrypsin (3 nM, Sigma–Aldrich, Poznan, Poland) and subtili-
sin (5 nM, Sigma–Aldrich, Poznan, Poland) was me assured in
0.1 M HEPES, 0.5 M NaCl, 0.03% Triton X-100 buffer (pH 7.5) at
37 °C. The enzymes were assayed using fluorogenic substrates:
Ac-Trp-Glu-Leu-Gln-ACC (10
lM, SplB, Ex. 355 nm, Em. 460 nm)
and Suc-Ala-Ala-Pro-Phe-AMC (5
lM, chymotrypsin and subtilisin,
Ex. 350 nm, Em. 460, Calbiochem, Merck, Warszawa, Poland). The
calculated Michaelis constant (KM) values for SplB, chymotrypsin
and subtilisin were 135 lM, 70 lM, and 60 lM, respectively.
The kinetics of SplB protease inhibition was determined by
addition of the enzyme into the solution of the substrate and inhib-
itor tested ([E]0 << [I]0) according to the following mechanism:
k2
E þ I ꢀ EI ! Ei
ð1Þ
Ki
where Ki is the reversible enzyme-inhibitor complex (EI) dissocia-
tion constant, and k2 is the rate of irreversible complex (Ei) forma-
tion. The observed rate of inhibition was determined by the
progress curve method using the following (Eq. 2):
lnð½Pꢁ1 ꢀ ½PꢁtÞ ¼ ln½Pꢁ1 ꢀ kobs
t
ð2Þ
where [P]1 is the product concentration at the end of the reaction,
[P]t is the product concentration at time t and kobs is a pseudo-first-
order rate constant.18 Control curves in the absence of the inhibitor
were linear at the evaluated conditions. For derivatives showing an
inhibitory activity of less than 50% at 200
lM concentration we pre-
sumed a k2/Ki value <10 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1. For inhibitors displaying a mini-
mum 50% activity at 200 lM concentration kinetic parameters
(kobs, Ki and k2/Ki) were examined according to the (Eq. 3)18
:
k2
Ki
kobs
½Iꢁ
¼
ð3Þ
½Sꢁ
½Iꢁ
1 þ K þ K
m
i
All measurements were performed using a Spectra Max Gemini
XPS spectrofluorometer (Molecular Devices, USA) at 37 °C.
The synthesis of phosphonic diaryl ester analogues of
glutamine (Scheme 1) started with the preparation of a 4-oxo-
N-tritylbutanamide. Briefly, the succinic anhydride (1) was
suspended in methanol and was refluxed for 3 h until a single spot
appeared on TLC.19 After the reaction was completed the volatile
products were evaporated. The resulting mono-methyl hydrogen
succinate (2) was used directly in the next step without further
purification. Coupling of triphenylmethylamine with mono-methyl
hydrogen succinate was performed in acetonitrile using HBTU as
the coupling agent in the presence of triethylamine leading to
the methyl 4-oxo-4-(tritylamino)butanoate (3). The reduction of
an ester group of 3 was achieved by the application of lithium
borohydride leading to 4-hydroxy-N-tritylbutanamide (4). Further
oxidation of 4-hydroxy-N-tritylbutyryloamid was performed
under Swern conditions leading to 4-oxo-N-tritylbutanamide (5).
Compound 5 was used as the starting material for the synthesis
of all 1-aminoalkylphosphonate diaryl esters presented in this
study.
Although the influence of the electrowithdrawing character on
the increased overall inhibition could be clearly noticed,15,16 the
electrodonating substituents could, in some cases, induce the per-
fect fitting of the phosphoryl oxygen to the oxyanion hole and in-
crease the electrophilicity of the phosphorous atom by a ‘steric’
and not ‘electronic’ effect. In another words, the substituent on
the phenyl ester ring could stabilize TS for the phosphonylation
reaction and increase k2/Ki despite its electrodonating character.
Distinguishing the effect of each of these two factors is difficult
and its understanding requires further studies.
Additionally, when the chemical stability of the 1-amin-
oalkylphosphonate diaryl esters and their outstanding selectivity
of action, together with the stability of enzyme-inhibitor complex,
are taken into consideration, it is clear that these compounds rep-
resent a perfect tool to study the role of the SplB protease in vivo.
In order to effectively inactivate a target protease, several types
of short distance interactions are required that include not only the
optimal structural fit of the P1 residue of the inhibitor into the S1