COMMUNICATION
DOI: 10.1002/chem.201201532
Catalytic Enantioselective tert-Aminocyclization by Asymmetric Binary Acid
Catalysis (ABC): Stereospecific 1,5-Hydrogen Transfer
Liujuan Chen, Long Zhang, Jian Lv, Jin-Pei Cheng, and Sanzhong Luo*[a]
Initially disclosed in the 1970s and remaining largely ig-
nored in the following decades,[1] the tert-amino effect and
its related transformations have now been recognized in the
pursuit of selective activation and functionalization of rela-
3
À
À
tively inert C H bonds, particularly sp C H bonds. In this
regard, intramolecular tert-aminocyclization, a redox-neutral
process involving a 1,n-hydride transfer, represents an intri-
3
À
Scheme 1. Activation of sp C H through 1,5-H transfer/ring closure pro-
cess.
guing cascade sp3 C H activation/C X formation process
for the synthesis of heterocyclic compounds.[2] Recently,
both Lewis and Brønsted acids have been shown to promote
this previous thermal process with greatly improved activity
and synthetic applicability.[3] In light of its atom and redox
economy as well as its significant synthetic potential, as in
the asymmetric synthesis of PNU-286607,[4] the development
of catalytic enantioselective tert-aminocyclization has been
frequently attempted, with successes reported only recently.
In 2009, Seidel and co-workers reported the first catalytic
enantioselective tert-aminocyclization reaction using a chiral
magnesium complex.[5] Chiral metal complexes such as
cobalt[6] and gold complexes[7] as well as chiral organocata-
lysts such as diphenylprolinol[8] and phosphoric acids[9] were
subsequently developed as chiral catalysts for this transfor-
mation. Despite those advances, the development of new
asymmetric catalysts is still highly desirable for further im-
provements in activity, stereoselectivity, and applicability.
The mechanistic details of tert-aminocyclization remain
À
À
garding the enantioselective catalytic process, however,
there is currently no experimental information about the
proton transfer pathway nor its stereochemical features. It
also remains unclear how a rate-limiting 1,5-H transfer dic-
À
tates the subsequent stereocenter-generating C X bond for-
mation step. Elucidation of these mechanistic details would
certainly facilitate the exploration of distinctive new designs
in asymmetric catalysts.
We have recently been developing chiral Brønsted acids,
such as chiral monophosphoric acid, as dual ligands and acid
catalysts for metal catalysis.[11] This binary catalytic system
synergistically integrates chiral Brønsted acids and metal
catalysts, leading to mutually enhanced acidity/electrophilici-
ty and multiple sites for substrate binding due to their weak
coordinating behavior. These features, together with combi-
natorial flexibility, inspired us to explore this binary acid
strategy in the hitherto less developed asymmetric tert-ami-
nocyclization reaction. Herein we present our initial efforts
in this regard, which allowed us not only to identify a re-
markably effective and selective binary acid catalyst, but to
disclose interesting mechanistic features regarding 1,5-H
transfer and the mode of stereocontrol.
We started with chiral phosphoric acid as the selected
Brønsted acid ligand in the cyclization of 1a. Previously,
Akiyama and colleagues reported that the sole use of chiral
phosphoric acid was successful in promoting the reaction of
acyclic tertiary amines with good enantioselectivity at high
temperature.[9] Unfortunately, the reaction with cyclic terti-
ary amines gave rather low enantioselectivity (e.g.,
<10% ee for 1a). In our studies, it was found that chiral
phosphoric acid alone could not catalyze the reactions of
cyclic tertiary amine 1a (Table 1, entry 1). The combination
of chiral phosphoric acid 2a with various Lewis acids was
then examined (Table 1). To our delight, the combined use
of Lewis acids and 2a resulted in smooth reactions with ac-
tivity similar to, or even better than, that with Lewis acid
alone (e.g., Table 1, entries 5 versus 22) under ambient tem-
perature. Among the many different Lewis acids screened,
obscure, particularly regarding the catalytic asymmetric pro-
cesses for this appealing redox-neutral sp C H bond activa-
tion reaction. It is known that tert-aminocyclization involves
a rate-limiting 1,5-H transfer and subsequent stereocenter-
3
À
[1,2]
À
generating C X bond formation (Scheme 1).
This mecha-
nistic feature poses an intriguing challenge in controlling
a likely stereoselective 1,5-H transfer as initially proved by
Reinhoudt et al.[10] in the thermal cyclization of chiral terti-
ary amines and recently verified by Akiyama et al.[9] in
chiral phosphoric acid catalyzed tert-aminocyclization. Re-
[a] L. Chen,+ Dr. L. Zhang,+ Dr. J. Lv, Prof. J.-P. Cheng, Prof. S. Luo
Beijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences (BNLMS)
CAS Key Laboratory of Molecular Recognition and Function
Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences
Beijing 100190 (P.R. China)
Fax : (+86)10-62554449
[+] These authors contributed equally to this work.
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW
Chem. Eur. J. 2012, 00, 0 – 0
ꢀ 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
1
&
ÞÞ
These are not the final page numbers!