.
Angewandte
Communications
rearrangement involves the migration of only one of the
diastereotopic methyl groups (TS-1).[13] However, when we
attempted the same rearrangement using cis-b-lactone 9b as
the starting material, only 9b was recovered (Scheme 1B),
thus indicating the crucial role of the phenyl group in 9a in
facilitating the rearrangement under the reaction conditions.
This result necessitated further investigation of the dyotropic
rearrangement of a-methyl-cis-b-lactones before it could be
used for the preparation of biologically active natural
products such as the xanthanolides. Herein we describe our
efforts in identifying reaction conditions for expanding the
substrate scope of this stereospecific rearrangement; this
methodology provided a foundation for the collective total
syntheses[14] of the naturally occurring xanthanolides (1–7) as
well as their unnatural analogues.
Toward evaluating the aforementioned transformation
using a model compound that is relevant to the total synthesis
of the xanthanolides, we commenced our studies by synthesiz-
ing enantioenriched b-lactone 9c by employing two organo-
catalytic reactions, one of which was developed by the
research group of MacMillan and the other by the research
group of Nelson (see the Supporting Information for
details).[15,16] Satisfyingly, the X-ray crystallographic analysis
g-butyrolactone 10c was obtained in 67% yield by using
a stoichiometric amount of TiCl4, although the product was
contaminated by an inseparable unidentified byproduct
(Table 1, entry 2). Ultimately, we found that when 9c was
treated with EtAlCl2 for 5 minutes at room temperature in
either CH2Cl2 or toluene 10c was obtained as the predom-
inant product (Table 1, entries 3 and 4). Surprisingly, the
reaction was complete within a short period of time and
reducing the reaction time to 2 minutes led to 10c being
isolated in 85% yield (Table 1, entry 5). Several other
aluminum Lewis acids were examined: whereas Et2AlCl
was as effective in mediating the reaction as EtAlCl2 (Table 1,
entry 6), a sluggish reaction was observed when Et3Al was
used. Specifically, when 9c was treated with Et3Al for 3 hours,
10c was isolated in 42% yield and the substrate 9c was
recovered in 48% yield (Table 1, entry 7). In sharp contrast,
the use of AlCl3 led to complete decomposition of 9c (Table 1,
entry 8), thus indicating that the nature of the organoalumi-
num Lewis acid is crucial for the rearrangement. When the
reaction temperature was reduced to À408C, the rate of the
reaction was lower and hence a reaction time of 4 hours was
required to achieve full conversion of 9c (Table 1, entry 9).
The use of a catalytic amount of EtAlCl2 was also effective,
although a longer reaction time was required and 10c was
isolated in lower yield than the reaction wherein a stoichio-
metric amount of EtAlCl2 was used (Table 1, entry 10 versus
entry 5). To the best of our knowledge, there is no precedent
for the organoaluminum-promoted dyotropic rearrangement
of b-lactones.[18] Importantly, compound 10c was isolated as
a single diastereomer, the structure of which was determined
unambiguously by X-ray crystallography.[17]
The scope of the EtAlCl2-mediated Wagner–Meerwein-
type dyotropic rearrangement was investigated with respect
to various cis-b-lactones (Table 2). Enantiopure b-lactones
9d–9 f were converted into the corresponding trans-fused
[5.3.0] bicycles 10d–10 f in good yields (Table 2, entries 1–3);
notably, 10 f only differs from 8, the key intermediate toward
the xanthanolides, by the absence of a methyl group. The
rearrangement of 9g also proceeded smoothly to afford
tricycle 10g (Table 2, entry 4). Moreover, [4.3.0] bicyclic
compound 10h was obtained in 82% yield from b-lactone 9h,
suggesting that this protocol has the potential to construct
polycyclic systems other than [5.3.0] bicycles (Table 2,
entry 5).[19] The superiority of EtAlCl2 over MgBr2 in
promoting the current reaction of a-methyl-cis-b-lactones
was evident again in the successful conversion of 9b into 10b
in quantitative yield under the optimized conditions (Table 2,
entry 6 versus Scheme 1B). In the case of b-lactone 9i, the
phenyl group migrated in the transformation, thus furnishing
10i in 78% yield (Table 2, entry 7). Most interestingly, a pair
of diastereomers, cis-b-lactones 9j and 9k, underwent methyl
migration and 2-phenylethyl migration, respectively, to form
the corresponding trisubstituted g-butyrolactones 10j and
10k, respectively (Table 2, entries 8 and 9), thus demonstrat-
ing that this reaction is stereospecific. In addition to a-methyl
cis-b-lactones, a a-ethyl-cis-b-lactone, 9l, also underwent the
EtAlCl2-mediated rearrangement, thus affording 10l in 76%
yield (Table 2, entry 10).
À
of 9c confirmed the antiperiplanar relationship of the C5 C6
s bond and the C4 O s bond (see scheme in Table 1).[17] If the
À
conformation of the transition state structure of the dyotropic
reaction of 9c is similar to the solid-state conformation of 9c,
À
we anticipate that the migration of the C5 C6 s bond would
À
À
be more favored than that of the C5 C10 and C5 H s bonds,
thus affording g-butyrolactone 10c as the major product.
Encouraged by this rationalization, we screened various
Lewis acids that we thought could facilitate the rearrange-
ment; among these, the use of MgBr2 (Table 1, entry 1),
Zn(OTf)2, In(OTf)3, Yb(OTf)3, and TMSOTf failed to
promote the desired transformation and led to recovery of
the starting material or substantial decomposition. Pleasingly,
Table 1: Optimization of reaction conditions for the dyotropic rear-
rangement of 9c into 10c.[a]
Entry
Lewis acid
Solvent/T
t
Yield [%][b]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
MgBr2
TiCl4
Et2O, RT
12 h
1 h
0[c]
67[d]
73
75
85
CH2Cl2, RT
CH2Cl2, RT
toluene, RT
toluene, RT
toluene, RT
toluene, RT
toluene, RT
toluene, À408C
toluene, RT
EtAlCl2
EtAlCl2
EtAlCl2
Et2AlCl
AlEt3
AlCl3
EtAlCl2
EtAlCl2
5 min
5 min
2 min
2 min
3 h
3 h
4 h
1.5 h
81
42[e]
0[c]
70
9
10[f]
67
[a] [9c]=0.025m (0.3 mmol), 1.1 equiv Lewis acid. [b] Yields after
column chromatography. [c] Substrate 9c decomposed. [d] Yield deter-
mined by NMR analysis using mesitylene as internal standard. [e] Sub-
strate 9c was recovered in 48% yield. [f] 0.2 equiv Lewis acid was used.
2
ꢀ 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2012, 51, 1 – 6
These are not the final page numbers!