Angewandte
Chemie
Lindlar reduction,[24] the desired cyclization precursor 10 was
obtained. X-ray crystallographic analysis[25] of this intermedi-
ate confirmed that the coupling step involved the addition of
the amide nitrogen atom (11!21) and not the pyrrole
nitrogen atom. When the Z olefin 10 was subjected to
a variety of Lewis and Brønsted acids, a deep-red solution
was formed immediately; upon addition of water, nucleo-
philic attack occurred regioselectively at C5, thus delivering
carbinolamine 24 a single diastereomer. When the deep-red
solution was treated with EtOH, the corresponding ethoxy
carbinolamine was formed (not shown). Formation of the
C ring was quite facile because complete conversion occurred
within 5 minutes; this ring formation also delivered three
contiguous stereocenters with the relative configuration
corresponding to the agelastatins and nagelamide J. Mecha-
nistically, this process occurs either through a 5-exo-trig
cyclization involving nucleophilic addition of the imidazolone
moiety to the N-acyliminium moiety of 13 or through
a Nazarov 4p electrocyclization of pentadienyl cation 14,
which is an alternative resonance form of 13, involving the
pseudoaromatic imidazolone.[17] However, the second cycli-
zation, which was envisioned to complete the synthesis and
involves nucleophilic addition of the pyrrole nitrogen atom to
C7 of the a,b-unsaturated N-acyliminium 23, did not proceed
under a variety of reaction conditions, including prolonged
reaction times, addition of non-nucleophilic bases, or expo-
sure to elevated temperatures. Under most reaction condi-
tions, the dark-red intermediate, which is presumably the acyl
iminium 23, was easily regenerated from 24 with both Lewis
and Brønsted acids. This intermediate persisted until a nucle-
ophile, for example water or methanol, was added; in the case
of water being the nucleophile, carbinolamine 24 was
reisolated. Conformational analysis of intermediate 23 sug-
recyclization. Attempted cyclizations with alternative sub-
strates revealed that the absence of the Tse group and the
presence of both the unprotected OH group at C5 and the
bromine substituent at C13 of the pyrrole ring of 25 were
essential for successful cyclization.
We were intrigued by the observed intense red color
during the first cyclization event (10!24); this color change
occurs immediately upon addition of acid even at low
temperature. Given the absorption of light in the visible
region, we suspected that the color may be due to a charge-
transfer complex involving the N-acyliminium intermediate
23. We used time-dependent density functional theory
(TD-DFT) calculations incorporating B3LYP and X3LYP
hybrid functionals to analyze excited states of this charged
intermediate and simpler substructures.[29] We compared
these values with those extracted from experimental UV/
Vis spectra of this colored intermediate and related simpler
substructures. These studies revealed that the red color of
intermediate 23, is likely due to a p!p* transition between
the HOMO, which is composed mostly of orbital contribu-
tions from the bromopyrrole amide moiety, and the LUMO,
which is composed mostly of orbital contributions from the
N-acyliminium moiety (Figure 1).
In summary, we accomplished a concise total synthesis of
agelastatin A (1) through two sequential, potentially biomim-
etic, cyclizations. The described sequential assembly of the C
and B rings provides evidence for the proposed reactivity of
a linear alkenyl imidazolone pyrrole, which leads to the
agelastatins; the strategy complements other approaches to
agelastatin that involve initial B-ring followed by C-ring
formation.[5] C-ring formation, which sets three contiguous
centers in a highly diastereoselective fashion, led to a reaction
mixture with an intense red color, which we propose
originates from a p!p* transition between the HOMO and
LUMO of N-acyliminium intermediate 23, a hypothesis,
which is supported by TD-DFT calculations. The final B-ring
ꢀ
gests that the C6 C7 olefin is out of plane with respect to the
N-acyliminium moiety by approximately 258, thus resulting in
a low degree of conjugation, which in turn is responsible for
the low electrophilicity at C7.[26] This analysis may also
explain why intermolecular addition of nucleophiles occurs
exclusively at the more electrophilic C5 carbon atom. More-
over, DFT calculations predict that products arising from
nucleophilic trapping at C7 were energetically disfavored by
approximately 2 kcalmolꢀ1 relative to those obtained upon
trapping at C5.[27]
An alternative strategy to form the final B ring from
bicyclic intermediate 24, would be a transient base-induced
opening of the cyclic urea (D ring) to a cyclopentenone
followed by an aza-Michael addition and reformation of the
cyclic urea. Interestingly, several previous syntheses of
agelastatin A that required late-stage B-ring closure
involved an enone intermediate, thus bolstering this idea
further.[6a,h,i,k,o,q] The Tse protecting group on one of the urea
nitrogen atoms was removed to enable greater conforma-
tional mobility and thus facilitate D-ring cleavage. After
much experimentation, we serendipitously found that bicyclic
intermediate 25 is readily converted into agelastatin A on
silica gel[28] under solvent-free conditions with mild heating.
4,5-Bis-epi-agelastatin A (26) was observed as a byproduct of
the cyclization and presumably arises from a retro-Nazarov
reaction or a retro-5-exo-trig ring opening followed by
Figure 1. Calculated HOMO and LUMO of the red-colored N-acylimi-
nium 23 and the p!p* transition, which based on TD-DFT calcula-
tions is proposed to be responsible for this color. Isovalue for
surface=0.04.
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2012, 51, 1 – 5
ꢀ 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!